Yahoo Finance 5 Signs the Envelope Challenge Will Never Work for You
No matter how tried and true some budgeting methods are for some people — there are some that might never be your cup of tea.
Check Out: 5 Frugal Habits of Mark Cuban
Learn More: How To Get $340 Per Year in Cash Back on Gas and Other Things You Already Buy
“The Envelope Challenge is a classic savings method, but it has its drawbacks,” said Nischay Rawal, a certified public accountant and founder of NR Tax & Consulting.
“Carrying cash around can be inconvenient and even risky,” he noted.
“With more stores going cashless, this method becomes less practical. Additionally, remembering to fill and manage envelopes consistently requires a level of discipline that not everyone can maintain over time.”
Below, more experts offer signs that this particular method won’t ever work for you — and what you can try instead.
You Hate Relying on Cash
“The Envelope Challenge, while popular for its simplicity, may not suit everyone’s lifestyle or financial habits,” said Jeff Mains, finance expert and founder of Champion Leadership Group.
“The Envelope Challenge requires carrying cash, which is increasingly impractical as more stores move towards cashless transactions.
“Many people find it inconvenient to withdraw cash regularly and prefer the ease of digital payments.”
Explore More: 6 Things the Middle Class Should Sell To Build Their Savings
You Can’t Keep Up With the Discipline and Consistency
“This method demands a high level of discipline and consistency in filling the envelopes and tracking spending,” Mains said. “If you’re someone who struggles with regular habits or tends to forget, this can be a significant hurdle.”
You Have Security Concerns
Keeping large amounts of cash at home can be risky, Mains continued.
“There’s always the potential for loss, theft, or damage, which can make this method less secure compared to digital alternatives.”
Dalton Tigner, agent at Tigner Insurance & Associates, noted the same.
“The Envelope Challenge can indeed be a tough one to stick to in today’s largely digital and cashless society. Carrying cash around isn’t just inconvenient — it can also be unsafe.”
It’s Inconvenient
“Managing physical envelopes can be cumbersome and less adaptable to sudden changes in financial situations,” Mains noted. “For instance, if you need to adjust your budget quickly, reassigning money between envelopes can be inconvenient.”
Tigner agreed, “With more and more retailers going cashless, finding places to actually use your cash can be a challenge in itself.”
It’s Too Inflexible for You
On another note, Mains said The Envelope Challenge is rigid and doesn’t easily accommodate unexpected expenses.
“If an emergency arises, you might find it challenging to reallocate funds promptly.”
Here’s What To Try Instead
“From my experience helping small businesses manage their finances, I’ve seen clients benefit immensely from switching to digital budgeting tools,” Tigner said. “Using an app like YNAB (You Need A Budget) can automate expense tracking and categorization, saving you time and reducing manual errors.
“For example, one client I worked with saw a notable 15% increase in their savings within just three months after switching to a digital budgeting app. It was easier for them to track their spending in real-time and adjust their habits accordingly.”
Mains agreed, “Apps like YNAB (You Need a Budget) or PocketGuard provide a more modern approach to budgeting.
“They automatically track expenses, categorize spending and offer real-time updates, making it easier to manage finances without the need for cash.”
Another effective method Tigner has seen work is the 52-Week Savings Challenge integrated with online banking tools.
“This method is straightforward: you start by saving a small amount each week, incrementing it by an additional dollar each week. By the end of the year, not only have you saved a substantial amount, but you’ve also ingrained a habit of saving.”
He said this method works particularly well because it leverages the psychological principle of gradual habit formation and doesn’t overwhelm the saver.
Mains also recommended setting up automated transfers to your savings account on payday.
“This ensures you save a predetermined amount before you have the chance to spend it. Apps like Digit or Qapital can help with this by analyzing your spending habits and transferring small, manageable amounts to your savings.”
Experts also advocated for trying goal-based savings accounts.
“Many banks now offer the option to create sub-savings accounts for different goals,” Mains said. “This digital approach mimics the envelope method but offers the flexibility and security of online banking. You can easily allocate funds towards specific goals without dealing with cash.”
While traditional methods like the Envelope Challenge have their merits, Tigner stated that modern tools and techniques often offer the same benefits without the hassle.
“By utilizing budgeting apps or structured, incremental savings challenges, you can streamline your savings process and make it more suitable for today’s digital environment.”
More From GOBankingRates
6 Things to Try This Week if You're Behind on Your Savings Goals
4 Reasons Retired Women Need More Money Than Men -- And What To Do About it
This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com: 5 Signs the Envelope Challenge Will Never Work for You
