Why the Days of Stock Picking May Be Ending



Another woeful year for active managers is coming to a close, sparking concerns that the day of the stock picker is over.

Just as in 2011, only about 1 in 5 active managers are beating their benchmarks in a year marked by the same type of headline volatility caused by events in Europe and fiscal concerns closer to home.

While the advantage of passive over active is nothing new, the near-record level of futility is, and the cracks are beginning to show.

"Clearly it's been a tough couple of years for active," said Gary Flam, portfolio manager at Bel Air Investment Advisors in Los Angeles. "For investors, you really have to have a forward-looking view."

That means investors will have to shrug off recent results and count on the importance of having advisers who can see through the fog of politically driven markets with tight correlations, where all asset classes essentially move together up and down. (Read More: Goldman to Clients: Brace for Another 8% Drop in S&P)

Those correlations make it much more difficult to have a diversified portfolio - and add further challenges to active managers to match returns of passive funds that simply follow popular indexes.

"The market is being driven by macro factors," Flam said. "So most professional advisors have a background in evaluating companies, industries, economies. It's not in politics, and politics is what dominating the markets over the last couple of years."

So as active managers struggle, investors have flocked to products more tied either to broader indexes like the Standard & Poor's 500 (^GSPC), or to specialized sub-indexes that track sectors such as energy, financials or consumer stocks.

Actively managed funds make up 16.4 percent of all mutual fund assets, a number that has surged by two-thirds over the past decade and by 44 percent over the past five years, according to Strategas Research Partners.

The $1.256 trillion exchange-traded fund market includes a handful of actively managed products but is mostly concentrated in the passive space. Assets have jumped 18.3 percent this year and the amount of funds has increased 5 percent, according to XTF.

It's no surprise why investors have turned to passive investing.

"The active managers who beat the market are more tactical-oriented and they tend to be more concentrated and they put larger positions in particular sectors. The problem with that is, if they're wrong they get hit more," said Nadav Baum, executive vice president at BPU Investment Management in Pittsburgh, Pa.

"It's a lot easier for the average retail investor to go out there and buy a basket of ETFs and have a broad-based market exposure. With this explosion of ETFs you can then spike out into other sectors and do your own tactical management."

  • For more on the active vs. passive discussion, check out CNBC's "Closing Bell at 3:15 pm ET.

To be sure, the strategy is not fool-proof.

The classic catch to the passive side, according to active managers, is that buying and holding only works until the inevitable bursting of asset bubbles.

Some believe the stock market, spurred on at virtually every step by cheap money from the Federal Reserve and its $2.9 trillion balance sheet, is in a major bubble that soon will pop. (Read More: 'Fiscal Cliff' Fever Breaks-Does the Bounce Have Legs?)

"What we do best is model the difference between inflation and deflation which is caused by the Federal Reserve," said Michael Pento, president of Pento Portfolio Strategies. "I don't think it's even possible anymore, the idea that you can buy and hold a diverse group of assets and hold them for 10 years."

Pento believes the current climate sets up for a rising stock market but ultimately will lead to inflation and a need for investors to migrate to hard assets and energy.

Many investors, mindful of a need to vary their choices, are clamoring for indexes that are composed not just of basic indexes but now apply overall strategies.

"What's interesting about indexes now is that we've gone through three distinct phases," said Shaun T. Wurzbach, vice president of channel management and solutions at Standard and Poor's Dow Jones Indices. "The first was the creation of the S&P 500 (and other major indexes), the second phase was the creation of sector-based indices for narrower exposures. The third wave is a wave of strategy-based indexes."

Some of those gaining popularity are geared towards low volatility, bank loans and weighted by country, Wurzbach said during an interview at last week's Charles Schwab Impact 2012 conference, where there was substantial chatter about investor desire for new options away from simple stock and bond portfolios. (Read More: Are Investors Actually Taking the 'Fiscal Cliff' Too Lightly?)

"Sometimes innovation is well-received in the marketplace and sometimes it isn't," Wurzbach said.

In any event, active managers have their work cut out for them if they want to stay relevant as returns continue to diminish.

Jeff Coons, president and co-director of research at Manning & Napier in Fairport, N.Y., said investors shouldn't judge the industry as a whole and instead should focus on individual managers with sound strategies to navigate bubble and post-bubble markets.

"Demonstrating the value of active management ultimately requires a thorough manager evaluation, he said. "While the quest for absolute-return-focused solutions can be challenging at times, it's important to remember that no single mix of assets is likely to meet an investor's goals in every market environment."

More From CNBC


Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
  • China manufacturing activity expands slightly in September - official PMI Reuters - 19 minutes ago

    BEIJING (Reuters) - Activity in China's manufacturing sector expanded slightly in September, an official survey showed on Saturday. The official Purchasing Managers' Index (CNPMIB=ECI) (PMI) stood at 50.4 ... … More »

  • China Factory Gauge Signals Economic Stabilization Still Intact Bloomberg - 38 minutes ago

    "Thanks to heavy fiscal stimulus through SOE investments, production related to infrastructure projects and the enlarging current account surplus, GDP growth could edge up to 6.9 percent in Q3 and Q4, bringing the annual figure to 6.8 percent," … More »

  • Glencore's former No. 2 aluminium trader buys bankrupt U.S. smelter Reuters - 39 minutes ago

    Noranda Aluminium Holding Corp (NORNQ.PK) said on Friday it sold its 263,000 tonne-per-year New Madrid primary aluminium smelter in Missouri to ARG for $13.7 million in a court-approved auction. Noranda filed for bankruptcy in February after … More »

  • Expats guide to personal finance in Singapore
    Expats guide to personal finance in Singapore ZUU online - 1 hour 51 minutes ago

    Singapore remains an attractive location for expats due to its English-speaking culture, world-cl... … More »

  • NTSB has yet to interview injured engineer in deadly crash
    NTSB has yet to interview injured engineer in deadly crash Associated Press - 2 hours 2 minutes ago

    National Transportation Safety Board investigators held off questioning the engineer in the deadly Hoboken train crash because of his injuries Friday and struggled to lift clues from the train's black ... … More »

  • The Latest: Investigators say train crew 'very cooperative'
    The Latest: Investigators say train crew 'very cooperative' Associated Press - 2 hours 9 minutes ago

    The Latest on a commuter train that crashed into a station in New Jersey, killing one person and injuring more than 100 others (all times local): 7:20 p.m. The National Transportation Safety Board says ... … More »

  • PM May orders employment law review as labour market changes
    PM May orders employment law review as labour market changes Reuters - 2 hours 16 minutes ago

    British Prime Minister Theresa May ordered a review of employment practices on Saturday, saying she wanted to ensure workers' rights were protected under changing business models and a growing trend towards flexible or self-employment. The review … More »

  • Hammond says Brexit deal should not harm economy - Telegraph
    Hammond says Brexit deal should not harm economy - Telegraph Reuters - 2 hours 21 minutes ago

    British controls on immigration following the country's referendum decision to leave the European Union must not be damaging for the economy, finance minister Philip Hammond was quoted as saying in the Daily Telegraph story on Friday. Hammond told … More »

  • China's yuan joins elite club of IMF reserve currencies Reuters - 2 hours 28 minutes ago

    China's yuan joins the International Monetary Fund's basket of reserve currencies on Saturday in a milestone for the government's campaign for recognition as a global economic power. It is the first time that a currency has been added to sit … More »

  • Stocks rebound in Deutsche Bank-led volatile trading
    Stocks rebound in Deutsche Bank-led volatile trading AFP News - 2 hours 37 minutes ago

    US and eurozone shares pushed higher Friday in volatile trade driven by Deutsche Bank's negotiations to settle US charges over its sale of toxic mortgage bonds before the financial crisis. News that Deutsche Bank was close to a much lower … More »

  • Accounting software maker BlackLine files for IPO Reuters - 2 hours 52 minutes ago

    Los Angeles-based BlackLine, founded in 2001 by Chief Executive Therese Tucker, counts Coca-Cola Co (KO.N), Under Armour (UA.N) and Dow Chemical Co (DOW.N) among its 1,500 customers. Reuters reported last week that the company was preparing for an … More »

  • Florida Lottery plans major expansion under huge new deal Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    The Florida Lottery — which just registered more than $6 billion in annual sales — is in line for a large expansion due to a massive new contract that state officials signed this month. Lottery officials, ... … More »

  • Deutsche Bank pressure eases as US fine looks smaller
    Deutsche Bank pressure eases as US fine looks smaller AFP News - 3 hours ago

    Heavy market pressure on Deutsche Bank eased Friday as a knowledgeable source told AFP the US fine over toxic debt it sold would be only $5.4 billion, not the $14 billion originally demanded. A person familiar with the talks between Deutsche Bank … More »

  • A Deutsche Bank settlement overshadows U.S. equities
    A Deutsche Bank settlement overshadows U.S. equities Reuters - 3 hours ago

    Deutsche Bank will likely cast a pall over equity markets next week as the largest German lender navigates a possible multi-billion dollar settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice over the sale of mortgage-backed bonds. Deutsche shares traded … More »

  • A Yahoo insider believes the hackers could really have stolen over 1 billion accounts
    A Yahoo insider believes the hackers could really have stolen over 1 billion accounts Business Insider - 3 hours ago

    REUTERS/Ruben Sprich Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer The actual … Continued The post A Yahoo insider believes the hackers could really have stolen over 1 billion accounts appeared first on Business Insider. … More »

  • IMF leader cites 'historic milestone' for China
    IMF leader cites 'historic milestone' for China Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    Christine Lagarde, the managing director of the International Monetary Fund, is calling the inclusion of China's renminbi as the fifth currency in an elite group of the world's reserve currencies an "important ... … More »

  • Chinese yuan set to join IMF's elite currency basket
    Chinese yuan set to join IMF's elite currency basket AFP News - 3 hours ago

    China's yuan is poised to enter the International Monetary Fund's elite SDR basket of currencies, elevating Beijing's banknotes into a family long exclusive to global reserve assets. A symbolic coup for policymakers in Beijing, the move represents … More »

  • Business Highlights Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    ___ Malls, stores consider new ways to protect shoppers More sophisticated cameras. Security robots. Customers feeling shaken by recent attacks at U.S. malls may not notice huge changes — but mall operators ... … More »

  • The only executive to hold a high-ranking position at both Uber and Lyft is leaving Uber
    The only executive to hold a high-ranking position at both Uber and Lyft is leaving Uber Business Insider - 3 hours ago

    Uber Uber’s VP of Driver Growth, Travis VanderZanden, … Continued The post The only executive to hold a high-ranking position at both Uber and Lyft is leaving Uber appeared first on Business Insider. … More »

  • Trump vs Miss Universe: White House race hits new low
    Trump vs Miss Universe: White House race hits new low AFP News - 4 hours ago

    Donald Trump urged voters on Friday to check out the supposed "sex tape" of a former Miss Universe backing his rival Hillary Clinton, provoking the Democrat to label him "unhinged" in a surreal new turn to the White House race. In a pre-dawn … More »

  • Data storage provider Nutanix soars in market debut
    Data storage provider Nutanix soars in market debut Reuters - 4 hours ago

    After getting strong encouragement from investors, the company kept nudging up the asking price for shares from the $11 to $13 range set early last week, co-founder and Chief Executive Officer Dheeraj Pandey said in an interview on Friday. … More »

  • Municipal-bond week in review: Yields sag then finish strong Associated Press - 4 hours ago

    Yields on municipal and Treasury bonds sagged this week on concerns about the health of Germany's largest bank, before retracing their steps on Friday. The 10-year yield on the AP Municipal Bond index ... … More »

  • Nutanix exceeds expectations in upsized IPO Reuters - 4 hours ago

    San Jose, California-based Nutanix's share price exceeds the $13.40 value last placed on its shares in a 2014 funding round, an upgrade encouraging for the many unprofitable technology companies that, like Nutanix, have been weary of testing public … More »

  • US stocks rally on Deutsche Bank deal AFP - 4 hours ago

    US stocks rose strongly Friday as financial shares surged on news that Deutsche Bank was near a settlement with US regulators over its sale of toxic mortgage bonds before the financial crisis. US-traded ... … More »

  • How the Dow Jones industrial average fared on Friday Associated Press - 4 hours ago

    U.S. stocks climbed Friday as banks made a rapid recovery following a steep fall a day ago. Investors hoped Deutsche Bank and the financial system in general were in better shape than they had feared. ... … More »

Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
to view quotes in your portfolios.


  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg

Market Data

  • Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change