Are Stocks a Screaming Buy? It Depends on Your Time Horizon

When investing, it's good to beware of following the herd, because the herd, we're supposed to have learned, can go wildly astray. When it's not chasing past outperformance, it's fleeing past underperformance--hence the reported aversion to stocks in recent years.

But has the herd, frightened into bonds for much of this year, fled so far into the hills that it's now underinvested in stocks?

By some measures, the answer is yes. The most stock-loving investors have pulled back on their positions. The Investment Company Institute reports that equity aversion rose across all age groups above 30 in the decade through 2011. The proportion of each cohort that has at least 80 percent of its portfolio invested in stocks fell during that period--by a bigger proportion the older the investor. That's not the same thing as being under underinvested in stocks, though. Vanguard reports that equity (domestic and foreign) accounted for 50.2 percent of assets under management by U.S. open-end funds and ETFs as of July 31--about the average for the past 20 years.

[Read: Are Individual Investors Destined to Fail?]

The question is, should equity allocations be even bigger? Fidelity argues in a recent report that stocks are cheap by several measures. One is the S&P 500 index's "current" price-earnings ratio--based on the trailing 12 months' earnings--which was 13.8 at the end of the second quarter, below the long-term average of around 16. If you rank all the quarterly P/E ratios since 1926, the second quarter's is in the second-cheapest quintile, says Fidelity. Historically, buying at these P/Es has produced real returns of 8.1 percent over the subsequent five years and 10.1 percent over the subsequent decade, well above the long-term averages of 6.5 percent and 6.9 percent, respectively, says the study.

True, the cyclically adjusted, or CAPE, ratio, which measures prices against the previous five or 10 years' earnings, makes stocks look more expensive than does the current method. On the other hand, some would caution, a five-year measure would include the unusually deep recession of 2007-09.

"That's not representative of what corporate America can earn," says John Fox, co-manager of Fenimore Asset Management's $740 million FAM Value fund (symbol:FAMVX).

Fidelity notes other measures of market value that hint of bargains to be had. The "equity risk premium" (ERP)--the difference between the earnings yield on equities and the yield on the "risk-free" 10-year Treasury--is historically quite high, indicating inexpensive stocks and above-average returns in coming years. Though there is some subjectivity built into ERP calculations, the idea is that there's room for stock prices to rise without eliminating a reward for the additional risk that stocks entail.

[Read: How a Dogged Focus Helps Investors.]

To be sure, investors can find plenty of reasons to shun stocks in the short term. Uncertainty about whether the United States will get its fiscal house in order; wariness about Europe; prolonged sluggishness in both the United States and Europe. But Fidelity notes similar periods in the past: the deflationary 1930s and the years 1942-51, when the Fed kept rates unusually low, P/Es were down and ERPs were high. Both periods signaled higher subsequent five- and 10-year equity returns, Fidelity says.

So lots of signals are blinking "buy." The question then becomes: How reliable are the signals? The short answer: not very. Christopher Philips, senior analyst at Vanguard's Investment Strategy Group, says the CAPE measure, for example, explains about 35 percent of the variation in real returns over a 10-year period. That leaves 65 percent unexplained.

"The challenge is that there's so much noise in the data that even when you look at long-term relationships, there's more uncertainty than certainty with respect to predictability," says Philips. "Everyone's crystal ball seems to be cracked."

Also, a lot of that 35 percent is driven by what analysts call "tail" events--historical anomalies that skew the results. Strip out the high P/Es of the dot-come bubble and the low P/Es of the recessed early '80s, says Philips, and the 35 percent falls to 15 or 20 percent. Reduce the period from 10 years to one, and it disappears altogether.

Philips also warns against rules of thumb which say, for example, that after a lost decade of historical underperformance, the pendulum is due to swing back toward outperformance. "Mean reversion is a very dangerous game to play," he says. "Historical patterns look like they can be tracked and profited from. We tend to be a little cynical with respect to things like that. If it were that easy, a lot more people would be a lot more successful."

[In Pictures: The S&P's 10 Worst Trading Days]

Still, with bond yields at record lows and bond prices exposed to interest-rate and inflation risk, inevitably investors face the Henny Youngman question: Equities are risky compared to what?

"If you're a long-term investor--and here we agree with the takeaways of the Fidelity report--your best bet for realizing positive real returns--on average, over time--is going to be equities," says Philips. "They do a great job of mitigating the impact of inflation over longer periods and they should outperform more conservative investments--your money-market, your fixed-income investment--because they are riskier assets."

Even over the past decade, says Fox, investors using dollar-cost averaging have made money in stocks. Not much, but some.

"The lost decade is going into the rear-view mirror, you have made money in the stock market over last 10 years, and I think you'll have similar returns going forward," says Fox. "I don't think we're going back to the 1980s and '90s, where you made 17 or 18 percent a year. But there's nothing wrong with 8 percent a year for a decade. And compared to the alternatives, I think it's going to prove pretty good."



More From US News & World Report

--

Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
Loading...
  • How to put a number to “uncertainty” – and what it means for markets
    How to put a number to “uncertainty” – and what it means for markets Truewealth Publishing - 52 minutes ago

    Markets hate uncertainty. But lots of uncertainty – as there is now – doesn’t mean that markets won’t go up. Uncertainty is more subjective than (say) volatility, or stock market valuations, or the price performance of assets. To most people, … More »

  • Japan January industrial output falls 0.8 percent month/month - government
    Japan January industrial output falls 0.8 percent month/month - government Reuters - 52 minutes ago

    TOKYO (Reuters) - Japan's industrial output unexpectedly fell 0.8 percent in January, posting the first decline in six months, government data showed on Tuesday. The month-on-month fall compared with a ... … More »

  • PHI Inc. reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 53 minutes ago

    The Lafayette, Louisiana-based company said it had a loss of $1.08 per share. The helicopter transportation company serving the oil and gas industry posted revenue of $144.9 million in the period. For ... … More »

  • Ensco beats 4Q profit forecasts Associated Press - 1 hour 3 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the London-based company said it had profit of 13 cents. Earnings, adjusted to account for discontinued operations and non-recurring gains, came to 9 cents per share. The results ... … More »

  • BWX beats 4Q profit forecasts Associated Press - 1 hour 17 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Lynchburg, Virginia-based company said it had net income of 34 cents. Earnings, adjusted for non-recurring costs and restructuring costs, came to 46 cents per share. The results ... … More »

  • AppFolio reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 1 hour 19 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Santa Barbara, California-based company said it had a loss of 4 cents. Earnings, adjusted for stock option expense, were less than 1 cent on a per-share basis. The property management ... … More »

  • Elio’s tiny car gets 84 mpg and costs only $7,300 — here’s what it was like
    Elio’s tiny car gets 84 mpg and costs only $7,300 — here’s what it was like Business Insider - 1 hour 21 minutes ago

    Hollis Johnson Elio Motors has one of the … Continued The post Elio’s tiny car gets 84 mpg and costs only $7,300 — here’s what it was like appeared first on Business Insider. … More »

  • Sun Hydraulics posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 1 hour 37 minutes ago

    The Sarasota, Florida-based company said it had net income of 12 cents per share. The maker of screw-in hydraulic cartridge valves and manifolds posted revenue of $49.9 million in the period. For the year, ... … More »

  • Medpace tops Street 4Q forecasts Associated Press - 1 hour 39 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Cincinnati-based company said it had a loss of less than 1 cent. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, were 35 cents per share. The results topped Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

  • Theravance Bio reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 1 hour 48 minutes ago

    The George Town Grand Cayman, Cayman Islands-based company said it had a loss of $1.36 per share. The results did not meet Wall Street expectations. The average estimate of three analysts surveyed by Zacks ... … More »

  • Integer beats Street 4Q forecasts Associated Press - 1 hour 58 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Frisco, Texas-based company said it had net income of 25 cents. Earnings, adjusted for non-recurring costs and amortization costs, came to 87 cents per share. The results surpassed ... … More »

  • Kona Grill reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 2 hours 9 minutes ago

    The Scottsdale, Arizona-based company said it had a loss of $1.58 per share. Losses, adjusted for asset impairment costs, came to 39 cents per share. The results did not meet Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

  • Stocks drift awaiting Trump tax plan details
    Stocks drift awaiting Trump tax plan details AFP News - 2 hours 10 minutes ago

    Wall Street and the major European indices drifted higher on Monday in advance of a major address by President Donald Trump, as investors in New York sent the Dow to a fresh record. The blue-chip Dow Jones Industrial Average crept up to close at a … More »

  • Business Highlights Associated Press - 2 hours 16 minutes ago

    ___ New highs for US stocks; Dow win streak longest since 1987 Wall Street notched another set of milestones as the Dow Jones industrial average closed at a record high for the 12th consecutive time, the ... … More »

  • Britain urges Malaysia to share evidence on Kim VX attack
    Britain urges Malaysia to share evidence on Kim VX attack AFP News - 2 hours 21 minutes ago

    Britain on Monday urged Malaysia to share evidence from the lethal VX nerve gas attack on Kim Jong-Un's half-brother with the United Nations, which could take action against North Korea. British Ambassador Matthew Rycroft said information on the … More »

  • Watchdog agency warns of costly student loan data errors Associated Press - 2 hours 22 minutes ago

    The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau on Monday issued a warning to consumers to pay close attention to their personal information on record with student loan servicers as errors are popping up that ... … More »

  • Nutrisystem beats Street 4Q forecasts Associated Press - 2 hours 24 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Fort Washington, Pennsylvania-based company said it had net income of 29 cents. The results topped Wall Street expectations. The average estimate of four analysts surveyed by ... … More »

  • Gaiam reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 2 hours 28 minutes ago

    The Louisville, Colorado-based company said it had a loss of 22 cents per share. Losses, adjusted to account for discontinued operations, came to 23 cents per share. The lifestyle media company posted ... … More »

  • Here’s the advice Bill Gates would give to his 19-year-old self
    Here’s the advice Bill Gates would give to his 19-year-old self Business Insider - 2 hours 28 minutes ago

    Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images Bill Gates would tell his … Continued The post Here’s the advice Bill Gates would give to his 19-year-old self appeared first on Business Insider. … More »

  • Essendant reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 2 hours 37 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Deerfield, Illinois-based company said it had a loss of 6 cents. Losses, adjusted for non-recurring costs, came to 2 cents per share. The workplace supplies distributor posted ... … More »

  • ICF misses Street 4Q forecasts Associated Press - 2 hours 40 minutes ago

    The Fairfax, Virginia-based company said it had profit of 65 cents per share. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, came to 76 cents per share. The results missed Wall Street expectations. The ... … More »

  • Nelnet posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 2 hours 42 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Lincoln, Nebraska-based company said it had net income of $2.32. Earnings, adjusted for non-recurring gains, were $1.05 per share. The education services company posted revenue ... … More »

  • ServiceNow appoints former eBay executive as CEO Reuters - 2 hours 44 minutes ago

    ServiceNow Inc (NOW.N) said it had hired former eBay Inc (EBAY.O) executive John Donahoe to be chief executive, replacing longtime CEO Frank Slootman starting in April, a surprise move that sent shares of the enterprise software lower on Monday. … More »

  • How major US stock market indexes fared on Monday Associated Press - 2 hours 44 minutes ago

    U.S. stocks closed slightly higher Monday, nudging the Dow Jones industrial average to a record high for the 12th consecutive time. The Standard & Poor's 500 index also closed at an all-time high. The ... … More »

  • New highs for US stocks; Dow win streak longest since 1987
    New highs for US stocks; Dow win streak longest since 1987 Associated Press - 2 hours 46 minutes ago

    Wall Street notched another set of milestones Monday as the Dow Jones industrial average closed at a record high for the 12th consecutive time, the longest winning streak for the 30-company average in ... … More »

 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.

MARKET MOVERS

    Market Data

    • Currencies
      Currencies
      NamePriceChange% Chg
      1.4056+0.0015+0.11%
      USDSGD=X
      1.4870+0.0007+0.05%
      EURSGD=X
      1.7471+0.0011+0.06%
      GBPSGD=X
      80.1830-0.04-0.05%
      SGDJPY=X
      5.5206-0.0049-0.09%
      SGDHKD=X
      3.1591-0.0019-0.06%
      SGDMYR=X
      9,504.5137+0.4902+0.01%
      SGDIDR=X
      4.8857-0.0046-0.09%
      SGDCNY=X
      1.0783+0.0008+0.07%
      AUDSGD=X
    • Commodities
      Commodities
      NamePriceChange% Chg
      1,253.00-5.80-0.46%
      GCJ17.CMX
      18.33-0.09-0.47%
      SIK17.CMX
      84.47-4.15-4.69%
      ^XAU
      2.690.00-0.19%
      HGK17.CMX
      54.13+0.08+0.15%
      CLJ17.NYM
    • Bonds
      Bonds
      TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change
      1.87+0.07
      ^FVX
      2.37+0.05
      ^TNX
      2.99+0.03
      ^TYX