The Real Lesson of Excessive Pay at GM, AIG, and Ally

Taxpayers got rolled--again.

That's the conclusion of a scathing new report by a Treasury Department watchdog overseeing the 2008 and 2009 bailouts of General Motors, AIG, Ally Financial, and several other troubled firms. In 2012, the Treasury approved pay of $1 million or more for 68 executives at the three firms, even though they were still operating with taxpayer assistance. Treasury approved pay of $3 million or more for 37 of those executives, and $5 million or more for 16 of them.

[RELATED: AIG Decides Against Suing Taxpayers Over Bailout]

Such lavish compensation violated the Treasury's own guidelines for pay at rescued firms, according to the Special Inspector General for the TARP bailout program, known as SIGTARP. Treasury guidelines call for maximum cash salaries of $500,000, with anything above that awarded as longer-term incentives meant to discourage risk-taking that boosts short-term profits at the expense of stability. Yet Treasury-approved pay packages exceeded those limits for at least 70 percent of executives subject to oversight in 2012. Treasury "is effectively relinquishing some of [its] authority to the companies, which have their own best interests in mind," the report found.

The natural reaction to this is outrage, if there's any left after all the awful revelations that followed the extraordinary bailouts in 2008 and 2009. Yet every mistake involving the bailouts provides important insights about what the government can and can't do well during an economic emergency. With luck, we'll learn enough from these mistakes to do it better next time (and there will be a next time).

The biggest problem with regard to executive pay is that the bailouts left the rescued firms as hybrid operations trying to operate by free-market principles while under strict government supervision. They were neither fish nor fowl. It turned out to be an unworkable situation requiring one model or the other to prevail.

[READ: Why Taxpayers Will Lose Big on the GM Bailout]

Treasury wanted the rescued firms to operate like regular businesses so they could repair themselves and pay back taxpayer funds as quickly as possible. Yet doing this required talented executives paid at the same scale as other big firms, to assure they wouldn't bolt for better-paying jobs, causing more high-level turnover at companies that were already reeling.

We can have a healthy debate about whether corporate America overpays its top people, but for better or worse, typical pay for top officers at Fortune 100 firms often tops $1 million per year. It's also worth pointing out that fixing a complex, sprawling and massively broken company such as GM or AIG is one of the toughest jobs in business. It takes somebody who's seasoned and dogged, even though dozens of armchair critics no doubt feel they could have done a better job. They couldn't have.

Yet the politics of democratic government make it highly problematic to use taxpayer funds to pay anybody a million-dollar salary, especially since the president himself earns just $400,000 per year. No matter how rational the argument might be, it's political dynamite.

In one sense, this hybrid approach worked. AIG has righted itself, while paying back all the TARP money it got plus $23 billion in interest that amounts to a profit for the Treasury. The government will probably lose about $5 billion on the GM bailout, yet it still saved a company that's critical to the domestic auto industry. As for Ally (formerly GMAC), the Treasury is still about $10 billion in the hole, according to the ProPublica Bailout Tracker, but it could recoup that over time.

[RELATED: 3 Lessons From the AIG Bailout]

There has been a big cost to these bailouts, however. For one thing, they severely damaged confidence in the U.S. government and hardened the impression many people have of crony capitalists dominating decision-making in Washington, at the expense of ordinary people. The bailouts also institutionalized failure by rescuing many firms that should have gone belly up and by sparing investors who should have borne the pain of excessive risk-taking. Market discipline has been lost as a result.

If it happened again, there's a strong case that instead of the hybrid model, the government should either nationalize failed firms and treat them as government bureaucracies, or let them fail and focus on containing the damage. There are in fact new policies meant to prevent companies that are "too big to fail" from collapsing. There's also a good chance they won't work as expected. If they don't, the first principle of the next bailout should that a company that can't pay its own executives probably shouldn't exist.

Rick Newman's latest book is Rebounders: How Winners Pivot From Setback To Success. Follow him on Twitter: @rickjnewman.



More From US News & World Report

--

Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
Loading...
  • China to extend anti-dumping measures on U.S. broiler chicken product imports Reuters - 21 minutes ago

    China's commerce ministry said it will extend anti-dumping measures on imports of U.S. broiler chicken products for a further five years, effective from Sept 27. A suspension of the measures would potentially hurt Chinese firms, according to a … More »

  • PBOC Drains Most Funds in Six Months Amid Debt Curb Speculation Bloomberg - 25 minutes ago

    The monetary authority has signaled that it wants to limit runaway borrowing, with Deputy Governor Yi Gang cited as saying that the goal is to bring down leverage ratio growth. The central bank has in the past month restarted the use of both 14- … More »

  • Sakakibara Says Yen May Gradually Gain to 90 per Dollar in 2017 Bloomberg - 33 minutes ago

    Given the monetary policy divergence between the U.S. and Japan, some appreciation of the Japanese currency “is only natural,” said Sakakibara, dubbed “Mr. Yen” for his ability to influence the exchange rate while a senior Ministry of Finance … More »

  • Hyundai Motor union stages first full strike in 12 years
    Hyundai Motor union stages first full strike in 12 years Reuters - 34 minutes ago

    Hyundai Motor's South Korean labour union staged its first full nationwide strike in 12 years on Monday over wages, putting the automaker's earnings and sales targets at risk. The full-day walkout came after a series of partial stoppages since July … More »

  • Ekovest upbeat on RM1b revenue Business Times - 36 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: Construction outfit Ekovest Bhd expects to surpass the RM1 billion revenue mark by its financial year ending December 31 next year, driven by strong outstanding order book of RM5.3 billion. Its managing director Datuk Seri Lim Keng … More »

  • 'Malaysia showing impressive growth' New Straits Times - 36 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: American industrial giant General Electric Co (GE) is impressed with Malaysia growing its economy at four per cent despite the global economic turbulence. “I just think the fact that Malaysia is growing at four per cent in a world … More »

  • GE targets to be among top 10 software firms Business Times - 37 minutes ago

    UNITED States multinational conglomerate General Electric Co (GE) aims to be among the top 10 software companies with some US$15 billion (RM62 billion) of revenue by 2020. The company also moved its headquarter from Connecticut to Boston in … More »

  • LTAT plans more property projects Business Times - 37 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: Lembaga Tabung Angkatan Tentera (LTAT) will launch several more property projects to “unlock potential” for its members. The armed forces fund, through wholly-owned Perbadanan Perwira Harta Malaysia (PPHM), launched the second phase … More »

  • Transforming into digital industrial powerhouse Business Times - 37 minutes ago

    Q: You had some sort of signing ceremony today (Thursday) with Malaysia Airlines. Can you tell us why are you embarking on this transformation from hard iron big machines into a digital industrial company? … More »

  • 'TPP pact important for US' Business Times - 38 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: The Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP) agreement is crucial to the United States to forge stronger economic ties with Southeast Asian countries such as Malaysia. The 60-year-old, who runs one of the world’s biggest multinational … More »

  • A380 is great for haj and umrah market, says MAS CEO Business Times - 38 minutes ago

    SEPANG: The super-jumbo Airbus A380 aircraft, which hit turbulence in terms of new orders of late, has a great future in the haj and umrah market, says Malaysia Airlines Bhd (MAS) chief. MAS chief executive officer Peter Bellew said the A380 is … More »

  • Japan Scrambles Jets as China Makes Show of Force in Key Strait Bloomberg - 41 minutes ago

    Japan sent out the jets after eight of the Chinese planes crossed back and forth over waters between Okinawa’s main island and Miyako-jima island near Taiwan, the Defense Ministry in Tokyo said in a statement. Two of the planes may have been … More »

  • Do U.S. Elections Matter to Singapore’s Stock Market?
    Do U.S. Elections Matter to Singapore’s Stock Market? Truewealth Publishing - 41 minutes ago

    It makes sense that the American political calendar moves the U.S. stock market. What makes less sense is that history suggests that the U.S. election cycle may have an even bigger effect on Singapore’s stock market – as well as the rest of Asia’s. … More »

  • Oil prices rebound after Algeria says all options open at OPEC meeting
    Oil prices rebound after Algeria says all options open at OPEC meeting Reuters - 42 minutes ago

    Crude prices rebounded on Monday after Algeria's energy minister said the day before that all options were possible for an oil output cut or freeze at this week's informal meeting of OPEC producers. Members of the Organization of the Petroleum … More »

  • Malaysian banks brace for profit hits as O&G firms restructure debt Reuters - 53 minutes ago

    Malaysian lenders are bracing for a hit to profits this year as they bump up provisions for sour loans to the local oil and gas services sector that has been battered by the slump in energy prices and cutbacks in projects. The problem mirrors pain … More »

  • Contagion Risks Rise as China Banks Fund Each Others’ Loans (2) Bloomberg - 57 minutes ago

    Wholesale funds, including those raised in the interbank market, accounted for a record 34 percent of small- and medium-sized bank financing as of June 30, compared with 29 percent on Jan. 31 last year, Moody’s Investors Service estimated in an Aug. … More »

  • How to Get Richer Every Day
    How to Get Richer Every Day Truewealth Publishing - 1 hour 0 minutes ago

    Mark Ford is a self-made multimillionaire, best-selling author and real estate investor. I introduced you to Mark a few weeks ago. And everyMonday you can read Mark’s thoughts on wealth, living life well, and achieving success. (You can read his … More »

  • Trump says he'll recognize Jerusalem as Israel's 'undivided' capital
    Trump says he'll recognize Jerusalem as Israel's 'undivided' capital AFP News - 1 hour 13 minutes ago

    Republican candidate Donald Trump pledged to recognize Jerusalem as Israel's "undivided" capital if he is elected president, meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who Hillary Clinton also met that evening. Netanyahu met privately … More »

  • Parents of Mexico's missing students live in classrooms
    Parents of Mexico's missing students live in classrooms AFP News - 1 hour 14 minutes ago

    They turned classrooms at their children's college into dormitories, sleeping on the floor, but parents of 43 Mexican students missing since 2014 won't rest until they find them. Around 20 parents have made the teacher training college in … More »

  • Hong Kong Stocks Sink Most in Two Weeks as Financial Shares Fall Bloomberg - 1 hour 16 minutes ago

    AAC Technologies Holdings Inc. and Bank of Communications Co. were the biggest losers on the gauge. China Resources Land Ltd. retreated for the first time in six days, while Sands China Ltd. extended a slump from this month’s high to almost 10 … More »

  • Rebound in Ezra Seen to Be Fleeting Amid Oil Industry Woes (1) Bloomberg - 1 hour 35 minutes ago

    Ezra has surged more than 40 percent in September, and oil-related companies including Ezion Holdings Ltd. and Vard Holdings Ltd. are among the top five gainers on the 129-member FTSE Straits Times All-Share Index for the month. Traders are … More »

  • Ringgit opens lower on weak oil prices Business Times - 1 hour 37 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: The ringgit eased against the US dollar in the early session today, tracking a weaker oil market ahead of the three-day informal meeting of the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) in Algiers beginning today.At 9.00 … More »

  • Stars of Kovan, Star Qualities
    Stars of Kovan, Star Qualities The Edge Property - 1 hour 39 minutes ago

    What makes the condo stand apart from the rest  Stars of Kovan, the latest property of leading Hong Kong giant Cheung Kong Property Holdings, is set to turn a once-rustic neighbourhood into a trendy one.Cheung Kong is renowned in Singapore as a … More »

  • Bank of Shanghai Set to Raise at Least 10.5 Billion Yuan in IPO Bloomberg - 1 hour 47 minutes ago

    The lender will sell as many as 600 million shares, according to a prospectus posted to the city’s stock exchange. Guotai Junan Securities Co. and Shenwan Hongyuan Securities will be lead underwriters, according to the prospectus. The lender’s net … More »

  • Japanese Companies and Households Continue to Pile Up Cash Bloomberg - 2 hours 10 minutes ago

    Households held 920 trillion yen ($9.1 trillion) of their assets in cash or deposits at the end of the quarter through June, the second-highest level on record, a report by the Bank of Japan showed Monday. The figures indicate that the central … More »

 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.

MARKET MOVERS

  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.145+0.002+1.40%
    5DM.SI
    0.137+0.001+0.74%
    N21.SI
    0.44+0.02+4.76%
    5SO.SI
    0.725+0.005+0.69%
    BS6.SI
    0.365+0.005+1.39%
    E5H.SI
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.60+0.04+7.14%
    BDR.SI
    0.56+0.04+6.67%
    BJE.SI
    0.145+0.009+6.62%
    5NF.SI
    0.245+0.015+6.52%
    5RE.SI
    0.193+0.011+6.04%
    43B.SI
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.255-0.120-32.00%
    AZT.SI
    0.15-0.02-10.71%
    A04.SI
    0.171-0.018-9.52%
    AXH.SI
    1.525-0.090-5.57%
    BAI.SI
    0.14-0.01-6.67%
    5AM.SI

Market Data

  • Currencies
    Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1.3610+0.0029+0.21%
    USDSGD=X
    1.5281+0.0045+0.30%
    EURSGD=X
    1.7659+0.0087+0.50%
    GBPSGD=X
    74.1550+0.033+0.04%
    SGDJPY=X
    5.6971-0.0084-0.15%
    SGDHKD=X
    3.0371+0.0103+0.34%
    SGDMYR=X
    9,612.5234-43.0098-0.45%
    SGDIDR=X
    4.9031-0.0035-0.07%
    SGDCNY=X
    1.0363+0.0013+0.13%
    AUDSGD=X
  • Commodities
    Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1,336.90-7.80-0.58%
    GCZ16.CMX
    19.60-0.50-2.48%
    SIZ16.CMX
    95.76-3.02-3.05%
    ^XAU
    2.190.00-0.02%
    HGZ16.CMX
    43.85+0.41+0.94%
    CLV16.NYM
  • Bonds
    Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change
    1.15-0.02
    ^FVX
    1.62-0.02
    ^TNX
    2.34-0.01
    ^TYX