More Savers Ask: 'Should I Roll Into a Roth?'

The U.S. budget compromise reached at the start of the year included a few significant changes for retirement plans. The most important is a provision that will encourage Americans, who hold some $3 trillion in retirement accounts, to make a big shift in their savings plans and roll their savings into a Roth account to avoid the specter of higher tax rates at retirement.

The Roth is now open to anyone who has a 401(k) and works for an employer that offers a conversion plan. This extends the benefit to far more people because it eliminates income caps for higher earners who can benefit most. Because it is a workplace plan, it can only be set up through the 401(k), and only about half of plans offer the option now, though the number is growing quickly.

As a result, Roth plans have been opened for many more wealthy people than in the past. For Roth plan providers and wealth managers, it promises a wave of new rollovers, and they are already stepping up their marketing campaigns to sign you up. But some retirement experts are skeptical about whether investors should be rolling their savings from 401(k) plans into Roth accounts.

While new Roth savers must pay a big tax on previously untaxed IRAs, making the switch provides tax-free withdrawals that are particularly attractive to upper-income earners who know they will remain in a high tax bracket after they retire. In the past, income caps have limited their access.

As such, Roths will attract tax-phobic investors at a time when many fear that the $16 trillion national debt will cause tax increases far into the future. Eliminating future taxes on retirement funds is the main selling point for Roths. Some advisers say the choice comes down to a single question: Do you think taxes will rise? If you do, you should pay taxes now at a lower rate.

[Read: Need Income From Your Retirement Funds? Try These.]

But that is an oversimplification, says Jean Setzfand, vice president for financial security at AARP. While a compelling case can be made for a Roth rollover for some people, the cost-benefit is hard to clearly demonstrate for many others.

"The way I think about it, the future is in the unknown bracket for most of us, as far as future tax rates and bills. It's not a clear-cut decision in my mind," she says. "The macroeconomic issues are out of your control, and you can never be sure about your own job and future."

Another simple Roth-related question advisers ask: "Do you want to pay taxes now or later on in retirement when you have less money?" In this economy, people struggling to get by are discouraged about their future, and the reaction might be that retirement may be off the table altogether, or a less-pressing concern than avoiding any extra expense today.

No silver bullet for deciding conversions. But retirement experts say it's not good science to make retirement plans based on either fear or denial. The chances of a grim, tax-crazed future are not as high as some might think. But ignoring the future impact of taxes in retirement will not fix the problem either, and most people will be in retirement for a long time.

"You can't just hunker down and say, 'I'll just put some away some fixed income and forget about it,'" says Billy Lanter, fiduciary investment advisor at Unified Trust in Lexington, Ky. "This is where the longevity issue comes in. You need to plan for the long-term horizon for living another 25 years or more after retirement."

The people for whom Roths make the most sense are those who have a realistic expectation that they will be making enough money at retirement age to create a significant tax bill. There is no clear cutoff or formula about income levels or life expectancy, although many calculators let you explore various scenarios.

"There is no silver bullet and no perfect answer. It comes down to each special tax situation and stage of life a person is in," says Lanter.

[Read: Know Your Retirement Distribution Basics.]

One rule does hold for everyone, he says. People should never raid tax-protected IRAs to pay the tax required to do a conversion. Those funds built up over time are the hardest to replace. "If you have to pay the tax liability from nontaxable funds, you lose 100 percent of the time," Lanter says.

There is also widespread agreement that younger people are good candidates for a Roth as they start their careers. They can forego pre-tax contributions afforded by the traditional IRA while their tax burden is relatively light. As they do so, they will be investing in assets that will grow tax-free for all of their working years and they can keep 100 percent of the funds when they withdraw them in retirement.

"For them, it's really a no-brainer," says accountant and retirement adviser Ed Slott, of Ed Slott and Co.

The Roth plans also are not limited by minimum withdrawal requirements, adding flexibility that traditional IRAs lack. Some financial advisers see this as a way to protect income that people wish to pass along to heirs.

Long-term Roth advantage versus short-term cost. The choice of a Roth or a traditional IRA could also dictate the way you invest, says Slott. "Once you are in a Roth, you might tend to make more aggressive investments that accumulate capital gains that are all tax-free without required withdrawals, and that changes your risk profile."

[See 10 Books Investors Should Read.]

To be sure, the Roth adds a level of complexity to financial planning at a time when people are already confused by retirement options. AARP's Setzfand says that in some cases, a financial adviser will be needed to sort things out. Lanter agrees that some of the strategies for creating a diversified income source require a specialist view owing to the new batch of related rules and options. People with the cash to set up a Roth "usually have the money to do that," says Setzfand. But individuals can decide their own strategy for putting funds in one or both, she adds.

"I love the diversity this [expanded Roth] offers," says Setzfand. "You can set it up so you have a mix of income in retirement that is taxable and tax-free, and some that is not subject to required withdrawal rules. Just like with investments, it's always good to diversify."



More From US News & World Report

--

Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
Loading...
  • The skin cure fad threatening Myanmar's elephants
    The skin cure fad threatening Myanmar's elephants AFP News - 2 hours 8 minutes ago

    "Elephant's skin can cure skin diseases like eczema," one shop owner, who requested anonymity, told AFP next to a counter brimming with porcupine quills and snake skins. Then you get the ash and mix it with coconut oil to apply on the eczema." He … More »

  • Who's who in the Syria conflict
    Who's who in the Syria conflict AFP News - 2 hours 47 minutes ago

    Talks aimed at ending Syria's nearly six-year war are set to open on Monday in the Kazakh capital, brokered by regime allies Russia and Iran and rebel backer Turkey. Key regime backer Russia began an air campaign in support of President Bashar … More »

  • Years of failed efforts to end Syrian conflict
    Years of failed efforts to end Syrian conflict AFP News - 2 hours 58 minutes ago

    Since the start of Syria's war in 2011, several diplomatic initiatives have stumbled over the future of President Bashar al-Assad. Here is a recap: - End of Arab solutions - In January 2012, two months after an initial bid to end the violence, … More »

  • US stocks rise, dollar falls as Trump era begins
    US stocks rise, dollar falls as Trump era begins AFP News - 3 hours ago

    US stocks rose and the dollar fell Friday as Donald Trump was officially sworn in as the president of the United States and Barack Obama's term ended. Trump's inauguration dominated a day that saw most major equity markets rise as the … More »

  • Automotive industry: Sales lower but resilient Business Times - 3 hours ago

    CYBERJAYA: The Malaysian automotive industry is resilient, considering there were no “surprises” by the industry players last year, despite lower sales figures, according to Malaysia Automotive Institute (MAI) chief. Chief executive officer Datuk … More »

  • Automotive industry: Sales lower but resilient Business Times - 3 hours ago

    CYBERJAYA: The Malaysian automotive industry is resilient, considering there were no “surprises” by the industry players last year, despite lower sales figures, according to Malaysia Automotive Institute (MAI) chief. Chief executive officer Datuk … More »

  • Top gainer: UMW Holdings shares soar Business Times - 3 hours ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: UMW Holdings Bhd soared almost 10 per cent yesterday, while its subsidiary UMW Oil & Gas Corp Bhd (UMW O&G) plunged more than 17 per cent, following the announcement of their consolidation plans. UMW Holdings was Bursa Malaysia’s top … More »

  • Top gainer: UMW Holdings shares soar Business Times - 3 hours ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: UMW Holdings Bhd soared almost 10 per cent yesterday, while its subsidiary UMW Oil & Gas Corp Bhd (UMW O&G) plunged more than 17 per cent, following the announcement of their consolidation plans. UMW Holdings was Bursa Malaysia’s top … More »

  • Trump's inauguration day of ritual upends tradition
    Trump's inauguration day of ritual upends tradition AFP News - 4 hours ago

    Donald Trump awoke as your everyday American billionaire. By noon he was sworn in as the nation's 45th president, on a whirlwind day that saw him thrust into the spotlight like never before. Trump, 70, began his Inauguration Day as many American … More »

  • Trump signs executive order against Obamacare health law
    Trump signs executive order against Obamacare health law AFP News - 4 hours ago

    President Donald Trump signed an executive order aimed at limiting the "burden" of the Obamacare health law that the incoming US leader has vowed to repeal. During the signing in the Oval Office, Trump's chief of staff Reince Priebus described the … More »

  • Singaporean buyer scores a bargain at St Regis Residences
    Singaporean buyer scores a bargain at St Regis Residences The Edge Property - 5 hours ago

    One of the first few resale transactions in 2017 resulted in a hefty loss for the seller. On Jan 3, a high-floor unit at St Regis Residences Singapore was sold at a loss of $2.3 million. The seller bought the unit in a sub-sale transaction in 2008 … More »

  • US stocks rise, dollar falls as Trump era begins Business Times - 6 hours ago

    NEW YORK: US stocks rose and the dollar fell Friday as Donald Trump was officially sworn in as the president of the United States and Barack Obama’s term ended. Trump’s inauguration dominated a day that saw most major equity markets rise as the … More »

  • US stocks rise, dollar falls as Trump era begins AFP - 6 hours ago

    US stocks rose and the dollar fell Friday as Donald Trump was officially sworn in as the president of the United States and Barack Obama's term ended. Trump's inauguration dominated a day that saw most ... … More »

  • Trump gets Obama's house, title _ even his Twitter handle
    Trump gets Obama's house, title _ even his Twitter handle Associated Press - 7 hours ago

    Donald Trump built his campaign on early morning tweet storms and hashtag-worthy slogans. Now president, he's in control of the White House's powerful social media arsenal, including the official @POTUS ... … More »

  • Business Highlights Associated Press - 7 hours ago

    ___ China's growth in 2016 slumps as Trump trade struggle looms China's economic growth sank to a three-decade low in 2016 as its struggling exporters brace for a possible trade battle with President-elect ... … More »

  • Stocks edge higher, snapping a 5-day losing streak for Dow
    Stocks edge higher, snapping a 5-day losing streak for Dow Associated Press - 8 hours ago

    Materials companies led U.S. stocks modestly higher Friday, recouping much of the market's loss from a day earlier and snapping a 5-day losing streak for the Dow Jones industrial average. Another crop ... … More »

  • How major US stock market indexes fared on Friday Associated Press - 8 hours ago

    Stocks closed modestly higher Friday, recouping much of the market's loss from a day earlier. The gains, which snapped a 5-day losing streak for the Dow Jones industrial average, came against the backdrop ... … More »

  • Gambia's Jammeh agrees to go, but exile terms not reached
    Gambia's Jammeh agrees to go, but exile terms not reached AFP News - 8 hours ago

    Gambia's Yahya Jammeh agreed "in principle" to hand over power to President Adama Barrow on Friday, Mauritanian and Guinean sources said, but differences remained before a full deal could be reached. Mauritania's President Mohamed Ould Abdel Aziz … More »

  • Dollar falls, U.S. stocks end higher after Trump inauguration
    Dollar falls, U.S. stocks end higher after Trump inauguration Reuters - 8 hours ago

    The dollar ended down while U.S. stock indexes rose in the last day of a choppy trading week, as investors reacted to President Donald Trump's inaugural speech. U.S. stocks started the day higher but gave up some gains after Trump started speaking. … More »

  • TrailStone buys Cargill's power and gas group - sources
    TrailStone buys Cargill's power and gas group - sources Reuters - 8 hours ago

    Commodities trader and investor TrailStone Group has purchased Cargill Inc's gas and power trading group, three sources familiar with the deal said this week. The move, first reported by Sparkspread, comes amid a reshuffling in the power and … More »

  • Dollar falls as investors unpack inauguration speech
    Dollar falls as investors unpack inauguration speech Reuters - 8 hours ago

    The dollar edged down on Friday as investors were underwhelmed by the limited scope of executive actions and the lack of concrete policy reforms in the inauguration speech of newly sworn-in U.S. President Donald Trump. Investors had been looking to … More »

  • Oil prices jump 2 percent ahead of producers' compliance meeting
    Oil prices jump 2 percent ahead of producers' compliance meeting Reuters - 8 hours ago

    Oil prices rose more than 2 percent on Friday on expectations that this weekend's meeting of the world's top oil producers would demonstrate compliance to a global output cut deal, but rising U.S. drilling activity limited gains. Members of the … More »

  • Mars investigating Skittles said to be intended for cattle Associated Press - 8 hours ago

    A mysterious Skittles spill on a rural highway in Wisconsin is taking another twist, with Mars Inc. saying it doesn't know why the discarded candy might have been headed to become cattle feed. The case ... … More »

  • US stocks close higher as Trump takes office AFP - 9 hours ago

    Wall Street stocks finished higher Friday as Donald Trump was sworn in as the 45th president of the United States and Barack Obama's term ended. US stocks were in positive territory virtually the entire ... … More »

  • Markets Right Now: Dow industrials break 5-day losing streak Associated Press - 9 hours ago

    The latest on developments in financial markets (All times local): 4:00 p.m. Stocks are ending higher, recouping much of the market's loss from a day earlier and breaking a 5-day losing streak for the ... … More »

 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.

MARKET MOVERS

  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.172-0.002-1.15%
    N21.SI
    0.109+0.003+2.83%
    AAJ.SI
    0.121+0.006+5.22%
    40F.SI
    3.81+0.03+0.79%
    Z74.SI
    0.855-0.005-0.58%
    Y92.SI
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.45+0.12+36.36%
    MR8.SI
    0.44+0.09+25.71%
    AWC.SI
    0.46+0.08+21.05%
    AYB.SI
    0.52+0.07+16.85%
    E8Z.SI
    0.20+0.02+10.50%
    BDN.SI
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.22-0.03-13.73%
    AWI.SI
    0.155-0.015-8.82%
    F86.SI
    0.113-0.010-8.13%
    D79.SI
    0.23-0.02-8.00%
    T18.SI
    0.139-0.011-7.33%
    5NF.SI

Market Data

  • Currencies
    Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1.4246-0.0012-0.09%
    USDSGD=X
    1.5220+0.0019+0.12%
    EURSGD=X
    1.7591+0.0004+0.02%
    GBPSGD=X
    80.1670-0.478-0.59%
    SGDJPY=X
    5.4390+0.002+0.04%
    SGDHKD=X
    3.1179-0.0011-0.04%
    SGDMYR=X
    9,436.7451+30.9307+0.33%
    SGDIDR=X
    4.8209+0.004+0.08%
    SGDCNY=X
    1.0759-0.0017-0.16%
    AUDSGD=X
  • Commodities
    Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1,210.20+8.70+0.72%
    GCG17.CMX
    17.11+0.11+0.66%
    SIH17.CMX
    88.68+1.12+1.28%
    ^XAU
    2.620.00+0.19%
    HGH17.CMX
    52.33+0.96+1.87%
    CLG17.NYM
  • Bonds
    Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change
    1.94-0.01
    ^FVX
    2.47+0.01
    ^TNX
    3.05+0.01
    ^TYX