When Does Indicator-Watching Become Voodoo Investing?

The stock market will plunge next year, take it from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. How do we know? Because New York City received below-average rainfall this summer, and even Hurricane Sandy couldn't make up the deficit. True fact: There is a surprisingly strong correlation between rainfall in New York and the performance of the stock market, according to NOAA data assembled by Lakewood, Wash.-based analyst Tom McClellan.

If rain trends don't nail you, the solar system just might. The website Money Morning ("Only the News You Can Profit From") quoted market analyst Arch Crawford in July as saying his "astro indicators" show a market implosion sometime before March. As of this writing, we're about halfway through the "Mars/Uranus Crash Cycle," so there's still time to bail if you hurry. (Unless, of course, the Mayan Calendar Gods pull the celestial power plug on December 21. Let me get back to you.)

On the credibility spectrum, these theories fall somewhere between pseudoscience and straight-up flapdoodle. But they raise an interesting question: Are there stock-market indicators reliable enough to hang your portfolio on?

[Read: Fiscal Cliff Notes: Investing Ideas for the Coming Months.]

In the short term, no. In the longer term, also no, though it's worth noting that some long-term indicators are better than others, as the folks at Vanguard recently showed.

Vanguard studied 15 commonly used stock-market indicators (plus one random metric--rainfall--just as a "reality check") and ranked them by their power to predict stock prices. The most reliable, you'll be pleased to know, is not solar radiation levels or who wins the Super Bowl. It's plain old earnings.

Looking at the broad U.S. stock market over the period 1926 to 2012, Vanguard finds that price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios at any point in time explain about 40 percent of the variation in stock prices over the subsequent 10 years. In particular, the cyclically adjusted P/E ratio (CAPE)--which measures stock prices against the previous 10 years' earnings--explains 43 percent of subsequent variation, while the conventional P/E (trailing 12 months' earnings) explains 38 percent.

Note, however, than even the best indicators explain less than half of what moves stock prices. As Vanguard is quick to note, "the fact that even PEs--the strongest of the indicators we examined--leave a large portion of returns unexplained underscores our belief that expected stock returns are best stated in a probabilistic framework, not as a 'point forecast,' and should not be forecast over short horizons."

[Read: Are Second Terms Good for Stocks?]

What's more, notes Ryan Detrick, a senior technical strategist at Schaeffer's Investment Research, "the trend of P/E ratios can be more important than the absolute level. Just because something is low doesn't mean it can't go lower."

And the other indicators? The ratio of government debt to GDP explains 23 percent of variation. Dividend yields: 19 percent. The so-called Fed model (which compares stock yields to those on long-term government bonds): 16 percent. Corporate profit margins, trailing one-year stock returns, and consensus GDP growth: zero, zero, and zero. Even rainfall pulls 6 percent.

Of course, it's just possible that Vanguard hasn't considered the full range of possibilities. There's no mention of what Warren Buffett has called the single best measure of valuation: total stock-market capitalization as a percentage of GDP. At the end of the third quarter it was 94, which amounts to flashing yellow.

Other strange omissions: The Hemline Model (which says shortening skirts evince rising optimism), the Boston Snow Theory (a white Christmas means rising prices), or the Billboard Hypothesis (something about "beat variance" in top-100 tunes).

Should the average investor even pay attention to this sort of thing? Except as a loose reference point, probably not. It's good to have a sense of where we are on the great stock/bond/cash ellipse, and on that basis we should be looping around to equities right about now. "We've had one of the poorest decades [for stocks] in the past hundred years," says Schaeffer's Detrick of the lamentable aughties. "Historically, when you've had a bad decade, the next one or two decades are pretty good."

[In Pictures: The S&P's 10 Worst Trading Days]

Unless you know a good reason to defy the eternal laws of mean reversion, this might be a good time to stop digging yourself into a fixed-income hole. "Bonds are a very crowded trade," says Detrick. "Yields are at generational lows. That's not the best time to put money into bonds."

But stocks? What if the rain theorists are on to something? Lakewood's McClellan says you can't be too sure. "What's happening is that the Federal Reserve and quantitative easing are stomping all over natural fluctuations," he says. "Whether that is good or bad is a different question."



More From US News & World Report

--

Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
Loading...
  • US stocks flat as oil shares pressured AFP - 3 minutes 33 seconds ago

    Petroleum-linked shares retreated Wednesday ahead of a US oil inventory report as Wall Street stocks opened little-changed in sluggish trade. Shares of Dow members ExxonMobil and Chevron dipped with oil ... … More »

  • Markets Right Now: US stocks open lower Associated Press - 4 minutes 17 seconds ago

    The latest on developments in global financial markets (all times local): 9:35 a.m. Stocks are opening slightly lower on Wall Street as the market gives back a modest gain from the day before. Mining and ... … More »

  • Wall Street opens little changed as investors eye Fed
    Wall Street opens little changed as investors eye Fed Reuters - 14 minutes ago

    REUTERS - U.S. stocks were little changed at the open on Wednesday as investors kept up their wait for Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen's speech on Friday for clues on the timing of an interest rate ... … More »

  • Iran yet to decide on OPEC limits: ministry source AFP - 25 minutes ago

    Iran has yet to take any decision on whether to set a ceiling on oil production or take part in a planned OPEC meeting in Algeria, an oil ministry source told AFP Wednesday. "It is too early to talk ... … More »

  • Cnooc Posts 1st Half-Year Loss on Canadian Oil Sands Charge (3) Bloomberg - 48 minutes ago

    Prices have whipsawed this year, flipping five times between bear and bull markets, as production from nations outside the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries, including China and the U.S., declines in the wake of a price crash that began … More »

  • EU warns Greece statistics row 'dangerous' for bailout Reuters - 1 hour 13 minutes ago

    BRUSSELS/ATHENS (Reuters) - The European Union called on Greece on Wednesday to quash what Brussels said were false accusations the Greek statistics agency rigged data to help foreign creditors and warned that the row posed risks to Athens' current … More »

  • Glencore’s Worst Profit Shows Miners Still Reeling From Crisis Bloomberg - 1 hour 14 minutes ago

    Weak raw-material prices caused profit at the commodities giant to plunge 66 percent in the first half to $300 million. The shares slumped as much as 6 percent in London, the most in two months, even as Glencore promised to cut debt even further … More »

  • New trade deal with Britain may take time, Norwegian minister says Reuters - 1 hour 38 minutes ago

    Norway wants to maintain a good relationship with Britain after it leaves the European Union but it may take a long time for a new trade agreement to be established, the EU affairs minister in Oslo said on Wednesday. Elisabeth Aspaker told a … More »

  • Qatari state fund buys stake in NY's Empire State Building
    Qatari state fund buys stake in NY's Empire State Building Associated Press - 1 hour 40 minutes ago

    Qatar's sovereign wealth fund has made an iconic purchase in America — a stake in the company that owns New York's Empire State Building. The $622-million purchase by the Qatar Investment Authority comes ... … More »

  • European stocks rebound as euro slips, U.S. curve flattens
    European stocks rebound as euro slips, U.S. curve flattens Reuters - 1 hour 43 minutes ago

    European stocks edged towards consecutive daily gains for the first time in three weeks on Wednesday, drawing support from a weak euro as investors moved to price in a U.S. interest rate rise, boosting the dollar. The earlier mood was more … More »

  • WPP sees signs of post-Brexit recovery in British ad market
    WPP sees signs of post-Brexit recovery in British ad market Reuters - 1 hour 46 minutes ago

    WPP (WPP.L), the world's largest advertising group, reported a better than expected jump in first-half net sales and said its British operations showed signs in July of a "post-Brexit recovery", sending its shares to a record high. Run by … More »

  • Gold steady as investors await U.S. rate clues
    Gold steady as investors await U.S. rate clues Reuters - 1 hour 47 minutes ago

    Gold held steady on Wednesday as investors took to the sidelines ahead of a speech by Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen this weekend which will be closely watched for further clues on U.S. interest rate policy. Yellen is scheduled to address a … More »

  • Exclusive - German ratings firm Scope seeks ECB recognition Reuters - 1 hour 48 minutes ago

    German rating firm Scope says it is in talks to become one of the European Central Bank's recognised sovereign credit agencies, though tough requirements mean the process could take at least three years. Scope would become the first agency based in … More »

  • Oil prices drop as market tracks US supplies AFP - 1 hour 48 minutes ago

    Oil prices fell Wednesday, with Brent stuck below $50, after data showed an increase in US crude stockpiles, adding to supply glut concerns. Data from the American Petroleum Institute (API) Tuesday showed ... … More »

  • U.S. oil falls 2 percent on surprise build in crude stocks
    U.S. oil falls 2 percent on surprise build in crude stocks Reuters - 1 hour 52 minutes ago

    U.S. oil prices fell more than 2 percent on Wednesday on an unexpected increase in U.S. crude stocks that revived worries about the supply glut that has capped prices for the past two years. Industry data from the American Petroleum Institute (API) … More »

  • U.S. oil falls 2 pct on surprise build in crude stocks
    U.S. oil falls 2 pct on surprise build in crude stocks Reuters - 1 hour 59 minutes ago

    U.S. oil prices fell more than 2 percent on Wednesday on an unexpected increase in U.S. crude stocks that revived worries about the supply glut that has capped prices for the past two years. Industry data from the American Petroleum Institute (API) … More »

  • Buba's Dombret says eyes LSE-Deutsche Boerse merger with some concern Reuters - 2 hours 18 minutes ago

    Bundesbank board member Andreas Dombret said he was concerned the planned $29 billion (21.89 billion pounds) merger between German exchange operator Deutsche Boerse and the London Stock Exchange may raise systemic risks in derivatives clearing. … More »

  • PetroChina profit almost wiped out in first half
    PetroChina profit almost wiped out in first half AFP News - 2 hours 22 minutes ago

    China’s biggest oil producer PetroChina's net profit plunged 97.9 percent in the first half of this year, it said Wednesday, as it struggled with a weak domestic economy and low oil prices. Net profit was 531 million yuan ($79.9 million) in the … More »

  • European equities mainly rise on German GDP
    European equities mainly rise on German GDP AFP News - 2 hours 25 minutes ago

    European stock markets mostly rose on Wednesday, shrugging off a largely downbeat session in Asia, with sentiment partly lifted by German economic growth data. Strong foreign trade and buoyant consumption drove Germany's economy, Europe's largest, … More »

  • Malaysian oil service provider Perisai in talks with bondholders Reuters - 2 hours 31 minutes ago

    Malaysian oil and gas service provider Perisai Petroleum Teknologi on Wednesday said it has started talks with holders of its S$125 million ($92.36 million) bond maturing on Oct. 3. Perisai said its interest cover ratio had fallen below the … More »

  • Angry Birds maker Rovio turns a profit, plans movie sequel
    Angry Birds maker Rovio turns a profit, plans movie sequel Reuters - 2 hours 33 minutes ago

    Finnish mobile game and animation maker Rovio Entertainment Ltd said on Wednesday it made a profit in the first half of the year and was planning a sequel to its successful Angry Birds Movie. Rovio's adjusted operating profit in the first six … More »

  • Philippines' Duterte says willing to allow online gambling resumption Reuters - 2 hours 35 minutes ago

    Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte said on Wednesday he's willing to allow a resumption of online gambling in the Southeast Asian nation if correct taxes are paid and gaming parlours are far from schools and churches. The new president added … More »

  • German banks right to charge for accounts - Bundesbank's Dombret Reuters - 2 hours 44 minutes ago

    German banks are right to consider current account fees to counter low central bank rates, but an outright charge on deposits, as pioneered by a few lenders, is unlikely to become common, Bundesbank board member Andreas Dombret told Reuters. While … More »

  • EU, Portugal agree on recapitalisation for bank CGD Reuters - 2 hours 57 minutes ago

    The European Commission said it had reached an agreement in principle with Portugal over the recapitalisation on market terms of Portuguese state-owned bank Caixa Geral de Depositos - the country's largest lender. Under the terms of the deal, … More »

  • EU says Greek debt statistics not manipulated in 2010-2015
    EU says Greek debt statistics not manipulated in 2010-2015 Reuters - 3 hours ago

    The European Union's Employment Commissioner Marianne Thyssen said on Wednesday the Greek statistics office did not manipulate data on the country's debt in 2010-2015 and that she had sent a letter to Athens asking it to refute any such suggestions. … More »

 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.

MARKET MOVERS

  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.1290.0000.00%
    N21.SI
    0.250.00-1.96%
    5ME.SI
    0.60+0.04+6.57%
    5TP.SI
    0.99-0.02-1.98%
    Y92.SI
    0.156+0.007+4.70%
    AFC.SI
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.30+0.06+22.45%
    T18.SI
    0.15+0.02+15.38%
    5TI.SI
    0.225+0.025+12.50%
    Y35.SI
    0.51+0.05+12.09%
    BHU.SI
    0.162+0.017+11.72%
    QS9.SI
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.011-0.115-91.27%
    QF6.SI
    0.23-0.17-42.50%
    AWI.SI
    0.205-0.055-21.15%
    I06.SI
    0.45-0.10-18.18%
    BFK.SI
    0.385-0.085-18.09%
    E8Z.SI

Market Data

  • Currencies
    Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1.3541+0.0029+0.21%
    USDSGD=X
    1.5257-0.0013-0.09%
    EURSGD=X
    1.7941+0.0114+0.64%
    GBPSGD=X
    74.1370+0.028+0.04%
    SGDJPY=X
    5.7246-0.0109-0.19%
    SGDHKD=X
    2.9829+0.0071+0.24%
    SGDMYR=X
    9,784.7578-31.9463-0.33%
    SGDIDR=X
    4.9148+0.0014+0.03%
    SGDCNY=X
    1.0324+0.0035+0.34%
    AUDSGD=X
  • Commodities
    Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1,332.10-14.00-1.04%
    GCZ16.CMX
    18.64-0.29-1.52%
    SIU16.CMX
    101.09-2.80-2.70%
    ^XAU
    2.10-0.02-0.78%
    HGU16.CMX
    47.59-0.51-1.06%
    CLV16.NYM
  • Bonds
    Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change
    1.13-0.02
    ^FVX
    1.54-0.01
    ^TNX
    2.23-0.01
    ^TYX