How Chicago Is Beating Silicon Valley At The Patent Game



Silicon Valley leads the world in technology but it’s losing a debate over how that technology should be used. A new surge in patent lawsuits shows that Chicago, not Silicon Valley, is setting the rules for how patents should encourage innovation.

The University of Chicago, through its Nobel-prize winning economists, is a champion of property rights and free market policies. Now, in the field of technology, Chicago’s ideas are also being used to justify harmful and expensive lawsuits.

Patent lawsuits made headlines yet again this month after Yahoo (NSDQ:YHOO - News) used ten questionable patents to claim that it, not Facebook, invented the social network. There have also been a rash of new suits by patent trolls—shell companies that don’t make anything but use patents to sue companies that do.

Trolls (known more politely as “non-practicing entities”) have been around for years but stepped into high gear in 2012. In the last two months, for instance, troll shell companies have unleashed lawsuits that claim monopolies on everything from emoticons to virtual goods in video games.

The problem is becoming worse. Top patent lawyers are leaving their firms to partner with hedge funds on new trolling ventures and super-troll Intellectual Ventures (reported to own more than 60,000 patents) is now suing with a vengeance. Meanwhile, mystery troll Lodsys is still demanding small app developers hand over two percent of revenues or else be taken to court over a common ‘in-app purchase’ feature.

So where does Chicago fit into all this? The answer is that it’s behind the “liquid market” theory of patents that gives a gloss of legitimacy to what many people would call extortion.

Chicago firms like Ocean Tomo, which runs intellectual property auctions, have helped popularize the idea of treating patents like widgets to be bought and sold. Lodsys front man, Mark Small, is also from Chicago. In their view, the patent status quo is working well.

The liquid market theory has a more formidable defender in Richard Epstein, a renowned University of Chicago law professor and Financial Times contributor. In an email exchange, he described trolls as “an overrated issue” and added,  “So long as there is quick closure, a patent is a wasting asset, and marketing beats lurking every time.”

This view—that treats patents as any other form property to be bought and sold—holds up in theory. But in practice, it’s dangerous because the property in question is not a widget but an idea that the owner can control and punish others for using. And since a patent is effectively a monopoly, the royalty demands seem less like a free market exchange than an old fashioned tax.

If Congress imposed a two percent tax “invention tax”, the politicians responsible would be voted out for a generation. But if a company like Lodsys does the same thing, it can claim to be promoting a free market.

The larger problem here is that a market for shaky patents is not a good idea in the first place. Do we think a complicated IRS tax is justified just because it creates a market for accounting services?

And if anyone doubts the patents are shaky, read what a former Yahoo engineer or a leading venture capitalist has to say about Yahoo’s so-called inventions. And these are just a small sample of the thousands of suspect patents fueling lawsuits and license demands.

The patent system is obviously dysfunctional and needs to be fixed but the role of patents in American mythology makes it hard to do so. To most people, the word “patent” still conjures images of Thomas Edison or Abraham Lincoln (US Patent 6469)—even though most of today’s patents are the product of lawyers and MBA’s using obtuse language to pressure a swamped and overworked patent office. The courts, meanwhile, are still in a state of confusion about what can and can’t be patented.

As for Silicon Valley developers, most know intuitively that innovation comes from sharing and collaboration and not from a single genius shrieking Eureka! For them and many academics, patent monopolies (especially those for software and “business methods”) are not a spur to research but a barrier.

These real inventors of Silicon Valley have champions of their own such as Mark Lemley, a Stanford professor and the country’s leading authority on patent law.

In a new paper called “The Myth of the Solo Inventor,” Lemley provides evidence that many famous inventions were produced by different people at the same time, and that patent owners typically sue independent inventors and not copycats. His work raises important questions about why patents are awarded in the first place.

Meanwhile, new economic research
suggests that free licensing is more efficient than patent monopolies to achieve technology breakthroughs and create large markets for new products.

For now, though, this research is going unheeded as Intellectual Ventures and others continue to spin Chicago-style theories to justify their troll taxes.

If Silicon Valley is to escape a circular firing squad of patent litigation, it must push back with its own homegrown patent theories. The recent SOPA victory taught engineers to flex their political muscles. Now, it’s time for them to flex their policy ones and restore sanity to the patent system.

(A final note: debates over innovation are, of course, taking place in many forms across the country. In this article, “Chicago” and “Silicon Valley” are simply used as shorthand for two very different visions of America’s patent system—one based on market theories and one based on how innovation actually works—and to point out that Chicago has gained the upper hand.)


More From


Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
  • How the Dow Jones industrial average fared on Tuesday Associated Press - 7 minutes ago

    Stocks fell slightly on Tuesday in another quiet day on Wall Street as hesitant investors remained on the sidelines as a slow summer winds down. On Tuesday: The Dow Jones industrial average fell 48.49 ... … More »

  • US stocks mostly lower as investors wait for jobs report
    US stocks mostly lower as investors wait for jobs report Associated Press - 10 minutes ago

    Stocks fell slightly on Tuesday in another quiet day on Wall Street as hesitant investors remained on the sidelines as a slow summer winds down. Shares of the candy company Hershey plunged after it walked ... … More »

  • Palo Alto forecasts revenue below estimates, shares drop
    Palo Alto forecasts revenue below estimates, shares drop Reuters - 11 minutes ago

    (Reuters) - Cyber security firm Palo Alto Networks Inc forecast current-quarter revenue and profit below analysts' estimates, sending its shares down 3 percent in extended trading on Tuesday. However, ... … More »

  • EU ruling on Apple stirs calls for U.S. tax reform
    EU ruling on Apple stirs calls for U.S. tax reform Reuters - 11 minutes ago

    A European Commission order requiring Apple Inc (AAPL.O) to pay Ireland $13 billion euros ($14.5 billion) in unpaid taxes on Tuesday drew swift rebukes from the Obama administration and lawmakers in Congress, while reigniting calls for U.S. tax … More »

  • CM posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 16 minutes ago

    The New York-based company said it had profit of 29 cents per share. Earnings, adjusted for investment costs, were 32 cents per share. The specialty finance company posted revenue of $7.8 million in the ... … More »

  • U.S. shares slip on Fed rate hike worries; dollar climbs Reuters - 27 minutes ago

    By Sam Forgione NEW YORK (Reuters) - U.S. stocks slipped on Tuesday after strong U.S. economic data stoked concerns about the impact of a potential Federal Reserve interest rate hike this year and a drop ... … More »

  • Ooma reports 2Q loss Associated Press - 28 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Palo Alto, California-based company said it had a loss of 19 cents. Losses, adjusted for stock option expense and amortization costs, came to 5 cents per share. The results exceeded ... … More »

  • Kurdish-backed fighters in Syria agree Turkey truce
    Kurdish-backed fighters in Syria agree Turkey truce AFP News - 31 minutes ago

    Kurdish-backed militias in Syria agreed Tuesday to a US initiative to stop fighting Turkish forces whose week-old incursion in the country has stoked tensions between Washington and Ankara. The truce was announced separately by a senior US defence … More »

  • Matrix Service beats 4Q profit forecasts Associated Press - 32 minutes ago

    The Tulsa, Oklahoma-based company said it had profit of 34 cents per share. The results beat Wall Street expectations. The average estimate of three analysts surveyed by Zacks Investment Research was for ... … More »

  • Markets Right Now: US markets end lower in quiet trading Associated Press - 49 minutes ago

    The latest on developments in global financial markets (all times local): 4:00 p.m. Stocks are closing slightly lower as a summer slowdown continues on Wall Street. Hershey slumped 11 percent and Mondelez ... … More »

  • Wall St. ends slightly lower as banks offset Apple drag
    Wall St. ends slightly lower as banks offset Apple drag Reuters - 50 minutes ago

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Apple Inc was the largest weight on U.S. stock indexes on Tuesday after antitrust regulators ordered the company to pay about $14.5 billion in back taxes to the Irish government, but ... … More »

  • Potash Corp, Agrium talk merger; competition scrutiny expected
    Potash Corp, Agrium talk merger; competition scrutiny expected Reuters - 52 minutes ago

    WINNIPEG, Manitoba/WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Canada's Agrium Inc (AGU.TO) and Potash Corp of Saskatchewan Inc (POT.TO) said on Tuesday they are in talks to merge, a deal that would create a fertiliser and farm retailing giant worth more than $25 … More »

  • S&P 500’s Monthly Gain in Peril as Apple Slumps; Dollar Climbs Bloomberg - 53 minutes ago

    The S&P 500 Index dropped from near a record high as the iPhone maker was ordered to pay a record 13 billion euros ($14.5 billion) plus interest in a European Union tax crackdown. Oil slipped below $47 a barrel ahead of a weekly U.S. inventory … More »

  • Deals of the day- Mergers and acquisitions Reuters - 1 hour 2 minutes ago

    ** Canada's Agrium Inc and Potash Corp of Saskatchewan Inc said on Tuesday they are in talks to merge, a tie-up that would create a global fertilizer and farm retailing giant as the agriculture sector struggles with soft crop prices. ** … More »

  • APNewsBreak: Ohio State tells alumni clubs to fall in line Associated Press - 1 hour 9 minutes ago

    Ohio State University is requiring its roughly 150 alumni clubs and societies to keep mum when it comes to disparaging comments about the school, or risk losing money and other perks it provides them. ... … More »

  • Grain lower, livestock higher Associated Press - 1 hour 12 minutes ago

    Grain futures were lower Tuesday on the Chicago Board of Trade. Wheat for Sept. fell 7.25 cents at $3.6325 a bushel; Sept. corn lost 7.75 cents to 3.04 a bushel; Sept. oats was off .25 cent at $1.6175 ... … More »

  • EU-U.S. trade deal in doubt as France urges end to talks
    EU-U.S. trade deal in doubt as France urges end to talks Reuters - 1 hour 15 minutes ago

    PARIS/BRUSSELS (Reuters) - France cast serious doubt on Tuesday on the prospects of an EU free trade deal with the United States, adding to opposition within Germany and growing scepticism among Americans. Washington and Brussels are officially … More »

  • Alaska agency turns to crowdfunding for park project
    Alaska agency turns to crowdfunding for park project Associated Press - 1 hour 31 minutes ago

    With Alaska's fiscal crisis drying up funding for a number of state projects, officials hope a crowdfunding campaign will raise $50,000 toward shoring up a crumbling riverbank creeping toward century-old ... … More »

  • Gold at six-week low as focus shifts to U.S. payrolls data
    Gold at six-week low as focus shifts to U.S. payrolls data Reuters - 1 hour 33 minutes ago

    NEW YORK/LONDON (Reuters) - Gold fell to a six-week low on Tuesday after Federal Reserve officials sounded a hawkish note on interest rates, boosting the dollar, while attention turned to U.S. payrolls data this week for further clues on the pace of … More »

  • Oil falls on strong dollar, crude glut; storms limit losses
    Oil falls on strong dollar, crude glut; storms limit losses Reuters - 1 hour 43 minutes ago

    Oil prices fell Tuesday, with Brent losing nearly 2 percent, as the dollar rallied and glut worries grew amid forecasts for higher U.S. crude stockpiles and Iran's remark that it was on target to reach peak production. News that energy companies in … More »

  • Templeton’s $130 Billion Man Finds Haven in Emerging Markets Bloomberg - 1 hour 59 minutes ago

    In this new economic world, emerging markets are becoming a surprising haven, according to Franklin Templeton bond manager Michael Hasenstab, who beat almost all his peers for years until making wrong-way bets on the yen and Treasuries. With … More »

  • EU hits Apple with 13 billion euro Irish tax demand
    EU hits Apple with 13 billion euro Irish tax demand Reuters - 2 hours 45 minutes ago

    BRUSSELS/DUBLIN (Reuters) - The European Commission ordered Apple Inc. to pay Ireland unpaid taxes of up to 13 billion euros ($14.5 billion) on Tuesday as it ruled the firm had received illegal state aid. Apple and Dublin said the U.S. company's … More »

  • Gamesa, Siemens reject GE's offer for Adwen JV - sources Reuters - 3 hours ago

    MADRID/FRANKFURT (Reuters) - Siemens and Gamesa have rejected a non-binding offer from General Electric for assets belonging to a wind power venture between Gamesa and Areva, sources close to the talks told Reuters on Tuesday. Spain's Gamesa is … More »

  • Rajoy seeks support for second term as Spanish PM
    Rajoy seeks support for second term as Spanish PM AFP News - 3 hours ago

    Spain's caretaker Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy on Tuesday urged lawmakers to back him for a second term, arguing ahead of a confidence vote which he appears set to lose that the country "urgently" needs a government. Rajoy, whose conservative … More »

  • Lactalis strikes price deal with French milk producers Reuters - 3 hours ago

    PARIS/RENNES (Reuters) - Lactalis, the world's largest dairy firm, reached a deal with French milk producers on Tuesday to raise prices paid to suppliers and farmers called off their week-long protests, the company and unions said. Lactalis agreed … More »

Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
to view quotes in your portfolios.


  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg

Market Data

  • Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change