Daily Ticker

Finally, A Rich American Destroys The Fiction That Rich People Create The Jobs

In the war of rhetoric that has developed in Washington as both sides blame each other for our economic mess, one argument has been repeated so often that many people now regard it as fact:

Rich people create the jobs.

Specifically, entrepreneurs and investors, when incented by low taxes, build companies and create millions of jobs.

And these entrepreneurs and investors, therefore, the argument goes, can solve our nation's huge unemployment problem — if only we cut taxes and regulations so they can be incented to build more companies and create more jobs.

In other words, by even considering raising taxes on "the 1%," we are considering destroying the very mechanism that makes our economy the strongest and biggest in the world: The incentive for entrepreneurs and investors to build companies in the hope of getting rich and, in the process, creating millions of jobs.

Now, there have long been many problems with this argument starting with

  1. Taxes on rich people (capital gains and income) are, relative to history, low, so raising them would only begin to bring them back in line with prior prosperous periods, and
  2. Dozens of rich entrepreneurs have already gone on record confirming that a modest hike in capital gains and income taxes would not have the slightest impact on their desire to create companies and jobs, given that tax rates are historically low.

So this argument, which many people regard as fact, is already flawed.

But now a super-rich and super-successful American has explained the most important reason the theory is absurd, while calling for higher taxes on himself and people like him.

The most important reason the theory that "rich people create the jobs" is absurd, argues Nick Hanauer, the founder of online advertising company aQuantive, which Microsoft bought for $6.4 billion, is that rich people do not create jobs, even if they found and build companies that eventually employ thousands of people.What creates the jobs, Hanauer astutely observes, is a healthy economic ecosystem surrounding the company, which starts with the company's customers.

The company's customers buy the company's products, which, in turn, creates the need for the employees to produce, sell, and service those products. If those customers go broke, the demand for the company's products will collapse. And the jobs will disappear, regardless of what the entrepreneur does.

Now, of course entrepreneurs are an important part of the company-creation process. And so are investors, who risk capital in the hope of earning returns. But, ultimately, whether a new company continues growing and creates self-sustaining jobs is a function of customers' ability and willingness to pay for the company's products, not the entrepreneur or the investor capital. Suggesting that "rich entrepreneurs and investors" create the jobs, therefore, Hanauer observes, is like suggesting that squirrels create evolution.

(Or, to put it even more simply, it's like saying that a seed creates a tree. The seed does not create the tree. The seed starts the tree. But what creates the tree is the combination of the DNA in the seed and the soil, sunshine, water, atmosphere, nutrients, and other factors that nurture it. Plant the seed in an inhospitable environment, and it won't create anything. It will die.)

So, then, if what creates the jobs in our economy is, in part, "customers," who are these customers? And what can government policy do to make sure these customers have more money to spend to create demand and, thus, jobs?

The customers of most companies, Hanauer points out, are ultimately the gigantic middle class — the hundreds of millions of Americans who currently take home a much smaller share of the national income than they did 30 years ago, before tax policy aimed at helping rich people get richer created an extreme of income and wealth inequality not seen since the 1920s.

The middle class has been pummeled, in part, by tax policies that reward "the 1%" at the expense of everyone else.(It has also been pummeled by globalization and technology improvements, which are largely outside of any one country's control.)

But, wait, aren't the huge pots of gold taken home by "the 1%" supposed to "trickle down" to the middle class and thus benefit everyone? Isn't that the way it's supposed to work?

Yes, that's the way it's supposed to work.

Unfortunately, that's not the way it actually works.

And Hanauer explains why.

Hanauer takes home more than $10 million a year of income. On this income, he says, he pays an 11% tax rate. (Presumably, most of the income is dividends and long-term capital gains, which carry a tax rate of 15%. And then he probably has some tax shelters that knock the rate down the rest of the way).

With the more than $9 million a year Hanauer keeps, he buys lots of stuff. But, importantly, he doesn't buy as much stuff as would be bought if that $9 million were instead earned by 9,000 Americans each taking home an extra $1,000 a year.

Why not?

Because, despite Hanauer's impressive lifestyle — his family owns a plane — most of the $9+ million just goes straight into the bank (where it either sits and earns interest or gets invested in companies that ultimately need strong demand to sell products and create jobs). For a specific example, Hanauer points out that his family owns 3 cars, not the 3,000 that might be bought if his $9+ million were taken home by a few thousand families.

If that $9+ million had gone to 9,000 families instead of Hanauer, it would almost certainly have been pumped right back into the economy via consumption (i.e., demand). And, in so doing, it would have created more jobs.

Hanauer estimates that, if most American families were taking home the same share of the national income that they were taking home 30 years ago, every family would have another $10,000 of disposable income to spend.

That, Hanauer points out, would have a huge impact on demand — and, thereby job creation.

It's time we stopped mouthing the fiction that "rich people create the jobs."

Rich people don't create the jobs.

Our economy creates jobs.

We're all in this together. And until we return to more reasonable tax policies that help the 99% instead of just the 1%, our economy is going to go nowhere.

Read Nick Hanauer's editorial here.

UPDATE: This article stuck a nerve, spawning vehement agreement and disagreement. The two smartest arguments made by those who believe that rich people DO create the jobs are that 1) the success of Silicon Valley proves that entrepreneurs and investors create the jobs, and 2) the observation that brilliant entrepreneurs like Steve Jobs create demand out of thin air by inventing products people didn't know they wanted. These arguments sound seductive and persuasive, but they miss the key point. Click this follow-up to see why: No, Entrepreneurs Like Steve Jobs Do Not "Create Jobs" By Inventing Products Like The iPhone

SEE ALSO: The Truth About Tax Rates: Rich People Have Rarely Had It So Good

  • Asia stocks ease, dollar steadies after Fed-led losses
    Asia stocks ease, dollar steadies after Fed-led losses Reuters - 2 hours 9 minutes ago

    By Nichola Saminather SINGAPORE (Reuters) - Asian stocks pulled back from a 19-month high on Thursday, while the dollar tried to steady from losses suffered in the wake of the U.S. Federal Reserve minutes ... … More »

  • Solar Capital meets 4Q profit forecasts Associated Press - 2 hours 24 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the New York-based company said it had profit of 42 cents. The results met Wall Street expectations. The average estimate of four analysts surveyed by Zacks Investment Research was ... … More »

  • SP Plus posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 2 hours 24 minutes ago

    The Chicago-based company said it had profit of 43 cents per share. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, came to 52 cents per share. The parking facility management company posted revenue of ... … More »

  • U.S. oil rises after report shows drop in stockpiles
    U.S. oil rises after report shows drop in stockpiles Reuters - 2 hours 26 minutes ago

    TOKYO (Reuters) - U.S. oil futures rose nearly 1 percent on Thursday after data released by an industry group showed a surprise decline in U.S. crude stocks as imports fell, lending support to the view ... … More »

  • CoreLogic beats Street 4Q forecasts Associated Press - 2 hours 28 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Irvine, California-based company said it had profit of 4 cents. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, were 56 cents per share. The results exceeded Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

  • Tesla swings to loss in 4Q, says Model 3 on target
    Tesla swings to loss in 4Q, says Model 3 on target Associated Press - 2 hours 33 minutes ago

    Unable to string together profitable quarters, electric car and solar cell maker Tesla Inc. reported a loss for the last three months of 2016. Tesla posted its first profit in three years in last year's ... … More »

  • UK car production reaches nine-year high in January Reuters - 2 hours 33 minutes ago

    British car production rose by an annual 7.5 percent in January to hit its highest since 2008, as strong demand for exports compensated for a decline in demand at home, an industry body said on Thursday. Vauxhall's Ellesmere Port plant in northern … More »

  • Tokyo stocks open lower AFP - 2 hours 40 minutes ago

    Tokyo stocks opened lower Thursday as the yen strengthened against the dollar and investors contemplated the minutes from the US Federal Reserve's latest meeting. The benchmark Nikkei 225 index slipped ... … More »

  • Alleghany posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 2 hours 42 minutes ago

    The New York-based company said it had profit of $4.50 per share. Earnings, adjusted for non-recurring costs, came to $7.02 per share. The property and casualty insurance provider posted revenue of $1.46 ... … More »

  • Top banks' commodities revenue drops 7 percent in 2016 - survey
    Top banks' commodities revenue drops 7 percent in 2016 - survey Reuters - 2 hours 46 minutes ago

    LONDON (Reuters) - Commodities-related revenue at the 12 biggest investment banks fell by 7 percent last year, mainly due to weakness in the oil sector, a report by financial industry analytics firm Coalition ... … More »

  • Lower fares hit Qantas first half profit
    Lower fares hit Qantas first half profit AFP News - 2 hours 51 minutes ago

    Australian carrier Qantas Airways posted Thursday a 7.5 percent hit to first half earnings, impacted by lower fares, greater competition and empty seats. Underlying profit before tax fell to Aus$852 million (US$656 million) for the six months … More »

  • Fitbit reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 2 hours 52 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the San Francisco-based company said it had a loss of 65 cents. Losses, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, came to 56 cents per share. The results did not meet Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

  • Lower fares hit Qantas first half profit AFP - 2 hours 53 minutes ago

    Australian carrier Qantas Airways posted Thursday a 7.5 percent hit to first half earnings, impacted by lower fares, greater competition and empty seats. Underlying profit before tax fell to Aus$852 million ... … More »

  • Air NZ flies into turbulence as competition heats up
    Air NZ flies into turbulence as competition heats up AFP News - 2 hours 55 minutes ago

    Air New Zealand reported a 24 percent fall in interim net profit Thursday amid increased competition in the domestic aviation market. New Zealand's flag carrier said net profit for the six months to December 31 was NZ$256 million (US$184 million), … More »

  • 3 Reasons Why You Should Consider Buying Gold Now
    3 Reasons Why You Should Consider Buying Gold Now ValuePenguin - 2 hours 59 minutes ago

    This is because gold is perceived as an "alternate" currency whose value does not depreciate along with your ordinary paper money. While commodities as a whole have faced a bear market in recent years — the Bloomberg Commodity Index, which tracks … More »

  • The good times are back for copper. Here’s why
    The good times are back for copper. Here’s why Truewealth Publishing - 2 hours 59 minutes ago

    Not long ago, Dr. Copper was sick. Today the doctor is looking a lot healthier. It’s been a rough few years for copper. Since hitting all-time highs of US$10,250/metric tonne in February 2011, it has suffered nearly 6 years of tumbling prices. As … More »

  • OPEC Still Waiting for Evidence Oil Cuts Are Doing Their Job Bloomberg - 2 hours 59 minutes ago

    A reduction in the amount of oil held in storage around the world is the most important factor for the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries, Qatar’s Energy Minister Mohammed Al Sada said at the IP Week conference in London Wednesday. The … More »

  • Nissan appoints Hiroto Saikawa as CEO Reuters - 3 hours ago

    (Reuters) - Nissan Motor Co Ltd said on Wednesday it has appointed the company's co-chief executive officer, Hiroto Saikawa, as Nissan's chief executive, effective April 1. Carlos Ghosn, chairman of the ... … More »

  • Tesla Stays Steady With Model 3 as Musk Loses Latest Executive Bloomberg - 3 hours ago

    The Model 3 sedan, Tesla’s cheapest plug-in vehicle yet, remains on track to arrive in July, and production of the car should reach about 5,000 units by the end of the year, according to a letter to shareholders Wednesday related to the company’s … More »

  • Tredegar posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    On a per-share basis, the Richmond, Virginia-based company said it had net income of 5 cents. Earnings, adjusted for non-recurring costs, were 10 cents per share. The plastic films maker posted revenue ... … More »

  • Ansys beats Street 4Q forecasts Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    The Canonsburg, Pennsylvania-based company said it had profit of 80 cents per share. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, came to 98 cents per share. The results topped Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

  • Cenveo reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    The Stamford, Connecticut-based company said it had a loss of 3 cents per share. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, were 3 cents per share. The printing and packaging company posted revenue ... … More »

  • Global stocks fade from record highs, dollar falls on Fed minutes
    Global stocks fade from record highs, dollar falls on Fed minutes Reuters - 3 hours ago

    By Richard Leong NEW YORK (Reuters) - Global stocks pulled back from record highs on Wednesday while the dollar declined after minutes from the U.S. Federal Reserve offered little to support the notion ... … More »

  • Tesla has finished its investigation into Fremont plant working conditions and will release findings soon
    Tesla has finished its investigation into Fremont plant working conditions and will release findings soon Business Insider - 3 hours ago

    Scott Olson/Getty Images Elon Musk. Tesla CEO Elon … Continued The post Tesla has finished its investigation into Fremont plant working conditions and will release findings soon appeared first on Business Insider. … More »

  • Activist Glaucus Travels 10,000 Miles to Find Next Big Short (1)
    Activist Glaucus Travels 10,000 Miles to Find Next Big Short (1) Bloomberg - 3 hours ago

    The co-founder of Glaucus Research Group flew more than 10,000 miles (16,090 kilometers) from his base in Austin, Texas, to Australia, where he’s looking at companies including commodity producers. From his new firm in London, former Goldman Sachs … More »

Editors' Picks

Subscribe and RSS

[X]

How to subscribe

Roll over each section to subscribe using Add to My Yahoo or RSS Feed feeds.

Yahoo News offers dozens of RSS feeds you can read on My Yahoo or using a third-party RSS news reader software. Click here to find out more about RSS and how you can use it with Yahoo News.
 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.