Why The Fight Over The $1 Trillion Coin Is The Most Important Fiscal Policy Debate You'll Ever See In Your Life

The campaign to circumvent the debt ceiling by having the Treasury mint a trillion dollar platinum coin continues to infiltrate the minds of elite thinkers in Washington.

Paul Krugman has come out in favor of it. Congressman Jerry Nadler is in favor of it. Pretty much every major news organization is discussing it. Even Stephen Colbert talked about it last night.

As Jonathan Chait at NYMag observes, what's interesting is that there are very few good arguments, legal or economic, against minting the coin.

Most of the critics' arguments basically boil down to: It's just not serious, and it would make the US monetary and political system look like a farce.

Here are some representative examples:

Here's Reuters' Felix Salmon: "If you believe that the country is best run by grown-ups, you can’t believe in #mintthecoin, because it simply isn’t a grown-up strategy."

And here's The Guardian's Heidi Moore: "A small but relentless group of impish bloggers and columnists – including Joe Weisenthal of Business Insider and Josh Barro of Bloomberg, as well as hapless Congressman Jerry Nadler – have created a large-scale trolling project that is meant to pressure the US Treasury into creating a trillion-dollar platinum coin to solve this problem."

And here's CNBC's Eamon Javers on Twitter: "...reason not to do the coin is it makes mockery of US financial system and risks shaking confidence in it."

But contrary to all these people who say that this is a childish, non-adult proposal put forth by impish trolls, it's actually quite the opposite. It may be the most important fiscal policy debate you'll ever seen in your lifetime, because it gets right to the nature of what is money.

This question is central to any discussion about a country's monetary and fiscal policy, and yet it's almost never discussed, and virtually nobody understands it.

Almost everyone talking about fiscal policy imagines money to be a commodity of sorts that we can "run out" of if we don't spend it carefully. In this sense, although we've long gotten rid of the gold standard, we're still shackled with a gold standard mentality, where we think of money as a scarce natural resource that we need to husband carefully, lest one day the bond vigilantes show up at our door, causing us to go broke.

The critics of #MintTheCoin are very forthright in attacking the proposal from this view.

When GOP Congressman Greg Walden introduced his bill proposing a ban on minting a trillion dollar coin, he specifically likened a government to a small business: "

“My wife and I have owned and operated a small business since 1986. When it came time to pay the bills, we couldn’t just mint a coin to create more money out of thin air. We sat down and figured out how to balance the books. That’s what Washington needs to do as well. My bill will take the coin scheme off the table by disallowing the Treasury to mint platinum coins as a way to pay down the debt. We must reduce spending and get our fiscal house in order."

Judson Berger at Fox News uses a similar analogy to describe why minting the coin would be "absurd":

"Imagine sitting around the kitchen table, trying to figure out how you're going to pay off that next-generation HDTV you just bought.  Then someone has an idea. Brush off one of the old checker pieces in the attic, assign it a value of, say, $2,000 -- and use that newly minted "coin" to pay the credit card. Such an absurd idea is, pun intended, gaining currency as a technically legal way for Washington to avert a looming fight over the debt ceiling."

But these complaints actually get at the crux of the matter. Creating money is exactly what government does. What's absurd for a private business is not absurd for the government.

As John Maynard Keynes simply put it a long time ago: "Money is the creation of the state."

That the state creates the money we use is actually known to just about everyone, but people have a hard time making the key leap, which is that once the state is in the business of creating money, then the old gold standard notions of monetary scarcity don't apply in the same way.

You can see this flawed thinking all the time.

It's because people think that money is scarce that they think that gigantic government debts and deficits will lead to surging interest rates, because our lenders worry that we might not be good for it.

And yet, as this chart shows, as the national debt has surged (red line) the interest that the government pays on the debt (blue line) has gone down.

And it's because people think that money is a finite good (the gold standard mentality) that many people assumed that the Fed "creating money" (by expanding the money supply through quantitative easing) would cause hyperinflation to happen.

In fact, as the chart shows, the explosion of the money supply (red line) has coincided with muted inflation (blue line).

 Clearly, economic predictions that were predicted on money being finite have proven to be wrong.

This is why the coin debate is so crucial. Whereas most fiscal policy debates talk about what we're going to do with our money, or why we need to be careful not to run out, the coin gets right to the heart of the matter.

Stephanie Kelton, an economics professor at the University of Missouri Kansas City and one of the earliest defenders of the coin, explained via email:

Until the idea of minting a $1 trillion coin became a reality, most people probably never gave much thought to the government’s financial operations.  We understood that the government spent money, and we knew the money had to come from “somewhere”, but we assumed there were limits to how much the government could afford to spend.  

Like a household, we were told that the government could spend more than it takes in, but only as long as private lenders remained willing to extend credit.  Borrow too much, and your credit rating will suffer.  From there, it’s a hop, skip and a jump to “shared sacrifice” and “tough choices” to avoid becoming the next Greece.   

Enter the coin.  An idea so simple the mind recoils.  The Treasury has the power to end-run the process by cutting out the middlemen – taxpayers and bond markets –simply directing the Federal Reserve to add some numbers to its balance sheet.  Saints preserve us!   People are freaking out because the coin appears to remove the constraints on government finance by allowing the government to just “print” money.  The truth is, the government is already the issuer of the currency.  It is already not revenue constrained.  The coin doesn’t change anything fundamental, but most people don’t realize this because   they don’t know anything about the mechanics of the way the government currently gets numbers into its account at the Fed.

Cullen Roche, who blogs at Pragmatic Capitalist, and whose blog it was where we first came across the Trillion Dollar Coin idea put it similarly:

...the big lesson from all of this is that the coin proves an autonomous govt has no solvency constraint if it so chooses.  A prolonged and permanent financing of govt expenditure literally changes the way our system works though.  So it's important to understand the distinction between our current design (which privatizes money to the banking system) and a permanent coin solution which gives the power to the govt.  But it still highlights the power of an autonomous govt in its ability to fund its spending. 

In addition to exploding the myth about government being artificially constrained by an "amount" of money, the debate re-kindles the notion of seigniorage, the process by which governments make money via the creation of money.

Philip Diehl, the former head of the US Mint that helped draft the law enabling the platinum coin explained to us via email how funding the government via the creation of money is a history going back thousands of years.

What is seignorage?  Seigniorage is the difference between the face value of a coin and its cost of production. Say a quarter costs 11 cents to produce; banks pay 25 cents for the coin and the government books 14 cents in seignorage . When (more often, if) the coin is returned to the Mint damaged or worn out, the seigniorage is reversed on the books and the coin melted.  In this way seigniorage is like an interest-free loan for the life of the coin, and if the coin is never returned to the Mint, it is an interest-free loan in perpetuity.  

The history of seignorage dates back more than 2000 years, to the earliest days when governments issued coinage. When precious metals were used, the intrinsic value of the coin was slightly less than the face value, providing a means of financing the government . If the precious metal content were reduced, the currency was said to have been "debased". If this were done by the Crown, so be it. If it were done by the Mint director, he was hanged. 

The history of American coinage is more interesting than one might expect. Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton, otherwise bitter political antagonists, cooperated in creating the nation's coinage and founding the U.S. Mint. Jefferson had been thinking about an American system of coinage since the days he was writing the Declaration of Independence. He was intent on avoiding the non-decimal systems of Europe in order to simply commercial transactions and democratize the nation's economy, especially for the illiterate and innumerate. The first Mint was located in Philadelphia in a converted brewery, down the street from the home of the new president. Martha Washington is said to have donated some of the family silverware for the minting of the nation's first coins.  The institution of an American coinage system was a remarkable achievement. At the time, coinage from multiple countries was used in commerce. These competing means of exchange had to be gradually crowded out by the new American coinage and finally demonetized. We might think of this as an early 19th century American version of the introduction of the Euro.

In order to have a "serious" debate about fiscal policy, as so many pundits claim to want, we must first understand what money is, and how governments get it.

The answer is that they have always created it, and any notion of the government "running out" are illogical.

Remember, money is a fiction. Real wealth is capital assets, our infrastructure, our cars, our houses, and most importantly the potential human ingenuity and cooperation. Money is just something that the government creates to facilitate the trade in all of those things.

The #MintTheCoin debate, more than any other fiscal debate we can remember, gets right to this matter.

Find out everything you need to know about the trillion dollar coin below:

Please enable Javascript to watch this video

SEE ALSO: 3 myths about the mint the coin debate >

More From Business Insider


Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
  • PharMerica beats 4Q profit forecasts Associated Press - 1 hour 30 minutes ago

    The Louisville, Kentucky-based company said it had net income of 25 cents per share. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, came to 58 cents per share. The results beat Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

  • BRIEF-Tdm says Jan fresh fruits bunches production 33,144.23 MT Reuters - 1 hour 32 minutes ago

    Feb 24 (Reuters) - Tdm Bhd * Jan fresh fruits bunches production 33,144.23 mt, crude palm oil production 5,849.54 mt, palm kernel production 1,597.45 mt Source ( http://bit.ly/2lzDSOU ) Further company ... … More »

  • Ellen, Wal-Mart give scholarships to school's senior class
    Ellen, Wal-Mart give scholarships to school's senior class Associated Press - 1 hour 35 minutes ago

    Ellen DeGeneres has handed out college scholarships to the entire senior class of a New York City charter school. DeGeneres surprised the 41 students from Brooklyn's Summit Academy this week at her California ... … More »

  • China, France overtake US as top German trade partners
    China, France overtake US as top German trade partners Associated Press - 1 hour 39 minutes ago

    New statistics show that China and France have overtaken the U.S. as Germany's largest trading partners. Germany's Federal Statistical Office reported Friday that trade between the country and China in ... … More »

  • Bitcoin is hovering near all-time highs
    Bitcoin is hovering near all-time highs Business Insider - 1 hour 43 minutes ago

    Reuters/Bobby Yip Bitcoin on Friday pulled back slightly … Continued The post Bitcoin is hovering near all-time highs appeared first on Business Insider. … More »

  • Gold hits 3-1/2-month high as 'Trumpflation trade' fades
    Gold hits 3-1/2-month high as 'Trumpflation trade' fades Reuters - 1 hour 44 minutes ago

    Gold hit its highest in about 3-1/2 months on Friday as the dollar headed for its first week of decline in three after the new U.S. finance chief poured cold water on the "Trumpflation trade" that had boosted the greenback this year. Treasury … More »

  • Telkom Said to Mull Purchase of Cell C Debt in Ownership Bid (1) Bloomberg - 1 hour 44 minutes ago

    Cell C creditors approached Telkom to help reorganize debt that includes 640 million euros ($677 million) of bonds maturing in July 2018, said the people, who asked not to be identified because discussions are private. Telkom, whose attempts to … More »

  • BASF's fourth-quarter operating profit boosted by higher petrochemical prices Reuters - 1 hour 46 minutes ago

    Germany's BASF (BASFn.DE), the world's largest chemicals group by sales, forecast a rebound in earnings this year after higher petrochemical prices boosted profits in the final three months of 2016. The company, whose products include catalytic … More »

  • Bundesbank official warns London banks against post-Brexit tricks
    Bundesbank official warns London banks against post-Brexit tricks Reuters - 1 hour 50 minutes ago

    UK-based banks that want to operate across the European Union after Brexit must set up genuine operations, not 'empty shells' in EU countries, a Bundesbank official said on Friday. Andreas Dombret, the Bundesbank board member responsible for … More »

  • J.C. Penney to Shut as Many as 140 Stores as Industry Slumps (1) Bloomberg - 1 hour 51 minutes ago

    The closings represent as much as 14 percent of the company’s store base and less than 5 percent of total sales, J.C. Penney said Friday. J.C. Penney’s plan echoes rival Macy’s Inc.’s announcement last year that it would shut about 100 of its … More »

  • Standard Chartered shares fall as it withholds dividend but lifts bonuses Reuters - 1 hour 52 minutes ago

    LONDON/HONG KONG (Reuters) - Standard Chartered (STAN.L) shares fell as much as 5 percent on Friday as the British bank said it would not pay a dividend for 2016 due to restructuring costs, but increased its staff bonus pool by 5 percent. The bonus … More »

  • BRIEF-Borneo Oil bhd updates on January production Reuters - 1 hour 56 minutes ago

    Feb 24 (Reuters) - Borneo Oil Bhd: * Jan ores mined 48,936.80 mt , Jan production of gold dore 72.54 oz Source text: Further company coverage: … More »

  • PSEG reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 1 hour 57 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Newark, New Jersey-based company said it had a loss of 19 cents. Earnings, adjusted for non-recurring costs, came to 54 cents per share. The results surpassed Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

  • Harsco reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 2 hours 3 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Camp Hill, Pennsylvania-based company said it had a loss of 19 cents. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, came to 16 cents per share. The industrial services company ... … More »

  • E.W. Scripps beats Street 4Q forecasts Associated Press - 2 hours 3 minutes ago

    The Cincinnati-based company said it had profit of 46 cents per share. The results exceeded Wall Street expectations. The average estimate of three analysts surveyed by Zacks Investment Research was for ... … More »

  • Exit by Polish Top Brass Guts Command on NATO Front Line (2) Bloomberg - 2 hours 3 minutes ago

    With the government moving to rid institutions of officials appointed by the former ruling Civic Platform party, which it defeated in 2015 elections, 90 percent of the General Staff leadership and more than 80 percent of the army’s top brass have … More »

  • Portugal could exit excessive deficit in spring - EU's Dombrovskis Reuters - 2 hours 8 minutes ago

    Portugal is set to exit the EU excessive deficit procedure if the European Commission confirms its latest forecasts for this year and next in a new assessment in the spring, a top EU official said on Friday. Lisbon says it cut the budget deficit … More »

  • EHealth reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 2 hours 13 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Mountain View, California-based company said it had a loss of 91 cents. Losses, adjusted for stock option expense and amortization costs, came to 79 cents per share. The results ... … More »

  • China overtakes US as Germany's top trade partner AFP - 2 hours 14 minutes ago

    China overtook the United States last year to become Germany's biggest trading partner for the first time, official data showed, a shift likely to reassure Berlin as worries grow over US President Donald ... … More »

  • Calgon reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 2 hours 27 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Moon Township, Pennsylvania-based company said it had a loss of 12 cents. Earnings, adjusted for non-recurring costs, were 5 cents per share. The results fell short of Wall Street ... … More »

  • Global stocks fall amid Trump trade policy concerns
    Global stocks fall amid Trump trade policy concerns Associated Press - 2 hours 27 minutes ago

    Global stocks fell Friday amid worries about the potential impact of U.S. trade policies and as investors became more cautious about the market's recent rally. KEEPING SCORE: France's CAC 40 slumped 1.4 ... … More »

  • Will the legend of Nokia 3310 see its comeback?
    Will the legend of Nokia 3310 see its comeback? International Business Times - 2 hours 28 minutes ago

    Nokia 3310 is truly a legendary phone that deserves a revival from HMD Global. … More »

  • IStar reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 2 hours 28 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the New York-based company said it had a loss of 27 cents. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, were 4 cents per share. The commercial real estate finance company posted ... … More »

  • Scomi records RM6.17m net loss Business Times - 2 hours 37 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: Scomi Group Bhd has recorded its third consecutive quarter in the red, with a net loss of RM6.17 million for the quarter ended December 31, 2017 on falling revenue and profit. The company was in the red mainly due to the almost 90 per … More »

  • China steams past U.S., France to be Germany's biggest trading partner Reuters - 2 hours 42 minutes ago

    China for the first time became Germany's most important trading partner in 2016, overtaking the United States, which fell back to third place behind France, data showed on Friday. German imports from and exports to China rose to 170 billion euros … More »

Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
to view quotes in your portfolios.


  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg

Market Data

  • Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change