Stock-Picking Is a Fool's Errand

BOSTON (TheStreet) -- In case it wasn't already clear, new studies show that index investing is the way to go.

That means fund managers, advisers and brokers largely don't help individual investors.

Three separate research reports, issued together by the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College, conclude, variously, that individual investors have poor stock-picking skills, investment advisers' advice is frequently not in clients' best interest, and that profits from value-style investing can be, at best, illusory.

All of which, the organization says, "raises serious questions about buying individual stocks or actively invested stock funds."

10 Ways Your 401(k) Can Fail You >>

And one of the studies even takes on the investment record of the Oracle of Omaha, billionaire investor Warren Buffett, and finds that his long-term results probably aren't repeatable.

Individual investors are woefully ineffective in managing their own portfolios successfully without a modicum of luck, according to a study by four professors at Germany's University of Goethe, published March 15.

They tracked 8,600 individual investor portfolios from a German online broker for five years, through April 2010, measuring their performances against a four-factor model's benchmark "to distinguish skill from luck" in stock-picking success. They found that about 89% of individual investors have "negative skill" since, by their calculations, a portfolio, "with an average level of risk-taking" underperformed the model's benchmark by 7.5% on a gross-return basis and by 8.5% net of expenses.

"It can thus be concluded that the large majority of individual investors do not have the skill to outperform the market -- and if they do, it is mere luck," the study concludes.

Value-oriented investing, which relies on the analysis of financial fundamentals to find undervalued companies, was put under the microscope by Aswath Damodaran of the Stern School of Business at New York University, and found wanting.

"Of all of the investment philosophies, value investing comes with the most impressive research backing from both academia and practitioners," he writes in the April report.

How to Turn Apple's Stock Into an Income Stream >>

The excess returns earned by stocks that fit value criteria, including low multiples of earnings and book value and high dividends and the success of some high-profile value investors, such as Buffett, "draws investors into the active value investing fold," Damodaran said.

The study analyzed the relative success of the different types of value investing: passive, built around screening for stocks; contrarian, or investing in companies that are down on their luck; and active, described as taking large positions in poorly managed and low-valued companies and making money from turning them around, in reaching its conclusions.

It found that "while value investing looks impressive on paper, the performance of value investors, as a whole, is no better than that of less 'sensible' investors who chose other investment philosophies and strategies.

"The only funds that beat their index counterparts are growth funds, and they do so in all three market cap classes," it said. "Active value investing funds generally do the worst of any group of funds and particularly so with large market-cap companies."

Buffett's success also gets scrutinized. "Given his track record, you would expect a large number of imitators," said Damodaran. "Why, then, do we not see other investors, using his approach, replicate his success?"

That's because his early successes came at a time when macro-economic risks were mild, he said, and today's market is so much more competitive because information on companies and trading strategies is widely available and dozens of other money managers are also looking for bargains in value stocks.

And, lately, Buffett has adopted a more activist investment style that he has used to good effect, but there are few, if any, big money managers who can duplicate the impact of his influence on a company's management given his reputation, Damodaran said.

Another key ingredient in Buffett's success, his investors' patience, is something that today's money managers don't enjoy as they demand immediate results, he adds.

10 Stocks That Won't Leave You High and Dry >>

And, finally, Harvard professor Sendhil Mullainathan, a special adviser to the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, led a study published by the National Bureau of Economic Research, aimed at testing the quality of advice provided by professional investment advisers to retail investors.

It is based on results of 284 visits to financial advisers in the Boston area between April and August 2008 by "auditors" who impersonated prospective customers for purposes of the study.

Mullainathan and his co-authors found that those advisers tended to give advice that supported the prospective clients' prior beliefs "for fear of losing the client," but at the same time had "no problem discouraging clients from investing more in their current strategies if this is not in the interest of the advisor."

It also found that advisers' recommendations for the same portfolios or investment scenarios presented by the auditors varied significantly. "Most strikingly, they were unsupportive of the (efficient) index portfolio and suggested a change to actively managed funds. Overall, advisers had a significant bias toward active management" and they sometimes "push clients towards funds with higher expected fees with little change in portfolio diversification."

Actively managed portfolios generate significantly more income for financial advisers than do passively managed index funds.

In many instances, it was found that advisers were reluctant to disclose advice about their investment style or the performances before the individual agreed to transfer their account to the adviser's firm, the study found, which "is, to some extent, comparable to a car dealer who asks first for a down payment before agreeing to a test drive of a car."

--

Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
Loading...
  • Gold steady ahead of Trump's policy speech Reuters - 2 hours 5 minutes ago

    The metal hit its highest since Nov. 11 at $1,263.80 in the previous session. * U.S. gold futures (GCcv1) fell 0.5 percent to $1,252.70. * Investors are looking towards U.S. President Donald Trump's policy speech to a joint session of Congress on … More »

  • Snap expects some IPO investors to make year-long commitments
    Snap expects some IPO investors to make year-long commitments Reuters - 2 hours 9 minutes ago

    While Snap cautioned it had no binding commitments yet from investors accepting such a lock-up period, the disclosure is a sign of confidence from the company in what is expected to be the biggest U.S. IPO since Facebook Inc (FB.O). A year-long … More »

  • Snap expects some IPO investors to make year-long commitments
    Snap expects some IPO investors to make year-long commitments Reuters - 2 hours 10 minutes ago

    While Snap cautioned it had no binding commitments yet from investors accepting such a lock-up period, the disclosure is a sign of confidence from the company in what is expected to be the biggest U.S. IPO since Facebook Inc (FB.O). A year-long … More »

  • Snap expects some IPO investors to make year-long commitments
    Snap expects some IPO investors to make year-long commitments Reuters - 2 hours 13 minutes ago

    While Snap cautioned it had no binding commitments yet from investors accepting such a lock-up period, the disclosure is a sign of confidence from the company in what is expected to be the biggest U.S. IPO since Facebook Inc. A year-long lock-up … More »

  • Self-driving Nissan car takes to Europe's streets for first time Reuters - 2 hours 29 minutes ago

    Guided by cameras and radars, and negotiating traffic and roundabouts, a self-driving Nissan car took to the streets of London on Monday for the Japanese company's first European tests of an autonomous vehicle. Travelling at up to 50 miles (80 km) … More »

  • Belmond posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 2 hours 32 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Hamilton, Bermuda-based company said it had profit of 7 cents. Earnings, adjusted for non-recurring gains and to account for discontinued operations, came to 1 cent per share. ... … More »

  • JBT posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 2 hours 34 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Chicago-based company said it had profit of 77 cents. Earnings, adjusted for restructuring costs and to account for discontinued operations, were 85 cents per share. The food ... … More »

  • BRIEF-Mitrajaya entered into a global JV agreement with Gema Padu Reuters - 2 hours 35 minutes ago

    Feb 28 (Reuters) - Mitrajaya Holdings Bhd * On 27 Feb entered into a global joint venture agreement with Gema Padu Sdn Bhd for 181.2 million RGT * Deal to jointly develop various parcels of land in Selangor ... … More »

  • Black Stone Minerals misses Street 4Q forecasts Associated Press - 2 hours 39 minutes ago

    The Houston-based company said it had net income of 1 cent per share. The results missed Wall Street expectations. The average estimate of five analysts surveyed by Zacks Investment Research was for earnings ... … More »

  • BHP Says `Bloody Awful' Trade Pledges Threaten Trump's Pump (1) Bloomberg - 2 hours 49 minutes ago

    (Bloomberg) -- The head of the world’s biggest mining company intensified his warnings that U.S. trade protectionism under President Donald Trump would threaten global growth and the fight against poverty. … More »

  • Maiden Holdings reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 2 hours 51 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Hamilton, Bermuda-based company said it had a loss of 87 cents. Losses, adjusted for one-time items, came to 81 cents per share. The reinsurance holding company posted revenue ... … More »

  • Japan January retail sales rise 1.0 percent year/year - government
    Japan January retail sales rise 1.0 percent year/year - government Reuters - 3 hours ago

    TOKYO (Reuters) - Japanese retail sales rose 1.0 percent in January from a year earlier, versus a median market forecast for a 0.9 percent increase, government data showed on Tuesday. To view full tables, ... … More »

  • UK consumer morale dips as inflation pinches households - GfK Reuters - 3 hours ago

    British consumer morale edged lower in February as rising inflation following last year's Brexit vote made householders warier about the outlook for their finances, surveys showed. Two separate reports conducted by market research firms GfK and … More »

  • South Korea's March business sentiment improves slightly
    South Korea's March business sentiment improves slightly Reuters - 3 hours ago

    An index measuring South Korean business confidence showed that manufacturers turned slightly more optimistic about business conditions for the month ahead as exports continued to grow, a central bank survey showed on Tuesday. The Bank of Korea's … More »

  • Shell Shuns New Oil Sands as Low Crude Prices Force Cost Control Bloomberg - 3 hours ago

    While Shell’s existing oil-sands operations generate strong cash flows, the expense of developing new projects discourages additional investments, Chief Executive Officer Ben Van Beurden said in an interview. Oil sands, the reserves of heavy crude … More »

  • How to put a number to “uncertainty” – and what it means for markets
    How to put a number to “uncertainty” – and what it means for markets Truewealth Publishing - 3 hours ago

    Markets hate uncertainty. But lots of uncertainty – as there is now – doesn’t mean that markets won’t go up. Uncertainty is more subjective than (say) volatility, or stock market valuations, or the price performance of assets. To most people, … More »

  • Exxon's Post-Tillerson Fortunes Closer to Home as New CEO Pivots Bloomberg - 3 hours ago

    After a two-year pricing rout erased 19 percent of Exxon’s untapped crude by making it unprofitable to extract, Woods faces a tough task in sustaining the company’s output. Woods’s first public appearance since becoming chief executive officer is … More »

  • Japan January industrial output falls 0.8 percent month/month - government
    Japan January industrial output falls 0.8 percent month/month - government Reuters - 3 hours ago

    TOKYO (Reuters) - Japan's industrial output unexpectedly fell 0.8 percent in January, posting the first decline in six months, government data showed on Tuesday. The month-on-month fall compared with a ... … More »

  • PHI Inc. reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    The Lafayette, Louisiana-based company said it had a loss of $1.08 per share. The helicopter transportation company serving the oil and gas industry posted revenue of $144.9 million in the period. For ... … More »

  • Ensco beats 4Q profit forecasts Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    On a per-share basis, the London-based company said it had profit of 13 cents. Earnings, adjusted to account for discontinued operations and non-recurring gains, came to 9 cents per share. The results ... … More »

  • BWX beats 4Q profit forecasts Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    On a per-share basis, the Lynchburg, Virginia-based company said it had net income of 34 cents. Earnings, adjusted for non-recurring costs and restructuring costs, came to 46 cents per share. The results ... … More »

  • AppFolio reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    On a per-share basis, the Santa Barbara, California-based company said it had a loss of 4 cents. Earnings, adjusted for stock option expense, were less than 1 cent on a per-share basis. The property management ... … More »

  • Elio’s tiny car gets 84 mpg and costs only $7,300 — here’s what it was like
    Elio’s tiny car gets 84 mpg and costs only $7,300 — here’s what it was like Business Insider - 3 hours ago

    Hollis Johnson Elio Motors has one of the … Continued The post Elio’s tiny car gets 84 mpg and costs only $7,300 — here’s what it was like appeared first on Business Insider. … More »

  • Sun Hydraulics posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    The Sarasota, Florida-based company said it had net income of 12 cents per share. The maker of screw-in hydraulic cartridge valves and manifolds posted revenue of $49.9 million in the period. For the year, ... … More »

  • Medpace tops Street 4Q forecasts Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    On a per-share basis, the Cincinnati-based company said it had a loss of less than 1 cent. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, were 35 cents per share. The results topped Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.

MARKET MOVERS

  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.225-0.005-2.17%
    N21.SI
    2.62-0.12-4.38%
    MC0.SI
    0.285+0.015+5.56%
    PH0.SI
    0.380.00-1.30%
    E5H.SI
    0.985-0.005-0.51%
    G13.SI
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.34+0.05+17.24%
    PA3.SI
    0.134+0.013+10.74%
    5IG.SI
    0.20+0.02+8.70%
    BJD.SI
    0.193+0.013+7.22%
    1A4.SI
    42.93+2.72+6.76%
    C07.SI
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.54-0.06-10.00%
    BQP.SI
    0.25-0.03-9.09%
    BLZ.SI
    0.205-0.020-8.89%
    S46.SI
    0.30-0.02-7.69%
    F83.SI
    0.095-0.007-6.86%
    5RC.SI

Market Data

  • Currencies
    Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1.4051+0.001+0.07%
    USDSGD=X
    1.4871+0.0008+0.05%
    EURSGD=X
    1.7463+0.0003+0.02%
    GBPSGD=X
    80.1160-0.107-0.13%
    SGDJPY=X
    5.5221-0.0034-0.06%
    SGDHKD=X
    3.1632+0.0022+0.07%
    SGDMYR=X
    9,498.3770-5.6465-0.06%
    SGDIDR=X
    4.8919+0.0016+0.03%
    SGDCNY=X
    1.0787+0.0012+0.11%
    AUDSGD=X
  • Commodities
    Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1,253.70-5.10-0.41%
    GCJ17.CMX
    18.36-0.06-0.31%
    SIK17.CMX
    84.47-4.15-4.69%
    ^XAU
    2.69-0.01-0.46%
    HGK17.CMX
    54.13+0.08+0.15%
    CLJ17.NYM
  • Bonds
    Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change
    1.87+0.07
    ^FVX
    2.37+0.05
    ^TNX
    2.99+0.03
    ^TYX