Socially Responsible ETFs: The Other Value Investing

Socially responsible investment (SRI) is about investing in values. Socially responsible ETFs select companies based on political, social, environmental and corporate governance considerations. Can ethics and values be profitable? Or must investors forgo profits for the sake of their belief system?Unethical behavior is not profitable. Accounting fraud, faulty risk management controls, and environmental sloppiness can send firms into bankruptcy. When companies are made responsible for injuries their products cause, shareholders are hurt. An ETF that comprised of companies avoiding these situations would be a winner.But over the long term, some of the best performing investments are in sectors many investors find objectionable. Tobacco, alcoholic beverages, gaming machines, defense contractors, oil exploration and drilling companies are all often stellar performers. Investors in socially responsible ETFs must balance these realities.There is no ultimate agreement about what constitutes socially responsible investment. SRI-focused ETFs take a variety of approaches to the challenge of investing in good without sacrificing financial performance.One approach is to focus on a particular sector and invest in companies that develop alternatives to that sector. If the environment is a priority, for example, ETFs focusing on alternative energy are an option. There are many such funds. PowerShares WilderHill Clean Energy (NYSEArca:PBW - News) is one of the oldest and best established alternative energy ETFs. The 5-year chart below compares the performance of alternative energy fund PBW with the traditional energy providers, represented by the Energy Select Sector SPDR (NYSEArca:XLE - News).

The chart shows PBW losing out to XLE, particularly in the last year. XLE holds major oil producers like Exxon Mobile and Chevron and oil service companies like Halliburton. Luckily for investors in XLE, there is little exposure to British Petroleum. PBW by contrasts holds companies that aim to be cost-competitive with fossil fuels but often are not yet competitive and therefore are partly or wholly dependent on government subsidy. These companies are much smaller than the major holdings in XLE. They do not have proven cash flows. They tend to be more volatile.Another approach to socially responsible investment is to focus on the market as a whole but choose companies thought to have comparatively superior record of environmental, social and corporate governance relative to their peers in the same sector. iShares KLD Select Social Index (NYSEArca:KLD - News) takes this approach. It holds 200-300 companies chosen from the S&P 900 Index. The sector allocation is almost identical to the SPY benchmark so big energy companies for example are allowed. But KLD holds no tobacco stock and a smaller allocation goes to utilities and energy companies when compared with the benchmark.The chart below compares the 5-year performance of KLD with a mutual fund from USA Mutuals called the Vice Fund (VICEX) that holds "vice" stocks: tobacco, gaming, defense companies, oil. The domestic benchmark Standard and Poors Depositary Receipts (NYSEArca:SPY - News) is also shown.
The chart shows, first of all, how closely KLD tracks the benchmark SPY. This is a success for KLD. Second, it shows that there is a long period where the vice stocks outperform the benchmark. Are vice stocks simply more profitable? The most important difference occurs between January 2006 and the Summer of 2008. This is partly due to the rise in oil over this period.Because KLD so closely tracks the SPY, the chart below compares just vice stocks with KLD, this time on a 1-year basis.
Here the chart shows vice stocks again outperforming. Why? As the market tumbled in August 2010, the defensive character of tobacco and alcoholic beverage companies won over investors. These companies have strong cash flow, pay regular and high dividends, and produce products that resist cyclicality, like tobacco.But sometimes vice does not outperform. In strong markets defensive companies like tobacco and beverages tend to underperform. The chart below shows the 2-year performance of the same funds.
Here the vice lags. From the Summer of 2009 to the Spring of 2010, KLD (and the benchmark) rose 40% and the vice fund only 20%. Again cyclicality is a par culprit. The broad market dropped more severely during the prior sell-off than the cash-rich vice sector.For some investors the market-targeting approach taken by KLD is not ambitious enough. They point to KLD's small position in Halliburton, which was involved in the BP oil spill as well as a major contractor in Iraq as an example of deviating from socially responsible objectives.These investors should take a look at the iShares KLD 400 Social Index (NYSEArca:DSI - News). DSI is at once more selective and more pro-active compared with KLD. It automatically excludes investments the SINdex-- tobacco, alcohol and gambling. It also excludes companies involved in weaponry and nuclear power. DSI overweights companies with strong environmental corporate governance and human rights records. Of course none of these considerations automatically keep Halliburton or Cameron International out of the portfolio-- at least prior to the BP oil spill.Over the last decade alternative energy ETFs have mostly underperformed conventional oil and oil service funds, defense contractors and notorious carbon polluters in the power generation business. But this long-term trend may be under attack. Concern about the environment is heating up. Public disgust with corporate malfeasance is increasingly important. Environmentally friendly technologies are becoming more prominent and profitable. Socially responsible investment, when done properly, can bring strong returns.Following is a list of ETFs with a focus on social responsibility:Responsible CompaniesiShares KLD Select Social Index (NYSEArca:KLD - News) 0.5%iShares KLD 400 Social Index (NYSEArca:DSI - News) 0.5%Alternative EnergyPowerShares Wilderhill Clean Energy Portfolio (NYSEArca:PBW - News) 0.60%PowerShares Wilderhill Progressive Energy Portfolio (NYSEArca:PUW - News) 0.60%First Trust NASDAQ Clean Edge (NasdaqGM:QCLN - News)0.60%PowerShares Cleantech Portfolio (NYSEArca:PZD - News) 0.60%Global Alternative EnergyVan Eck Market Vectors Global Alternative Energy (NYSEArca:GEX - News) 0.65%PowerShares Clean Energy Portfolio (NYSEArca:PBD - News) 0.75%Solar EnergyClaymore Global Solar Energy (NYSEArca:TAN - News) 0.65%Van Eck Market Vectors Solar Energy (NYSEArca:KWT - News) 0.65%Wind EnergyFirst Trust Global Wind Energy Fund (NYSEArca:FAN - News) 0.60%Jonathan Bernstein has been writing about ETFs since 2003 and is the author of Sector Trading: A Year in Exchange Traded Funds.


Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
  • Yuan Bears Emerge From Hibernation as Fed Imperils G-20 Calm (1) Bloomberg - 37 minutes ago

    Derivative markets are pointing to renewed bets on yuan depreciation, with a three-month measure of expected price swings poised for the biggest monthly increase since January. The increased pessimism comes after a period of calm that sent the … More »

  • Japan’s Household Spending and Unemployment Fall in July (1) Bloomberg - 43 minutes ago

    Household spending fell 0.5 percent in July from a year earlier, the statistics bureau said on Tuesday (forecast -1.5 percent). Retail sales fell 0.2 percent from a year earlier (forecast -0.9 percent), according to a trade ministry report. The … More »

  • Asian Stocks Gain Amid U.S. Rebound While Japan Shares Retreat Bloomberg - 54 minutes ago

    The MSCI Asia Pacific Index climbed 0.3 percent to 138.33 as of 9:16 a.m. in Tokyo. The index fell Monday after Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen indicated the case for an interest-rate hike is getting stronger. Investors are watching data … More »

  • Asia ex-Japan Stocks Advance After U.S. Rally as Oil Near $47 Bloomberg - 56 minutes ago

    South Korea’s won strengthened and crude oil was little changed. The MSCI Asia Pacific Excluding Japan Index rose as equity benchmarks advanced in Australia, New Zealand and South Korea. Japanese shares retreated following their biggest jump in … More »

  • Tokyo shares open lower despite Wall Street gains AFP - 1 hour 12 minutes ago

    Tokyo shares opened modestly lower on Tuesday following a jump the previous day, despite a positive lead from Wall Street. The benchmark Nikkei 225 index fell 0.28 percent, or 46.51 points, to 16,690.98 ... … More »

  • EU to hand Apple Irish tax bill of over 1 billion euro, source says
    EU to hand Apple Irish tax bill of over 1 billion euro, source says Reuters - 1 hour 18 minutes ago

    The European Commission will rule against Ireland's tax dealings with Apple (AAPL.O) on Tuesday, two source familiar with the decision told Reuters, one of whom said Dublin would be told to recoup over 1 billion euros in back taxes. The Commission … More »

  • Why Do People File For Bankruptcy In Singapore?
    Why Do People File For Bankruptcy In Singapore? - 1 hour 22 minutes ago

    Being a bankrupt does not mean you can default on all your debt The post Why Do People File For Bankruptcy In Singapore? appeared first on … More »

  • Mondelez abandons pursuit of U.S. chocolate maker Hershey
    Mondelez abandons pursuit of U.S. chocolate maker Hershey Reuters - 1 hour 31 minutes ago

    The abandoned deal, which would have created the world's largest confectioner, underscores the grip that a charitable trust has on the maker of Hershey's Kisses and Reese's Peanut Butter Cups. The trust which controls Hershey was set up by the … More »

  • Traders Said to Discuss Data Superhighway From Chicago to Japan Bloomberg - 2 hours 20 minutes ago

    The project, dubbed “Go West,” would install a line of microwave towers from the Chicago area to the U.S. west coast, possibly ending near Seattle, and then connect to an undersea cable that stretches to Asia, according to the people, who asked not … More »

  • US alarm as Turkey warns Syrian Kurd militia of more strikes
    US alarm as Turkey warns Syrian Kurd militia of more strikes AFP News - 2 hours 26 minutes ago

    Turkey warned Monday it would carry out more strikes on a US-backed Kurdish militia in Syria if it fails to retreat, as Washington said President Barack Obama will meet his Turkish counterpart over the weekend. Turkish forces pressed on with a … More »

  • Shell restarts gasoline-producing unit at Puget Sound refinery Reuters - 2 hours 39 minutes ago

    HOUSTON (Reuters) - Shell (RDSa.L) restarted a fluid catalytic cracking unit (FCCU) at its Puget Sound, Washington refinery on Aug. 23, according to a regulatory filing published on Monday. The unit was ... … More »

  • Business Highlights Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    ___ Mylan launching cheaper, generic version of EpiPen The maker of EpiPens will start selling a cheaper, generic version of the emergency allergy shots as the furor over repeated U.S. price hikes continues ... … More »

  • Island Standoff Again Clouds China-Japan Ties in Run-Up to G-20 Bloomberg - 3 hours ago

    One of the reasons China may be escalating its activity in the East China Sea is to warn Japan against getting involved in the South China Sea spat. While not a claimant in those waters, Japan has drawn China’s ire for supporting Southeast Asian … More »

  • Tokyo, Wall St. shares boosted by Fed rate hike talk
    Tokyo, Wall St. shares boosted by Fed rate hike talk AFP News - 3 hours ago

    Japanese shares pushed sharply higher and Wall Street got a boost Monday by rising expectations of an interest rate increase this year by the US Federal Reserve. The rate hike talk, which came out of the Fed's central banking symposium at the end … More »

  • Yale grad students file petition seeking union certification Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    Yale University graduate students on Monday petitioned the National Labor Relations Board for union recognition, saying they have organized to address concerns surrounding pay and benefits and give themselves ... … More »

  • Dollar rises following uptick in US consumer spending AFP - 3 hours ago

    The dollar rose against the euro, the yen and the pound on Monday as US Commerce Department data showed consumer spending had risen in July. The rise in the dollar also followed a comparatively bullish ... … More »

  • Consumer Stocks That Fueled U.S. Bull Market Remain Mired in Rut Bloomberg - 4 hours ago

    Consumer-discretionary companies, the engine of the seven-year rally in U.S. equities with a gain of more than 400 percent, remain on course for the worst year since the financial crisis even as the American consumer continues to show signs of … More »

  • Rates on US Treasury bills rise at weekly auction Associated Press - 4 hours ago

    Interest rates on short-term Treasury bills rose in Monday's auction, with rates on six-month bills climbing to their highest level since March. The Treasury Department auctioned $40 billion in three-month ... … More »

  • Shell to sell certain Gulf of Mexico assets to EnVen Energy
    Shell to sell certain Gulf of Mexico assets to EnVen Energy Reuters - 4 hours ago

    Houston-based EnVen plans to buy the Brutus/Glider assets, which include a subsea production system, and the deal is expected to close in October. The Brutus/Glider assets have a combined current production estimate of about 25,000 barrels of oil … More »

  • U.S. Venture Firm Aims to Break Corporate Hold On Japan Startups Bloomberg - 4 hours ago

    “We realized we had to create excuses for founders to contact us,” Riney, said in an interview at his office near Tokyo Station. Riney opened the Japan fund for 500 Startups, a fixture of Silicon Valley that made its name backing entrepreneurs just … More »

  • Deals Freeze Up in One of Asia’s Most Lucrative Office Markets Bloomberg - 4 hours ago

    Commercial property transactions in Australia fell 57 percent to $7.5 billion in the six months ended June 30 from a year earlier, according to Real Capital Analytics, Inc. That’s the biggest drop since the first half of 2008 and the steepest … More »

  • Phibro posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 4 hours ago

    On a per-share basis, the Teaneck, New Jersey-based company said it had profit of 38 cents. Earnings, adjusted for non-recurring costs, came to 40 cents per share. The maker of animal health products and ... … More »

  • Wall St. gains as data points to budding economy
    Wall St. gains as data points to budding economy Reuters - 4 hours ago

    Financial and commodity-sector stocks led the S&P 500 higher in a low-volume session on Monday after consumer spending rose for a fourth straight month, pointing to a pick-up in U.S. economic growth. After Fed Chair Janet Yellen said the case for a … More »

  • Oil down 1 percent, pressured by glut, dollar, Nigeria outlook
    Oil down 1 percent, pressured by glut, dollar, Nigeria outlook Reuters - 4 hours ago

    Oil prices settled down more than 1 percent on Monday, snapping two consecutive days of gains, on renewed concerns about an oil glut, a stronger dollar and expectations that Nigerian rebels will stop hampering that country's crude output. … More »

  • Catalent misses 4Q profit forecasts Associated Press - 4 hours ago

    The Somerset, New Jersey-based company said it had net income of 46 cents per share. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, came to 52 cents per share. The results missed Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
to view quotes in your portfolios.


    Market Data

    • Currencies
      NamePriceChange% Chg
    • Commodities
      NamePriceChange% Chg
    • Bonds
      TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change