Which Party Does the Market Perform Best Under?

If you're hoping for a GOP victory tomorrow because you think elephants mean stock-market booms while donkeys mean busts, be careful what you vote for.

In fact, the market--and the economy overall--has done way better under Democratic administrations than Republican. According to Doug Short, vice president of research for the Adviser Perspectives newsletter, since 1900 the Dow Jones Industrial Average has gained an average of 8.7 percent a year under Democrats and only 5.7 percent under Republicans. Short's figures exclude dividends and aren't adjusted for inflation.

Indeed, the Dow's two best years came under Democratic administrations (Wilson and Franklin Roosevelt) and the two worst under Republicans (Hoover and George W. Bush). The single best period for the Dow under a particular president was Bill Clinton's eight years (up an annualized 16.6 percent) and the single worst was Republican Herbert Hoover's four years (down an annualized 33 percent).

Since 1930, Short's data show, GDP growth has averaged 1.8 percent under Republican administrations and 4.8 percent under Democrats.

[Read: The Economy, Not the Market, Decides Elections.]

You can slice the data differently, but the Democrats still come out on top. The New York Times reported just before the 2008 election that a one-time investment in the S&P 500 under Democratic administrations alone since 1929 would have netted a 30-fold gain, compared with a total 17-percent gain under Republicans. That's 8.9 percent annualized growth under Democrats and 0.4 percent under Republicans, at a point when both had held the White House for equal periods over the previous eight decades.

Throwing out the disastrous Hoover years produces a five-fold increase, or a 4.7-percent annualized gain, for the GOP--still way behind the Democrats.

Obama has raised the Democratic average. As of Friday's close, the S&P was up 68 percent on Obama's watch, for an annualized gain of 14.9 percent.

Short's results reflect the annual change in the Dow measured by administration. A widely cited study by CMC Markets, a UK-based foreign-exchange trading company, averages the Dow's monthly changes to capture volatility within years. Like Short, CMC excludes dividends and does not account for inflation.

CMC's results also show markets under Democratic administrations well ahead since 1900, by an annualized 15.31 percent to 5.43 percent. If you average CMC's data by year instead of by month, you get an annualized 10.11 percent for Democratic eras and 7.64 percent for Republican periods. The Dow's gains under 61 years of Democratic administrations (through the end of August) come to a nominal 602 percent, versus 504 percent for 51 years of Republican administrations. What's more, market volatility has been lower during Democratic eras.

Other studies produce similar results. The Economist noted last month that the Barclays U.S. equity index gained an inflation-adjusted 300 percent under Democratic administrations between 1929 and 2011, versus slightly less than zero under Republican regimes.

[Read: A Deadlocked Election Should Scare Investors.]

To be sure, there's probably as much coincidence here as causation, and there are plenty of qualifications that bear mention. For starters, governance isn't entirely about who controls the White House. It also matters who controls Congress at any point, and there have been several periods marked by a divided government (the early Truman and late Clinton years, for example).

There's also the little matter of who runs the Federal Reserve, which was established in 1913. "It's fair to say that whoever chairs the Federal Reserve is almost as important as who's president, for the stock market," says Mark Calabria, director of financial-regulation studies for the libertarian CATO Institute. "How much of this is driven by inflation? In some years, like Kennedy and Nixon, those are probably negative real returns."

Based solely on White House control, the GOP market average also gets pulled down by the two biggest crashes on record. Even if you blame them on financial deregulation (and Democrat Clinton, as much as any Republican, comes to mind here) the crashes themselves could have come on anyone's watch. Conversely, Democrats--particularly Franklin Roosevelt and Obama--benefited from the rallies that naturally followed those two crashes.

If the implication is that party philosophy accounts for the Democratic advantage, it's worth noting that party comparisons over such a long period are a bit of a stretch. Markets were pretty weak under Republican Theodore Roosevelt, but in today's ideological terms he's better understood as a Democrat than a Republican. He railed against powerful financial interests ("trusts," as they were called) while promoting food-and-drug regulation and labor rights. If you're trying to link traditional Republican ideology to weak market conditions, TR is not your man.

[Read: How the Election May Influence the Investment Advice You Get.]

Conversely, the Dow's two biggest one-year rallies might be only partially attributable to Democratic policies. The first, in 1915, came after the market had been closed or trading severely curtailed for nine months amid the start of war in Europe, and it could reflect a flight of European capital into the safety of U.S. markets, suggests CATO's Calabria. The second, during 1933, surely owes something to confidence rekindled by the incoming Roosevelt administration, but could partly have been a particularly large dead-cat bounce, given that the markets were down by more than 90 percent at their Depression-era low point.

"If you held me to a pattern, the pattern I see is that when you have a new president that promised big departures in policy from the previous one, you get a positive market reaction," says Brian Gendreau, market strategist for Cetera Financial and a professor of finance at the University of Florida. Examples, he says: FDR, Reagan, and Obama.

The fact that the Democrats haven't been waving the numbers around may be one indication that there's more correlation than causation at play here. On the other hand, it could just be prudent gamesmanship, as Calabria notes: "You complain about inequality, then you're going to try to take credit for things that increase inequality?"



More From US News & World Report

--

Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
Loading...
  • Oil prices down on profit-taking after two-day jump
    Oil prices down on profit-taking after two-day jump Reuters - 10 minutes ago

    Oil prices dropped on Friday as investors took profits following a 7-percent rise in the last two sessions, amid doubts that OPEC's first planned output cut in eight years would make a substantial dent in the global crude glut. Brent and U.S. crude … More »

  • Foxconn's Sharp to spend $570 million on OLED panel production
    Foxconn's Sharp to spend $570 million on OLED panel production Reuters - 13 minutes ago

    Japan's Sharp Corp said it will spend $570 million on its organic light-emitting diode (OLED) screen business - one of its first major investments since it was taken over by Taiwan's Foxconn although the amount pales in comparison to efforts by … More »

  • Oil prices down on doubts over OPEC deal AFP - 19 minutes ago

    Oil prices fell in Asia Friday as doubts emerged over the long-term success of a surprise OPEC agreement to cut output and stabilise the oversupplied market. The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting ... … More »

  • $1 Coal Mines Turn to Jackpots as China’s Cuts Power Rally (1) Bloomberg - 29 minutes ago

    Stanmore Coal Ltd. bought the Isaac Plains metallurgical coal mine in Australia for A$1 in July 2015 from Brazilian miner Vale SA and Japan’s Sumitomo Corp. when the price of met coal, used to make steel, averaged the lowest in about a decade and … More »

  • Sharp says to invest 57.4 billion yen in OLED business
    Sharp says to invest 57.4 billion yen in OLED business Reuters - 31 minutes ago

    Japan's Sharp Corp said on Friday it will invest 57.4 billion yen in its organic light-emitting diode (OLED) business as part of a shift towards the production of displays for use in smartphones, automobiles and flat-screen televisions. The … More »

  • Hong Kong Stock Selloff Pares Best Quarterly Advance Since 2009 Bloomberg - 32 minutes ago

    The Hang Seng Index dropped 1.3 percent at the midday break, paring its gain since the end of June to 13 percent. Bank of Communications Co. led a measure of financial companies lower, sliding 2.5 percent. Property companies fell for a second day, … More »

  • Matrade expresses relief over OPEC's production cut decision Business Times - 34 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: The Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC)’s decision to cut oil production is a boon for the oil and gas (O&G) industry.Malaysia External Trade Development Corporation (Matrade)’s chief executive officer Datuk Dzulkifli … More »

  • Music school hits right note for Kabul's street children
    Music school hits right note for Kabul's street children AFP News - 40 minutes ago

    The 20-year-old used to sell chewing gum in the streets of Kabul, until he passed an audition at the Afghan National Institute of Music (Anim) and his life changed tune. Ahmad Sarmast, the school's founder, believes children deserve a better life … More »

  • SE Asia Stocks-Lower as Deutsche Bank woes spook investors Reuters - 50 minutes ago

    By Anusha Ravindranath Sept 30 (Reuters) - Southeast Asian share markets fell on Friday tracking Asian peers as concerns over the stability of Germany's largest lender, Deutsche Bank, prompted investors ... … More »

  • Alarm Bells Sound in New York as Duterte’s Audit Roils Mines (2) Bloomberg - 50 minutes ago

    The threat to shutter about three-quarters of the nation’s mines risks savaging the country’s reputation among investors, according to the head of a company whose operations face suspension. “I just came from New York, and investors are very … More »

  • China factories limp along, Japan inflation goes backwards Reuters - 54 minutes ago

    China's factory sector struggled to gain speed in September while Japanese inflation went backwards in August despite the best efforts of policymakers, underscoring the limits of stimulus in reviving world growth. Friday's unflattering figures … More »

  • GLOBAL ECONOMY - China factories limp along, Japan inflation goes backwards
    GLOBAL ECONOMY - China factories limp along, Japan inflation goes backwards Reuters - 57 minutes ago

    China's factory sector struggled to gain speed in September while Japanese inflation went backwards in August despite the best efforts of policymakers, underscoring the limits of stimulus in reviving world growth. Friday's unflattering figures … More »

  • Malaysia's closing tin prices for Sept 30 Reuters - 1 hour 0 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR, Sept 30 (Reuters) - Following is a table of Kuala Lumpur tin market prices provided by a Malaysian trader. (Prices in $/tonne, and volumes in tonnes unless stated) Date KL Premium/ Spot Bid ... … More »

  • Yen's Stop Sign at 100 Signals Japan May Avoid Intervention (1) Bloomberg - 1 hour 8 minutes ago

    Japan’s currency has appreciated to within 0.1 percent of 100 three times since it last traded stronger than that level five weeks ago, and each time it has retreated. Traders say it is running into waves of sell orders, spurring speculation there … More »

  • This Alibaba app lets you ask strangers to deliver toilet paper
    This Alibaba app lets you ask strangers to deliver toilet paper Business Insider - 1 hour 25 minutes ago

    Shu Zhang/Reuters Jack Ma The joke has turned … Continued The post This Alibaba app lets you ask strangers to deliver toilet paper appeared first on Business Insider. … More »

  • US paper facing threats for endorsing Hillary Clinton
    US paper facing threats for endorsing Hillary Clinton AFP News - 1 hour 25 minutes ago

    A conservative Arizona newspaper is facing death threats and losing subscriptions after it broke with tradition by endorsing Hillary Clinton over Donald Trump for US president, a senior editor told AFP. The Phoenix-based Arizona Republic, the … More »

  • Get to Know the Exact Change Act
    Get to Know the Exact Change Act MoneyMax.ph - 1 hour 30 minutes ago

    You’ve probably had to deal with the issue of paying for something with a larger bill only to be asked for a smaller one instead. In other cases, you’ve probably gotten candy as change because the store didn’t have any coins or smaller bills. To … More »

  • Tokyo shares down by break on Deutsche Bank worries AFP - 1 hour 37 minutes ago

    Tokyo shares fell Friday morning as Deutsche Bank's woes dented financial firms while exporters were hit by a stronger yen. The weak start followed a slump on Wall Street where Deutsche Bank sank nearly ... … More »

  • Extraordinary HDB designs
    Extraordinary HDB designs The Edge Property - 1 hour 39 minutes ago

    There is a natural tendency to expect less when it comes to the furnishing of HDB flats. The familiar “simple and minimal” design does not evoke feelings of a warm welcome. Some young homeowners whose properties are featured here decided to buck the … More »

  • Asian stocks lower on renewed worries about banking sector
    Asian stocks lower on renewed worries about banking sector Associated Press - 1 hour 42 minutes ago

    Asian stock markets were lower on Friday as investor sentiment was dented by overnight losses on Wall Street and renewed worries about the health of Deutsche Bank. KEEPING SCORE: Japan's Nikkei 225 slumped ... … More »

  • Asian markets track US losses on Deutsch Bank worries
    Asian markets track US losses on Deutsch Bank worries AFP News - 1 hour 42 minutes ago

    Asian markets tumbled Friday, tracking a sell-off in New York as worries about the future of German banking giant Deutsche Bank hammered financial stocks. … More »

  • Bursa caps Teck Guan surge Business Times - 1 hour 54 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: Bursa Malaysia yesterday capped the surge in Teck Guan Perdana Bhd’s share price at RM1.78 after the stock hit limit up for two consecutive days. The surge followed Teck Guan’s announcement of a solid results for the second quarter … More »

  • Fintech group C88 raises undisclosed Series B round led by Telstra Ventures
    Fintech group C88 raises undisclosed Series B round led by Telstra Ventures e27 - 1 hour 55 minutes ago

    Existing investors Monk’s Hill Ventures and Kejora Ventures also took part in the round, with many others participating Fintech company Compare88 (C88) today announced that it has raised an undisclosed Series B round led by Telstra Ventures, with … More »

  • EPF looking at diversification Business Times - 1 hour 55 minutes ago

    HONG KONG: Malaysia’s largest pension fund is looking to diversify its investment portfolios in a bid to boost returns, according to chief executive officer Datuk Shahril Ridza Ridzuan. The Employees Provident Fund (EPF) planned to invest more in … More »

  • 3 investment lessons from the House of Cards
    3 investment lessons from the House of Cards Truewealth Publishing - 1 hour 59 minutes ago

    The political drama House of Cards – on Netflix at an internet connection near you – is about the fictitious rise to power in the American political system of ruthless politico Frank Underwood and his wife, Claire. Frank and Claire are fearlessly … More »

 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.

MARKET MOVERS

  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.157-0.003-1.87%
    N21.SI
    0.12+0.01+12.15%
    40F.SI
    0.114+0.002+1.79%
    40E.SI
    3.97-0.05-1.24%
    Z74.SI
    0.97-0.01-1.02%
    Y92.SI
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.164+0.016+10.81%
    40N.SI
    0.12+0.01+12.15%
    40F.SI
    0.69+0.04+5.34%
    BHU.SI
    0.215+0.010+4.88%
    1A4.SI
    0.23+0.01+4.55%
    B69.SI
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.20-0.06-23.08%
    AWI.SI
    0.27-0.06-18.18%
    5VP.SI
    0.145-0.016-9.94%
    5PL.SI
    0.48-0.05-9.43%
    BQD.SI
    0.28-0.03-8.20%
    543.SI

Market Data

  • Currencies
    Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1.3653+0.0013+0.10%
    USDSGD=X
    1.5315+0.0015+0.10%
    EURSGD=X
    1.7708+0.0027+0.15%
    GBPSGD=X
    74.1160+0.045+0.06%
    SGDJPY=X
    5.6782-0.0058-0.10%
    SGDHKD=X
    3.0331+0.0102+0.34%
    SGDMYR=X
    9,526.3750-16.3379-0.17%
    SGDIDR=X
    4.8845-0.0025-0.05%
    SGDCNY=X
    1.0410+0.0001+0.01%
    AUDSGD=X
  • Commodities
    Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1,326.30+0.30+0.02%
    GCZ16.CMX
    19.17-0.02-0.12%
    SIZ16.CMX
    95.01-0.66-0.69%
    ^XAU
    2.18-0.01-0.32%
    HGZ16.CMX
    43.85+0.41+0.94%
    CLV16.NYM
  • Bonds
    Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change
    -1.13
    ^FVX
    -1.57
    ^TNX
    -2.29
    ^TYX