Should the NYT charge for early access to the news?



The New York Times recently ran an exclusive exposé about Walmart and bribery allegations in Mexico, a story that helped to shave about $16 billion from the retailing giant’s market value over the past few days. For Reuters blogger Felix Salmon, that sparked an idea: why not sell early access to that kind of story to customers who might want to pay for it — say, hedge funds who could trade on the information? After all, he argued, Reuters and Bloomberg have a huge business providing financially sensitive information to paying clients. But is that really the kind of game the New York Times wants to start playing with the news?

The proposal seems to have a lot going for it, at least for a newspaper that is seeking whatever new sources of revenue it can find in the wake of a continued decline in advertising revenue. In its latest financial report, the New York Times said that not only did print advertising fall, but digital advertising did as well. Revenues from the newspaper’s subscription plan or “paywall” are substantial and growing, but not substantial enough to make up for the shortfall — and it’s not clear when they will get to that point, if ever. Perhaps selling early access to stories is one solution?

Should hedge funds get an early look at important news?

Salmon points out that this is the same kind of thing that newswires such as Reuters provide for their enterprise customers: early access to information that matters to them, and for which they are willing to pay a lot. The Wall Street Journal and the Dow Jones wire are two parts of a similar business in a lot of ways — some customers get access to the news on the wire earlier than it appears in the newspaper or online. So why shouldn’t the New York Times get in on some of that action?

[H]ow much would hedge funds pay to be able to see the NYT’s big investigative stories during the trading day prior to the appearance of the story? It’s entirely normal, and perfectly ethical, for news organizations, including Reuters, to give faster access to the best-paying customers.

I had a fairly negative initial reaction to this idea, which I posted on Twitter — and an excerpt of the debate that ensued between Salmon, me, Emily Bell of the Tow Center for Digital Journalism at Columbia and John Gapper of the Financial Times (among others) appears below. For me, the idea of giving hedge funds preferential access to market-moving information seems wrong somehow, especially the idea that they would get access to these stories a day ahead of regular readers (many of whom pay for the paper). Would it be different if it was a few minutes, or an hour? Perhaps.

John Gapper said that if regular readers don’t value scoops, which many believe to be the case, then there should be nothing wrong with selling access to those who do value them. Others who debated the issue with me argued that media outlets like the New York Times are damned if they do and damned if they don’t — they get criticized for putting up paywalls and doing other things to try and monetize their content, but unless they can come up with new models their business appears to be doomed.

Does the news not have public value as well?

Just to be clear, I am all in favor of media companies like the Times trying new ways to monetize their content, including packaging it in different ways — e-books, PDF downloads, proprietary research reports like those the Economist and others (including GigaOM) offer, and so on. I’ve written about what I think the new CEO of the NYT should do, and most of those things were included in my prescription. And if we’ve learned anything from the music business, it’s that preferential access to music is something that fans will pay for. So why not preferential access to the news?

One of the things that bothers me about this idea is that I think there is still some kind of public-service or public-policy value in journalism, and especially the news — I don’t think it is just another commodity that should be designed to make as much money as possible. And if the New York Times were to take stories that are arguably of social significance and provide them to hedge funds in advance, I think that would make it a very different type of entity than it is now. What if it was a story about a dangerous drug or national security?

Maybe doing that would be more lucrative, and perhaps the future of broad, general-interest news vehicles is so unhealthy that they will all have to become controlled-circulation newsletters for the wealthy, with some free content provided almost as an afterthought. That’s effectively what Rupert Murdoch’s hard paywall at the The Times has done to that newspaper. Reuters and Bloomberg are somewhat different because they were created specifically to appeal to institutions, and started providing news to the public as a by-product.

That is not what people think of when they think of the New York Times — but perhaps it will be in the future. Will that be a good thing for the NYT, or for society in general? I honestly don’t know. Here’s the Storify with the conversation between Salmon, Emily Bell, John Gapper and I:

[View the story "Should the NYT monetize its scoops?" on Storify]

Should the NYT monetize its scoops?

Storified by Mathew Ingram · Tue, Apr 24 2012 17:32:25

@emilybell: I think @felixsalmon’s idea would be morally wrong and also professional suicide. What do you think?Mathew Ingram @mathewi @emilybell tell that to everybody at Reuters and Bloomberg, it’s what we do! Have we all committed professional suicide?felix salmon @emilybell @mathewi @felixsalmon how is this any different than what Reuters does? the entirety of the wire is only available to clientsAnthony De Rosa @mathewi @felixsalmon I can only see bad things coming from it for sure. As I say – useful thought exercise for J School ethics classemily bell @felixsalmon @emilybell: for Bloomberg, the terminal data business is core — consumer news is an add-on. NYT is differentMathew Ingram @felixsalmon @mathewi in fairness you sell wholesale info services… You don’t offer one-off stories to hedge funds for a bucket of cash…emily bell @emilybell @mathewi I wasn’t suggesting that the stories be sold on a one-off basis. I was thinking more of a $1m/yr NYT wire service.felix salmon @felixsalmon @emilybell: and wire subscribers would get a full trading day advance notice of a big story? I don’t think that would flyMathew Ingram @AntDeRosa @mathewi @felixsalmon nyt can construct a higher priced fence round any info they choose, but brand might suffer in a b to c bizemily bell @felixsalmon @emilybell @antderosa: I think it matters that the NYT puts readers first, not traders — Bloomberg does the oppositeMathew Ingram @mathewi @emilybell @antderosa OK, but now we’ve changed the conversation: it’s about branding, not ethics.felix salmon @felixsalmon @emilybell @antderosa: I think it’s unethical too, if only large hedge funds get access — what about the individual investor?Mathew Ingram @mathewi @emilybell @antderosa so, again, you’re saying that Bloomberg is unethical because individual investors can’t afford its product?felix salmon @emilybell @felixsalmon @mathewi If scoops don’t matter to most readers, as digerati claim, logic = sell them to those who do value themJohn Gapper @mathewi @johngapper @felixsalmon but also maybe not more lucrative, Bberg and Reuters have totally different cost structure for servicesemily bell @johngapper @emilybell @felixsalmon: it would turn the NYT into a very different sort of business — maybe more lucrative, but differentMathew Ingram @mathewi @emilybell @antderosa So therefore the NYT should be barred from learning from the more-financially-successful Bloomberg?felix salmon @dsquareddigest @mathewi @emilybell @antderosa if you pay $20k/year for the wire, you get stories faster than if you go to the website.felix salmon @emilybell @felixsalmon @antderosa: so NYT story says "our hedge fund clients read this exclusive yesterday and have already traded on it"Mathew Ingram @emilybell @felixsalmon @antderosa: that sends a very different message about who the NYT values than its stories do currentlyMathew Ingram @mathewi @felixsalmon @dsquareddigest @emilybell @antderosa PS I’m not sure it would work for NYT but early access is a logical premium tierJohn Gapper Sorry, @felixsalmon I think you’ve gone off the reservation with this one: Dealmaker @felixsalmon @mathewi @emilybell @antderosa Bloomberg doesn’t sell differential access to news stories. It really doesn’t.Dan Davies

Post and thumbnail images courtesy of Flickr users Zert Sonstige and jphillipg


Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
  • How the Dow Jones industrial average fared on Tuesday Associated Press - 20 minutes ago

    Stocks posted modest gains on Tuesday, bringing indexes nearly back to the record levels they reached last week. Homebuilders rose sharply following a big jump in sales of new homes last month, and Best ... … More »

  • S&P 500 Closes Near High on Fed Bets Amid Mixed Data; Oil Rises Bloomberg - 23 minutes ago

    The S&P 500 Index briefly topped its record closing high, while Treasury 10-year notes were stuck in the tightest monthly trading range since 2006. Oil rallied on speculation that Iran may be more willing to cooperate with other producers seeking … More »

  • Biden vows 'rock solid' NATO ties as allies slam Trump
    Biden vows 'rock solid' NATO ties as allies slam Trump AFP News - 33 minutes ago

    US Vice President Joe Biden promised unwavering commitment to NATO's collective defence Tuesday as he sought to reassure Baltic allies spooked by a resurgent Russia and White House hopeful Donald Trump. "Let there be no doubt -- America's Article 5 … More »

  • Intuit reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 39 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Mountain View, California-based company said it had a loss of 16 cents. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, came to 8 cents per share. The results exceeded Wall Street ... … More »

  • Wall St. edges higher on tech, housing boost
    Wall St. edges higher on tech, housing boost Reuters - 53 minutes ago

    With the U.S. earnings season winding down, investors are also turning their focus to the likelihood of an interest rate hike in the coming months. Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen's speech on Friday at Jackson Hole will be scrutinized for clues … More »

  • Markets Right Now: US stocks notch modest gains Associated Press - 59 minutes ago

    The latest on developments in global financial markets (all times local): 4:00 a.m. Stocks managed modest gains in another quiet day of trading that kept major U.S. indexes slightly below the record levels ... … More »

  • Nimble Storage reports 2Q loss Associated Press - 1 hour 1 minute ago

    On a per-share basis, the San Jose, California-based company said it had a loss of 47 cents. Losses, adjusted for stock option expense, came to 19 cents per share. The results exceeded Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

  • Oil prices jump on report Iran could support OPEC limits AFP - 1 hour 6 minutes ago

    Oil prices jumped on Tuesday after a new report that Iran could support an effort by OPEC and Russia to freeze production and firm up prices. The Reuters report, citing unnamed sources, said Tehran is ... … More »

  • Housing sector lifts U.S., European stocks; oil rises
    Housing sector lifts U.S., European stocks; oil rises Reuters - 1 hour 21 minutes ago

    Homebuilders helped lift both U.S. and European stock markets on Tuesday, while oil prices got a boost from Iran's positive signals about an output freeze. On Wall Street, technology companies led the Nasdaq to a record intraday high and robust … More »

  • Gold steady ahead of global central bankers meeting
    Gold steady ahead of global central bankers meeting Reuters - 1 hour 25 minutes ago

    NEW YORK/LONDON (Reuters) - Gold was largely unchanged on Tuesday as markets shifted focus from hawkish comments by a Federal Reserve official over the weekend to a meeting of global central bankers later this week that might provide hints on the … More »

  • Grain lower, livestock lower Associated Press - 1 hour 30 minutes ago

    Grain futures were lower Tuesday on the Chicago Board of Trade. Wheat for Sept. declined 7.50 cents at $4.0775 a bushel; Sept. corn fell 4.75 cents to 3.2850 a bushel; Sept. oats was off .75 cent at $1.7150 ... … More »

  • Dollar slips vs yen on Fed rate hike uncertainty
    Dollar slips vs yen on Fed rate hike uncertainty Reuters - 1 hour 39 minutes ago

    The dollar slid against the yen on Tuesday, as investors shifted their focus away from hawkish remarks on U.S. interest rates by Federal Reserve officials and towards a speech on Friday by Fed Chair Janet Yellen. Yellen will speak at the annual … More »

  • Oil up over 1 percent as Iran signals support for OPEC freeze action
    Oil up over 1 percent as Iran signals support for OPEC freeze action Reuters - 1 hour 47 minutes ago

    Oil prices rose more than 1 percent on Tuesday after Reuters reported that Iran was sending positive signals that it may support joint OPEC action to prop up the market. It refused to join a previous attempt this year by OPEC plus non-members such … More »

  • BOJ Spurs Bond Volatility on Policy Review Markets Can’t Predict Bloomberg - 2 hours 9 minutes ago

    The only sure thing in the run-up to the BOJ board meeting next month may be wilder market swings. Volatile movements in Japanese government bonds are likely because debt investors aren’t able to price in the outcome of the meeting, according … More »

  • Yuan Funds Abroad See Pickup After Luring $604 Million in 2016 Bloomberg - 2 hours 10 minutes ago

    China Asset Management Co. has seen more inflows into equity funds that invest offshore yuan into mainland equities since Britain’s June 23 vote to leave the European Union. CSOP Asset Management Ltd. had its strongest inflows in 14 months in June … More »

  • Social Security rolls back security measures on website Associated Press - 2 hours 23 minutes ago

    The Social Security Administration has rolled back extra security measures on the agency's website after getting complaints from people who had trouble accessing their accounts. For years, workers and ... … More »

  • AIG in talks to sell Lloyd's insurance business to CPPIB - WSJ
    AIG in talks to sell Lloyd's insurance business to CPPIB - WSJ Reuters - 2 hours 43 minutes ago

    (Reuters) - American International Group Inc (AIG.N) is in early talks to sell Lloyd's of London Ltd's insurance operations to Canada Pension Plan Investment Board (CPPIB), the Wall Street Journal ... … More »

  • VW, U.S. states to hold settlement talks over excess emissions
    VW, U.S. states to hold settlement talks over excess emissions Reuters - 3 hours ago

    Maryland, Massachusetts, New York and Pennsylvania sued Volkswagen over excess diesel emissions related to its use of cheating software while the state of Washington has filed a notice of penalty against Volkswagen. VW said settlement talks will … More »

  • BRIEF-Hartalega Holdings lays off almost 600 people in Q1 - Nikkei Reuters - 3 hours ago

    Aug 23 (Reuters) - Nikkei: * Hartalega Holdings has fired almost 600 people in a "cost management exercise", which is close to 10 percent of its headcount in Q1 - Nikkei Source text for Eikon:... … More »

  • Spain balcony-jumping craze: most are drunk Brits, study finds
    Spain balcony-jumping craze: most are drunk Brits, study finds AFP News - 3 hours ago

    They're young, mostly British, on holiday, drunk and sometimes high, and they decide to jump from their hotel or apartment balcony into the pool. The so-called "balconing" craze has taken off to such an extent in Spain's Balearic Islands that … More »

  • Campaign's rising rent at Trump Tower came as space expanded
    Campaign's rising rent at Trump Tower came as space expanded Associated Press - 4 hours ago

    Donald Trump's campaign is taking up more space inside Trump Tower in New York -- and paying a lot more in rent. The Republican presidential nominee's campaign paid $35,457 per month for rent and utilities ... … More »

  • European markets rise on better data
    European markets rise on better data AFP News - 4 hours ago

    European stock markets rebounded on Tuesday, driven by improving eurozone data and signs that the initial impact of Britain's shock EU exit vote may not be as bad as feared. Investors were also looking to a speech on Saturday from Federal Reserve … More »

  • Danish lawmakers to visit Australia's Nauru migrant camp
    Danish lawmakers to visit Australia's Nauru migrant camp AFP News - 4 hours ago

    Danish lawmakers will travel to the Pacific island of Nauru to visit a controversial Australian immigration centre and study the use of offshore settlements for asylum-seekers, one of the MPs said Tuesday. Six members of the Danish parliament's … More »


    Aug 23 (Reuters) - Following are Indonesian prices for crude palm oil (CPO) quoted at an auction by PT KPB Nusantara (formerly known as the state marketing centre) on Monday. Buyer Volume Price Terms (tonnes) ... … More »

  • RUBBER-Tokyo futures prices after evening session Aug 23 Reuters - 4 hours ago

    Following are prices for Tokyo rubber futures at the end of the Tokyo market's evening session on Aug 2016. Contract Day Volume Evening Volume * Aug 169.2 - 161.4 13 * Sep 163.8 23 161.8 26 * Oct 161.9 ... … More »

Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
to view quotes in your portfolios.


  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg

Market Data

  • Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change