Does High-Speed Trading Hurt Investors?

"Our financial system is much safer now because Wall Street has removed the weakest link--man."

-Stephen Colbert

One of the more heartwarming verities about our globalized, tightly coupled, warp-speed financial markets is that more information is better than less, thus more information technology means more-efficient markets on more-level playing fields.

But what if technology actually tilts the playing field and impedes efficiency? Lots of people say that's exactly what "high-frequency trading" (HFT) is doing, and that average investors like you will ultimately pay the price.

HFT--actually a generic term for a range of high-speed trading tactics--is the fine art of using powerful computers programmed with complex instructions to trade stocks at lightning speed, seeking profits in tiny price discrepancies that might exist for a fraction of a second. Also known as "black-box" and "algorithmic" trading, it involves the programming of computers by "quants" (for quantitative analysts) to buy this or sell that in response to information--some market trend or piece of news--getting into and out of a stock faster than a human can click a mouse. These trades might make a fraction of a penny per share, but do that millions of times a day and it adds up to real money.

HFT has nothing to do with investing, as most people understand the word, even if it can have an impact on investors. The quants and their computers usually know nothing of company fundamentals--business models, management bios, balance sheets, and whatnot. They trade based solely on statistically informed instructions called algorithms. A successful HFT operation will make almost as many losing bets as winning bets, but the huge volumes involved can make even razor-thin margins profitable in the aggregate.

[Read: That Rumbling in Your Portfolio? It's Real.]

Once a marginal part of market activity, in the past five years HFT has grown to represent half to three-quarters of a typical day's trading volume, even if HFTs themselves represent only 2 percent or so of investors. Among the chief beneficiaries are brokers and dealers, who get a slice of each trade and cater increasingly to HFT clients. Most HFT shops are standalone affairs, like Red Bank, N.J.-based Tradeworx, while a few are arms of big institutions such as Goldman Sachs.

Whoever the players, the name of the game is speed, and the winners are the folks who get information a few milliseconds before the losers--i.e., the people with the fastest computers and the lowest "latency" (the time it takes to transmit data). As the game boils down to how fast electrons can travel, latency is becoming a function of "co-location"--setting up shop as close as physically possible to the exchange servers that are the source of raw price data. NYSE Euronext sells space at its Mahwah, N.J., "Liquidity Center" to HFT outfits.

Technology has thus created what many complain is a new class of insiders--those who can afford the computer systems necessary to monitor "order flow" a few milliseconds before the competition, and siphon off the profits that result.

Does any of this matter to a typical retail investor? Yes, in good ways and bad. The upside of what might look like a post-human, vaguely Orwellian battle between armies of robots is a sharp improvement in what market professionals call "liquidity"--essentially the ease with which you can buy and sell a stock. With so many securities flying in so many directions at such high speeds, it's a rare buyer who won't find a seller, and vice versa, on a typical trading day.

HFT has also slashed trading costs by more than half, by one reckoning. Brokers and dealers benefit anyway, because the huge expansion of volume offsets the decline in commissions.

And the downside? Critics say the whole objective of HFT is to secure an information advantage over everyone else. Never mind that in the perfectly efficient market that purists like to imagine there aren't supposed to be any informational advantages. They do exist, and spotting them can allow for "front running"--exploiting price movements that you know about in advance--and other forms of market manipulation. There's reason entrepreneur Mark Cuban famously called HFTs "the ultimate hackers."

[Read: Are You Vulnerable to Computerized Markets?]

But the bigger problem may be systemic risk, as exemplified by the "flash crash" of May 6, 2010, and the $440 million loss incurred by Knight Capital in August as the result of a software glitch. There is an analogy to be made between the argument over HFT and that other tiresome acronym, TBTF. Too-big-to-fail banks defend themselves by arguing that they offer efficiencies smaller banks can't. Even Alan Greenspan has dismissed that claim. But even if the banks are right, there's the question--posed by Republican presidential candidate Jon Huntsman, among others--of whether the cost of the systemic risk they pose exceeds the benefits of the efficiencies. Likewise with HFT.

To be sure, some argue that they do not increase systemic risk. The most prominent defender of HFT practices, Tradeworx CEO Manoj Narang, argued in 2010 comments to the Securities and Exchange Commission that in a pinch, HFTs--unlike longer-term investors-- can simply "turn off" their trading strategies and unwind their positions (something they effectively do at the close of each trading day anyway), "thereby eliminating any possibility of further losses" and immunizing them from the contagions that can afflict big quant firms. He also wrote that critics exaggerate the likelihood of "runaway algorithms" accelerating a meltdown, saying exchange rules and market regulations "eliminate most of the risk."

Narang concedes in emailed comments that "large orders executed algorithmically could pose a systemic risk if the technology is faulty, but this is not high-frequency trading. High-frequency traders hold small positions in their inventory and do not execute large trades." Flawed technology, he says, is what explains the flash crash, in which HFT "had at best a peripheral role." As for the Knight debacle, he says, "there was never any systemic risk to the stock market."

Maybe, but others argue that systemic risk is less a function of how HFTs actually operate and more about how markets perceive their activity, fairly or not.

[Read: October Sell-Off, Anyone? The S&P's 10 Worst Trading Days.]

"I don't think anyone believes that the default of an HFT would cause the international economy to collapse. That's not the point," says Wallace Turbeville, senior analyst at the progressive think tank Demos and author of a forthcoming study on HFTs. "HFT activity creates a perception of great liquidity in the market, but in fact HFT activity, because it's algorithmic, can switch from providing high levels of liquidity to consuming even higher levels of liquidity instantaneously. It's worse than no liquidity at all. If it can change by the flick of a switch, it's a very volatile situation."

In other words, HFTs enhance liquidity until they don't, and the uncertainty impedes investor confidence.

So, it could be that the market is in fact becoming an unpredictable casino rigged by the people who can buy the most computing power. Or it might be that investors are overreacting. As that eminent economist Stephen Colbert put it: "You destroy the global economy once, and everyone forgets all the times you didn't destroy it."



More From US News & World Report

--

Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
Loading...
  • HP Inc. tops Street 3Q forecasts but outlook clips stock
    HP Inc. tops Street 3Q forecasts but outlook clips stock Associated Press - 21 minutes ago

    Shares in HP Inc. tumbled in extended trading Wednesday after the personal computer and printer maker beat expectations with its results for its fiscal third quarter but its outlook for the current quarter ... … More »

  • Syria regime launched chemical attacks, IS used mustard gas: UN report
    Syria regime launched chemical attacks, IS used mustard gas: UN report AFP News - 24 minutes ago

    A UN investigation has established that President Bashar al-Assad's forces carried out at least two chemical attacks in Syria and that Islamic State jihadists used mustard gas as a weapon, according to a report seen by AFP on Wednesday. The panel … More »

  • HP Inc beats estimates, weak printer demand weighs on forecast
    HP Inc beats estimates, weak printer demand weighs on forecast Reuters - 27 minutes ago

    By Aishwarya Venugopal (Reuters) - HP Inc, the hardware business of the former Hewlett-Packard Co, reported higher-than-expected quarterly revenue and profit as demand recovered for its notebooks. However, ... … More »

  • The Latest: Authorities say quake death toll at 159
    The Latest: Authorities say quake death toll at 159 Associated Press - 37 minutes ago

    The Latest on the earthquake in central Italy (all times local): __ 00:30 Among the victims of an earthquake in Italy was an 18-month-old girl whose mother survived the deadly earthquake of 2009 in nearby ... … More »

  • Ex-Comverse CEO pleads guilty to fraud, a decade after fleeing to Africa
    Ex-Comverse CEO pleads guilty to fraud, a decade after fleeing to Africa Reuters - 46 minutes ago

    The former chief executive officer of Comverse Technology Inc pleaded guilty to securities fraud on Wednesday and was ordered detained a decade after fleeing the United States for Namibia to avoid prosecution. Jacob "Kobi" Alexander, the Woodbury, … More »

  • 'SNL' star Leslie Jones' personal site offline after hacking
    'SNL' star Leslie Jones' personal site offline after hacking Associated Press - 48 minutes ago

    The personal website of Leslie Jones has been taken offline after it appeared hackers posted personal photos in the latest online attack on the black "Saturday Night Live" and "Ghostbusters" ... … More »

  • Weak petroleum, pharma hit US stocks
    Weak petroleum, pharma hit US stocks AFP News - 56 minutes ago

    Weakness in petroleum-linked shares and pharmaceuticals pushed US stocks lower Wednesday as global markets awaited a speech this week by Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen. The declines by US pharma companies came as mounting criticism of drugmaker … More »

  • China’s Power Play in Asia May Be Emboldened by U.S. Politics Bloomberg - 1 hour 17 minutes ago

    Beijing is boosting its military presence in the area unabated, in the face of stepped-up U.S. patrols and a recent arbitration court ruling that invalidated its claims to most of the waterway. After decades of U.S. dominance in the western … More »

  • Canada takes tougher line with China over canola export dispute
    Canada takes tougher line with China over canola export dispute Reuters - 1 hour 18 minutes ago

    Canada hardened its line with China on Wednesday in a dispute over Canadian canola exports, saying bilateral relations could not improve until Beijing took action to settle the matter. Trade Minister Chrystia Freeland made the remarks in an … More »

  • Stocks Decline on Emerging-Market Risk as U.S. Drugmakers Tumble Bloomberg - 1 hour 33 minutes ago

    Developing-nation shares slid after Turkey launched a military operation in Syria, while North Korea conducted a missile test. South Africa’s rand sank as the nation’s finance minister refused to report to police amid a probe. Drugmakers dragged … More »

  • Wall Street stocks retreat, oil tumbles on oversupply concerns
    Wall Street stocks retreat, oil tumbles on oversupply concerns Reuters - 1 hour 38 minutes ago

    Wall Street stocks retreated on Wednesday led by health care and materials stocks, while oil prices tumbled about 3.0 percent on worries about oversupply. Mylan (MYL.O) slumped 5.4-percent to $43.15 after U.S. presidential candidate Hillary Clinton … More »

  • Oil pipeline: The legal challenges and protests
    Oil pipeline: The legal challenges and protests Associated Press - 1 hour 43 minutes ago

    A federal judge has heard testimony in the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe's request to temporarily block the construction of a four-state oil pipeline near their reservation, which straddles the North Dakota-South ... … More »

  • Business Highlights Associated Press - 1 hour 52 minutes ago

    ___ The hidden risk to the economy in corporate balance sheets America's debt problem is showing up in an unexpected place: Corporate America. Of the $1.8 trillion in cash that's sitting in U.S. corporate ... … More »

  • U.S. banking regulators focused on cyber security after SWIFT attacks
    U.S. banking regulators focused on cyber security after SWIFT attacks Reuters - 1 hour 54 minutes ago

    U.S. banking regulators said on Wednesday they are focused on cyber security risks and controls for U.S. financial institutions after attacks earlier this year involving the global financial network known as SWIFT. In a letter responding to … More »

  • Dismal time for Gulf oil = record low lease bidding
    Dismal time for Gulf oil = record low lease bidding Associated Press - 2 hours 7 minutes ago

    The federal government's annual sale of oil and gas leases in the Gulf of Mexico attracted hardly any interest on Wednesday, reflecting a dismal outlook for offshore drilling. Only three oil companies ... … More »

  • Australia's Luxury-Car Binge Belies Its Drop in Living Standards Bloomberg - 2 hours 17 minutes ago

    "A lot has been made of softer economic conditions over the first half of 2016, however the same cannot be said for the luxury car market,'' said Savanth Sebastian, an economist at CommSec. "Higher home prices are boosting wealth levels and … More »

  • How the Dow Jones industrial average fared on Wednesday Associated Press - 2 hours 27 minutes ago

    Stocks closed lower on Wednesday, led by sharp declines in health-care companies as outrage over the steep price hikes for Mylan's EpiPens escalates. On Wednesday: The Dow Jones industrial average fell ... … More »

  • Stocks end lower as health-care companies decline
    Stocks end lower as health-care companies decline Associated Press - 2 hours 28 minutes ago

    Stocks closed lower on Wednesday, led by sharp declines in health-care companies as outrage over the steep price hikes for Mylan's EpiPens escalates. Trading remains quiet overall with many investors still ... … More »

  • Pharma shares under fire as US stocks fall AFP - 2 hours 31 minutes ago

    US stocks fell Wednesday with pharmaceutical shares tumbling as controversy over the sky-high price of Mylan's EpiPen prompted rebukes from the White House and Democratic presidential candidate Hillary ... … More »

  • Williams-Sonoma meets 2Q profit forecasts Associated Press - 2 hours 53 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the San Francisco-based company said it had net income of 58 cents. The results matched Wall Street expectations. The average estimate of 15 analysts surveyed by Zacks Investment ... … More »

  • Wall St. falls as healthcare, materials stumble
    Wall St. falls as healthcare, materials stumble Reuters - 2 hours 56 minutes ago

    Wall Street retreated on Wednesday, pulled lower by weakness in the materials and healthcare sectors as investors continued to weigh the possibility of an interest rate hike in the coming months. The market is awaiting Federal Reserve Chair Janet … More »

  • Markets Right Now: US stocks close lower Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    The latest on developments in global financial markets (all times local): 4:00 p.m. Stocks are closing lower, led by drops in health care companies, more than erasing a modest gain from the day before. ... … More »

  • One Tiny Ski Town Is Defying Japan’s Scary Population Collapse Bloomberg - 3 hours ago

    The area’s booming economy has spurred investment in luxury hotels, restaurants, and shops--and attracted local and expat workers who’ve become full-time residents. Niseko’s population grew 2.9 percent last year to 4,952 compared with 2010 levels, … More »

  • Grain lower, livestock lower Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    Grain futures were lower Wednesday on the Chicago Board of Trade. Wheat for Sept. declined 3.75 cents at $4.04 a bushel; Sept. corn fell 1 cent to 3.2750 a bushel; Sept. oats was off 2.25 cents at $1.6925 ... … More »

  • Oil slides on surprise jump in US crude stockpiles AFP - 3 hours ago

    Oil prices slumped Wednesday as a surprise jump in US crude stockpiles added to lingering concerns over a global supply glut. The US Department of Energy said commercial inventories of crude grew by 2.5 ... … More »

 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.

MARKET MOVERS

  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.1290.0000.00%
    N21.SI
    0.250.00-1.96%
    5ME.SI
    0.60+0.04+6.57%
    5TP.SI
    0.99-0.02-1.98%
    Y92.SI
    0.156+0.007+4.70%
    AFC.SI
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.30+0.06+22.45%
    T18.SI
    0.15+0.02+15.38%
    5TI.SI
    0.225+0.025+12.50%
    Y35.SI
    0.51+0.05+12.09%
    BHU.SI
    0.162+0.017+11.72%
    QS9.SI
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.011-0.115-91.27%
    QF6.SI
    0.23-0.17-42.50%
    AWI.SI
    0.205-0.055-21.15%
    I06.SI
    0.45-0.10-18.18%
    BFK.SI
    0.385-0.085-18.09%
    E8Z.SI

Market Data

  • Currencies
    Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1.3541+0.0004+0.03%
    USDSGD=X
    1.5257+0.0008+0.05%
    EURSGD=X
    1.7920+0.0014+0.08%
    GBPSGD=X
    74.1970+0.054+0.07%
    SGDJPY=X
    5.7242+0.0006+0.01%
    SGDHKD=X
    2.9765-0.0004-0.01%
    SGDMYR=X
    9,781.6260-1.6152-0.02%
    SGDIDR=X
    4.9125-0.0008-0.02%
    SGDCNY=X
    1.0310+0.0003+0.03%
    AUDSGD=X
  • Commodities
    Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1,329.40-0.30-0.02%
    GCZ16.CMX
    18.53-0.03-0.14%
    SIU16.CMX
    95.34-8.55-8.23%
    ^XAU
    2.080.00+0.17%
    HGU16.CMX
    46.82+0.05+0.11%
    CLV16.NYM
  • Bonds
    Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change
    1.140.00
    ^FVX
    1.56+0.01
    ^TNX
    2.24+0.01
    ^TYX