Does High-Speed Trading Hurt Investors?

"Our financial system is much safer now because Wall Street has removed the weakest link--man."

-Stephen Colbert

One of the more heartwarming verities about our globalized, tightly coupled, warp-speed financial markets is that more information is better than less, thus more information technology means more-efficient markets on more-level playing fields.

But what if technology actually tilts the playing field and impedes efficiency? Lots of people say that's exactly what "high-frequency trading" (HFT) is doing, and that average investors like you will ultimately pay the price.

HFT--actually a generic term for a range of high-speed trading tactics--is the fine art of using powerful computers programmed with complex instructions to trade stocks at lightning speed, seeking profits in tiny price discrepancies that might exist for a fraction of a second. Also known as "black-box" and "algorithmic" trading, it involves the programming of computers by "quants" (for quantitative analysts) to buy this or sell that in response to information--some market trend or piece of news--getting into and out of a stock faster than a human can click a mouse. These trades might make a fraction of a penny per share, but do that millions of times a day and it adds up to real money.

HFT has nothing to do with investing, as most people understand the word, even if it can have an impact on investors. The quants and their computers usually know nothing of company fundamentals--business models, management bios, balance sheets, and whatnot. They trade based solely on statistically informed instructions called algorithms. A successful HFT operation will make almost as many losing bets as winning bets, but the huge volumes involved can make even razor-thin margins profitable in the aggregate.

[Read: That Rumbling in Your Portfolio? It's Real.]

Once a marginal part of market activity, in the past five years HFT has grown to represent half to three-quarters of a typical day's trading volume, even if HFTs themselves represent only 2 percent or so of investors. Among the chief beneficiaries are brokers and dealers, who get a slice of each trade and cater increasingly to HFT clients. Most HFT shops are standalone affairs, like Red Bank, N.J.-based Tradeworx, while a few are arms of big institutions such as Goldman Sachs.

Whoever the players, the name of the game is speed, and the winners are the folks who get information a few milliseconds before the losers--i.e., the people with the fastest computers and the lowest "latency" (the time it takes to transmit data). As the game boils down to how fast electrons can travel, latency is becoming a function of "co-location"--setting up shop as close as physically possible to the exchange servers that are the source of raw price data. NYSE Euronext sells space at its Mahwah, N.J., "Liquidity Center" to HFT outfits.

Technology has thus created what many complain is a new class of insiders--those who can afford the computer systems necessary to monitor "order flow" a few milliseconds before the competition, and siphon off the profits that result.

Does any of this matter to a typical retail investor? Yes, in good ways and bad. The upside of what might look like a post-human, vaguely Orwellian battle between armies of robots is a sharp improvement in what market professionals call "liquidity"--essentially the ease with which you can buy and sell a stock. With so many securities flying in so many directions at such high speeds, it's a rare buyer who won't find a seller, and vice versa, on a typical trading day.

HFT has also slashed trading costs by more than half, by one reckoning. Brokers and dealers benefit anyway, because the huge expansion of volume offsets the decline in commissions.

And the downside? Critics say the whole objective of HFT is to secure an information advantage over everyone else. Never mind that in the perfectly efficient market that purists like to imagine there aren't supposed to be any informational advantages. They do exist, and spotting them can allow for "front running"--exploiting price movements that you know about in advance--and other forms of market manipulation. There's reason entrepreneur Mark Cuban famously called HFTs "the ultimate hackers."

[Read: Are You Vulnerable to Computerized Markets?]

But the bigger problem may be systemic risk, as exemplified by the "flash crash" of May 6, 2010, and the $440 million loss incurred by Knight Capital in August as the result of a software glitch. There is an analogy to be made between the argument over HFT and that other tiresome acronym, TBTF. Too-big-to-fail banks defend themselves by arguing that they offer efficiencies smaller banks can't. Even Alan Greenspan has dismissed that claim. But even if the banks are right, there's the question--posed by Republican presidential candidate Jon Huntsman, among others--of whether the cost of the systemic risk they pose exceeds the benefits of the efficiencies. Likewise with HFT.

To be sure, some argue that they do not increase systemic risk. The most prominent defender of HFT practices, Tradeworx CEO Manoj Narang, argued in 2010 comments to the Securities and Exchange Commission that in a pinch, HFTs--unlike longer-term investors-- can simply "turn off" their trading strategies and unwind their positions (something they effectively do at the close of each trading day anyway), "thereby eliminating any possibility of further losses" and immunizing them from the contagions that can afflict big quant firms. He also wrote that critics exaggerate the likelihood of "runaway algorithms" accelerating a meltdown, saying exchange rules and market regulations "eliminate most of the risk."

Narang concedes in emailed comments that "large orders executed algorithmically could pose a systemic risk if the technology is faulty, but this is not high-frequency trading. High-frequency traders hold small positions in their inventory and do not execute large trades." Flawed technology, he says, is what explains the flash crash, in which HFT "had at best a peripheral role." As for the Knight debacle, he says, "there was never any systemic risk to the stock market."

Maybe, but others argue that systemic risk is less a function of how HFTs actually operate and more about how markets perceive their activity, fairly or not.

[Read: October Sell-Off, Anyone? The S&P's 10 Worst Trading Days.]

"I don't think anyone believes that the default of an HFT would cause the international economy to collapse. That's not the point," says Wallace Turbeville, senior analyst at the progressive think tank Demos and author of a forthcoming study on HFTs. "HFT activity creates a perception of great liquidity in the market, but in fact HFT activity, because it's algorithmic, can switch from providing high levels of liquidity to consuming even higher levels of liquidity instantaneously. It's worse than no liquidity at all. If it can change by the flick of a switch, it's a very volatile situation."

In other words, HFTs enhance liquidity until they don't, and the uncertainty impedes investor confidence.

So, it could be that the market is in fact becoming an unpredictable casino rigged by the people who can buy the most computing power. Or it might be that investors are overreacting. As that eminent economist Stephen Colbert put it: "You destroy the global economy once, and everyone forgets all the times you didn't destroy it."



More From US News & World Report

--

Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
Loading...

Explore Related Contents

  • Hedge Funds Lose Bid to Quash Fannie, Freddie Profit Grab (3) Bloomberg - 1 hour 58 minutes ago

    Perry Capital LLC, the Fairholme Funds and other big investors lost a bid to overturn a judge’s ruling that said they can’t sue the government over the dividend change. The change known as the “net-worth sweep” forced the companies to send almost … More »

  • Vice Said to Hire Bankers to Raise Fund for Scripted Programs Bloomberg - 2 hours 1 minute ago

    Vice already produces a slew of unscripted shows, from a daily news update for HBO to programs about the culture of marijuana, gay and lesbian issues and food for its own cable network, Viceland. Vice also produces video for services like YouTube … More »

  • Sydney Morning Herald Owner Plans Property Listings Spinoff (1) Bloomberg - 2 hours 5 minutes ago

    Fairfax shares soared the most in three years after it said Domain Group could be listed in Australia by the end of 2017. A separate listing for Domain would put a market value on Fairfax’s biggest profit generator for the first time, while still … More »

  • Macquarie posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 2 hours 10 minutes ago

    The New York-based company said it had profit of 89 cents per share. The investment firm posted revenue of $437.2 million in the period. For the year, the company reported net income of $156.4 million, ... … More »

  • Invesco Mortgage Capital posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 2 hours 13 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Atlanta-based company said it had profit of $2.15. Earnings, adjusted for investment gains, came to 36 cents per share. The real estate investment trust posted revenue of $324.5 ... … More »

  • KAR Auction Services misses 4Q profit forecasts Associated Press - 2 hours 23 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Carmel, Indiana-based company said it had profit of 33 cents. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, were 45 cents per share. The results fell short of Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

  • Waste Connections beats Street 4Q forecasts Associated Press - 2 hours 25 minutes ago

    The Vaughan, Ontario-based company said it had profit of 49 cents per share. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, came to 68 cents per share. The results beat Wall Street expectations. The ... … More »

  • Morningstar posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 2 hours 29 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Chicago-based company said it had net income of $1.63. Earnings, adjusted for non-recurring gains, were 77 cents per share. The investment research firm posted revenue of $212.2 ... … More »

  • Terex reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 2 hours 30 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Westport, Connecticut-based company said it had a loss of $2.52. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, came to 7 cents per share. The results surpassed Wall Street ... … More »

  • Rates mixed at weekly US Treasury bill auction Associated Press - 2 hours 31 minutes ago

    Interest rates on short-term Treasury bills were mixed in Tuesday's auction, with rates on three-month bills declining, while rates on six-month bills rose to their highest level in more than eight years. ... … More »

  • Bsquare reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 2 hours 35 minutes ago

    The Bellevue, Washington-based company said it had a loss of 10 cents per share. The software and engineering services provider posted revenue of $26.8 million in the period. For the year, the company ... … More »

  • ARC Document Solutions posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 2 hours 39 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Walnut Creek, California-based company said it had profit of 6 cents. The provider of document services to businesses posted revenue of $85.9 million in the period. For the year, ... … More »

  • XPO tops 4Q profit forecasts Associated Press - 2 hours 47 minutes ago

    The Greenwich, Connecticut-based company said it had profit of 22 cents per share. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, were 24 cents per share. The results surpassed Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

  • QTS Realty reports 4Q results Associated Press - 2 hours 51 minutes ago

    The Overland Park, Kansas-based real estate investment trust said it had funds from operations of $35.4 million, or 64 cents per share, in the period. The average estimate of nine analysts surveyed by ... … More »

  • Business Highlights Associated Press - 2 hours 57 minutes ago

    ____ Deal hunger sends food stocks higher; US indexes at records Stocks again broke records Tuesday as investors came back from a long weekend hungry for deals. While Kraft Heinz and Unilever couldn't ... … More »

  • Whiting reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 2 hours 59 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Denver-based company said it had a loss of 59 cents. Losses, adjusted for non-recurring costs and asset impairment costs, were 28 cents per share. The results topped Wall Street ... … More »

  • Quad/Graphics posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    The Sussex, Wisconsin-based company said it had profit of 73 cents per share. The printing company posted revenue of $1.2 billion in the period. For the year, the company reported net income of $44.9 million, ... … More »

  • Global stocks hit record highs, dollar rises on rate-hike view
    Global stocks hit record highs, dollar rises on rate-hike view Reuters - 3 hours ago

    Stock prices across the world climbed to record highs on Tuesday on news euro zone business activity accelerated to a six-year high, while the dollar gained after hawkish comments from Federal Reserve officials. U.S. financial markets were closed … More »

  • Dasan Zhone reports 4Q loss Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    The Oakland, California-based company said it had a loss of 7 cents per share. The communications network equipment company posted revenue of $59.2 million in the period. For the year, the company reported ... … More »

  • Golden Star posts 4Q profit Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    The Toronto-based company said it had net income of 1 cent per share. The gold mining company posted revenue of $53.3 million in the period. For the year, the company reported that its loss narrowed to ... … More »

  • Bristol-Myers Rises After Report That Carl Icahn Owns Stake (1) Bloomberg - 3 hours ago

    Icahn owns a large stake, Dow Jones said, citing people familiar with the matter. It isn’t clear how large the holding is, the news agency said. The shares, which spiked after the report, pared some of the gains and closed up 0.4 percent to $54.78 … More »

  • World stocks mostly grind higher, but HSBC weighs
    World stocks mostly grind higher, but HSBC weighs AFP News - 3 hours ago

    World stocks regained momentum on Tuesday, lifted by rising oil prices and strong eurozone economic data, but a massive earnings drop at banking giant HSBC kept a lid on London and Hong Kong. … More »

  • First Solar Posts Biggest-Ever Loss as Revenue Slides 49% (1) Bloomberg - 3 hours ago

    The largest U.S. solar manufacturer’s fourth-quarter net loss was $719.9 million, or $6.92 a share, compared with net income of $164.1 million, or $1.60 a share, a year earlier, Tempe, Arizona-based First Solar said in a statement Tuesday. … More »

  • Yahoo price slashed as Verizon proceeds with buy
    Yahoo price slashed as Verizon proceeds with buy AFP News - 3 hours ago

    A price cut had Verizon on track Tuesday to go ahead with the purchase of Yahoo's internet business, and share the costs from a pair of epic hacks that threatened to derail the deal. Yahoo slashed the price of its core Internet business by $350 … More »

  • Uber CEO Apologizes for Company Culture After Harassment Claims Bloomberg - 3 hours ago

    (Bloomberg) -- At a meeting open to all Uber Technologies Inc. employees on Tuesday, Travis Kalanick apologized for cultural failings at his company after a former employee alleged she was harassed and discriminated against while working there. … More »

 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.

MARKET MOVERS

  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.24+0.01+4.35%
    N21.SI
    0.405+0.005+1.25%
    E5H.SI
    0.355+0.015+4.41%
    5ME.SI
    0.1060.0000.00%
    5WA.SI
    3.99+0.02+0.50%
    Z74.SI
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.128+0.017+15.32%
    UV1.SI
    0.49+0.03+6.52%
    AWV.SI
    1.31+0.07+5.65%
    5G3.SI
    0.395+0.025+6.76%
    R07.SI
    0.50+0.03+5.26%
    567.SI
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    0.54-0.08-12.90%
    AZA.SI
    0.11-0.01-8.33%
    RF7.SI
    0.405-0.030-6.90%
    N01.SI
    0.205-0.015-6.82%
    AXB.SI
    0.20-0.01-4.76%
    KJ5.SI

Market Data

  • Currencies
    Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1.4191-0.0015-0.10%
    USDSGD=X
    1.4969+0.0005+0.03%
    EURSGD=X
    1.7736+0.0016+0.09%
    GBPSGD=X
    80.0120+0.036+0.05%
    SGDJPY=X
    5.4672+0.006+0.11%
    SGDHKD=X
    3.1415+0.0042+0.13%
    SGDMYR=X
    9,444.3516-0.06350.00%
    SGDIDR=X
    4.8499+0.0068+0.14%
    SGDCNY=X
    1.0904+0.0004+0.04%
    AUDSGD=X
  • Commodities
    Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
    1,237.80-1.10-0.09%
    GCJ17.CMX
    18.000.00+0.02%
    SIH17.CMX
    91.73-0.83-0.89%
    ^XAU
    2.740.00-0.16%
    HGH17.CMX
    54.44+0.11+0.20%
    CLJ17.NYM
  • Bonds
    Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change
    1.92+0.01
    ^FVX
    2.430.00
    ^TNX
    3.04+0.01
    ^TYX