Convergence panel misses opportunity to make Singapore a media market leader

EVEN as South Korean sensation Park Jae-sang, better known by his stage name Psy, was preparing to perform for thousands at Marina Bay Sands, the local media industry seemed to be doing its best to rein in the free-wheeling Internet that shot him to unlikely stardom.

On Nov 28, the government-appointed Media Convergence Review Panel, comprising local broadcasting industry heavyweights StarHub, Singapore Telecommunications and MediaCorp, released a 65-page report that called for a tougher stance on digital media distributors and online piracy. "Local players are now increasingly exposed to overseas competitors who deliver content over the Internet, but are not subject to local regulatory obligations," the report says. "How do we rebalance the playing field?"

Among the principal recommendations of the panel, which also includes representatives from Google and Samsung Electronics as well as academics and consultants, is that foreign content providers must comply with local standards and regulations if they are targeting the local market. According to the report, copyright and digital piracy challenges can be tackled by blocking local access to the offending websites.

A day after the report was released, broadcast industry association CASBAA put the boot in with another report arguing that local consumers are turning to piracy despite having easy access to a wealth of affordable content. In fact, Singapore has the world's fifth-highest per capita infringement rate in terms of illegalof TV programmes, according to analysis from Media Partners Asia, an independent analyst firm, and MarkMonitor, which helps companies protect their revenues by monitoring illegal distribution of digital content.

CASBAA says rampant copyright infringements and piracy is no reflection of consumers' lack of legal access to the digital media content that they crave. It points, for instance, to the Season Pass offering by SingTel's pay-TV brand mio TV, which gives subscribers access to US TV shows 24 hours after the US telecast. Then, there is StarHub's just-launched TV Anywhere, which allows subscribers to watch content on their phones, tablets and PCs. Both SingTel and StarHub are members of CASBAA.

John Medeiros, chief policy officer of broadcast industry association CASBAA, figures that consumers in Asia are simply more inclined to download pirated content than consumers elsewhere in the world. "There's piracy everywhere, but I think the propensity to look for pirated sources of content is higher in Asian markets," he says.

Should these ideas and assumptions become the basis of regulatory policy, consumers in Singapore would be worse off. It would also do little to protect the interest of the artistes who produce the content. The only winners would be the local broadcasters and pay-TV players. And, even they would face an uphill battle as advancing technology makes bootleg TV content increasingly available.

Singapore is a tiny market for media content. So, it makes little sense to force foreign content providers to comply with local standards. Instead, the government ought to adopt a liberal, pro-innovation policy stance that enables local incumbents as well as foreign interlopers to competitively deliver content that local consumers want.

Choice and flexibility

Thanks to the lobbying efforts of media industry groups such as CASBAA, piracy is now widely accepted to be evil. Yet, why do ordinarily law-abiding people choose to download pirated content and visit illegal streaming sites?

The fact that the illegal content is free is only one reason. Another reason is that these sites fully empower consumers with choices. They can view content not available from the local incumbents and they can decide whether they want to view it on a PC, tablet or other device. They don't have to fill in forms, queue at a counter, pay installation charges for hardware they don't want or subscribe to an ancillary service they don't need.

Providers of legal content that similarly empower consumers are proving to be hugely popular, despite charging for content. Apple's­ iTunes is an example. You can find old seasons of popular TV dramas, choose to buy an episode or entire season, and watch your purchases on your TV, iPad, Mac or iPhone. There are no monthly fees. Amazon Instant Video, by, is another. It also offers a rental option. Not surprisingly, both services are popular in the US.

In fact, their offerings are so compelling that more and more Singapore consumers are willing to fork out an additional monthly fee, to a third party, for a virtual private network that will allow them to circumvent geographical restrictions and buy content from those platforms. Both Apple and Amazon are filling a void in the market for quality, paid content with choice and flexibility.

Learning from history

These players seem to have learned from history. At the turn of the century, the music industry fought hard to close down peer-to-peer (P2P) download services facilitated by Napster and Kazaa. While courts ruled in favour of the industry's big music companies, P2P music downloads continued to flourish for a long time because technology made it cheap and easy to build copycat services.

In the end, it was the music companies themselves that were forced to adapt by generating revenue from concert tickets, lowering the price of their music and — most importantly — embracing new methods of digital distribution. Where the option is available, music lovers have now largely given up P2P file sharing in favour of Apple's legal and paid-for iTunes.

In short, services such as Napster and Kazaa were innovative pioneers in music distribution that paved the way for the success of iTunes. Thanks to them and regardless of what the industry bigwigs say, consumers are better off now. And although Universal Media Group, one of the world's top three music companies, has seen its revenues fall over the last six years, great music is still being made and the artistes are still being rewarded with fame and fortune.

Now, Singapore ought to push its local broadcasters and pay-TV players towards an operating model that's winning the likes of Apple and Amazon global market share in the distribution of TV content. And, foreign players ought to be given more liberal access to the local market.

Will this more liberal policy route work in Singapore? What is the downside? Is there a risk in allowing disruptive technologies to flourish in the local media industry?

Fostering creativity

A key problem for the media industry is that Singapore is a relatively small market, says Medeiros of CASBAA. "You have 300 million people in the US and 5.3 million in Singapore. In the US, an operator like Amazon or Apple can launch an offering [that] costs a lot of money because of the infrastructure, but they can anticipate getting a certain number of subscriptions. Not only in Singapore, but in many of the Asian markets, because they are so fragmented, it's not easy to generate a business model that makes sense."

However, Singapore can improve its attractiveness as a market by liberalising its regulations and positioning itself as a test-bed for content providers such as Apple and Amazon that want to expand in Asia. While Singaporeans might download a large amount of content illegally, they aren't big originators of pirated content. In fact, they are eager adopters of legal online media services.

When iTunes finally launched its content library here this year, for instance, my Facebook feed was flooded with status updates from friends who were overjoyed that they would now be able to buy movies instead of having to download them illegally. Surely, that makes us an ideal focus group of sorts for new media providers to tweak and hone their Asian offerings.

One common problem they may encounter is consumers' or regulators' baulking at TV-content objectionable to the sensibilities of Asians. Indeed, it wasn't long after iTunes launched its content library in Singapore that it ran up against a regulatory roadblock over its distribution of movies rated R21 here. After the Media Development Authority contacted Apple, those videos were removed from the Singapore iTunes store.

Local pay-TV providers have since been allowed to distribute R21-rated content on their platforms. That's as long as they put in place publicity to educate consumers on the safeguards for R21 movies. In addition, they are allowed to offer only R21 titles that have been previously classified by the Board of Film Censors for commercial release. These titles are not available to corporate subscribers such as coffee shops, community clubs and hospitals.

Panel chairman Koh Boon Hwee says a consistent licensing framework for both traditional and new media platforms is "important to provide a level playing field for industry players while ensuring that their services are attuned to community norms and expectations". He also says in an email response to The Edge Singa­pore that "there is no presumption on the panel's part that this means that regulation will be tightened".

Yet, forcing foreign content providers to conform to a long list of regulations could result in Singapore's missing an opportunity to make itself a market leader. But, it's not too late.

Perhaps the lesson our small media industry can learn from Psy's meteoric rise is that underdogs have much to gain by embracing the Internet's permissive culture with creativity and ingenuity. Featuring catchy music and distinctive dance moves, his Gangnam Style music video has been copied, forwarded and shared as well as been the subject of numerous memes produced by YouTube users. It all probably involved some copyright infringement. But the pudgy South Korean, who performs in a language few people in the world actually understand, probably doesn't mind. By some estimates, his proverbial 15 minutes of fame will earn him some US$8 million this year.

This story first appeared in The Edge Singapore weekly edition of Dec 10-16, 2012.


Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
  • Yen higher as market eyes US politics AFP - 11 minutes ago

    The yen headed higher again Monday while the dollar slipped against the euro amid a paucity of economic news ahead of Donald Trump's presidential debate showdown against Hillary Clinton. The yen continued ... … More »

  • Fed wants more capital at largest banks
    Fed wants more capital at largest banks AFP News - 19 minutes ago

    Shares of the largest US banks fell Monday after the Federal Reserve's main regulator proposed higher capital requirements for them. Stress tests for the banks -- to see how they could ride out extreme crises -- indicated that the largest eight … More »

  • AP Top Extended Financial Headlines at 6:03 p.m. EDT Associated Press - 22 minutes ago

    Need a loan for a diamond ring or used car or wrench set … More »

  • US stocks slide as banks tumble on Deutsche Bank worries
    US stocks slide as banks tumble on Deutsche Bank worries Associated Press - 23 minutes ago

    U.S. stocks slumped Monday, and banks took the biggest losses. Deutsche Bank plunged as investors worried about the financial health of Germany's largest bank. Pfizer pulled drugmakers down after it announced ... … More »

  • How the Dow Jones industrial average fared on Monday Associated Press - 26 minutes ago

    U.S. stocks slumped Monday, and banks took the biggest losses. Deutsche Bank hit an all-time low as investors worried about the financial health of Germany's largest bank. Pfizer pulled drugmakers down ... … More »

  • Business Highlights Associated Press - 29 minutes ago

    ___ US stocks slide as banks tumble on Deutsche Bank worries U.S. stocks slumped Monday, and banks took the biggest losses. Deutsche Bank plunged as investors worried about the financial health of Germany's ... … More »

  • US stocks fall ahead of Trump-Clinton debate showdown AFP - 35 minutes ago

    Wall Street stocks tumbled Monday ahead of the first debate in the tightening US presidential campaign, and as worries about Deutsche Bank hit US financial stocks. US-traded shares of the embattled German ... … More »

  • Network security company ForeScout interviews banks for IPO: sources Reuters - 54 minutes ago

    ForeScout's IPO plans are a further sign of a rebound in the IPO market in the United States. The IPO could come later this year, the sources said, asking not to be identified because the matter is not public. A representative for ForeScout … More »

  • Anbang Said to Complete Most of $6.5 Billion U.S. Hotels Deal Bloomberg - 59 minutes ago

    It’s the second-largest U.S. acquisition by a Chinese buyer, after the $7 billion sale of Smithfield Foods Inc. to Shuanghui International Holdings Ltd. -- now known as WH Group Ltd. -- in 2013, according to data compiled by Bloomberg and New … More »

  • Wall Street drops as investors brace for presidential debate
    Wall Street drops as investors brace for presidential debate Reuters - 1 hour 8 minutes ago

    Big banks led the declines as investors worried that Deutsche Bank might need to add additional capital to pay for a $14 billion U.S. demand to settle claims it missold mortgage-backed securities. Its U.S.-listed shares fell 7.06 percent to a … More »

  • Lane says ECB has to continue with current monetary policy strategies
    Lane says ECB has to continue with current monetary policy strategies Reuters - 1 hour 22 minutes ago

    The European Central Bank must continue with its current strategies to lift inflation, but it will of course look at tools being pursued by other central banks including Japan's, governing council member Philip Lane said on Monday. "In Europe we … More »

  • Early China Indicators Signal Factory Pickup, Business Optimism Bloomberg - 1 hour 26 minutes ago

    Sales and production recovered from weather-related disruptions, even as the investment appetite remained muted, Shen Lan, a Beijing-based China economist, wrote in a report. The China Satellite Manufacturing Index jumped to 50.2 in the first weeks … More »

  • Oil ends up 3 percent as OPEC meets; volatility hits post-Doha high
    Oil ends up 3 percent as OPEC meets; volatility hits post-Doha high Reuters - 1 hour 51 minutes ago

    NEW YORK/LONDON (Reuters) - Oil settled up 3 percent on Monday as the world's largest producers gathered in Algeria to discuss ways to support prices, with nervous trade driving volatility to its highest since a similar meeting to freeze output in … More »

  • Russian bombers flying too close to airliners: Iceland AFP - 1 hour 59 minutes ago

    Iceland complained Monday that Russian air force bombers have been flying too close to civil airliners, the most recent incident involving a flight from Reykjavik. The Icelandic foreign ministry said three ... … More »

  • Synnex beats Street 3Q forecasts Associated Press - 2 hours 0 minutes ago

    On a per-share basis, the Fremont, California-based company said it had profit of $1.47. Earnings, adjusted for one-time gains and costs, came to $1.73 per share. The results surpassed Wall Street expectations. ... … More »

  • Global stocks wobble before U.S. debate, output deal hope lifts oil
    Global stocks wobble before U.S. debate, output deal hope lifts oil Reuters - 2 hours 1 minute ago

    By Richard Leong NEW YORK (Reuters) - Stock prices around the world fell on Monday ahead of the first U.S. presidential debate between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump, while oil prices rose in advance ... … More »

  • Markets Right Now: Banks lead a slump in US stocks Associated Press - 2 hours 12 minutes ago

    The latest on developments in global financial markets (all times local): 4:00 p.m. Banks led a broad decline on Wall Street as interest rates fell and the stock of a major German bank dropped sharply. ... … More »

  • MetLife Offers Staff Buyouts in Japan Amid Office Consolidation Bloomberg - 2 hours 15 minutes ago

    Non-sales employees who are 45 or older and have been with the insurer for at least three years will get as much as two years of monthly pay if they decide to leave, John Calagna, a spokesman for the New York-based company, said in an e-mail Monday. … More »

  • CBOE to buy BATS for $3.2 billion in latest exchange deal Reuters - 2 hours 16 minutes ago

    The deal values Bats, which went public just over five months ago at $22.88, at about $32.50 per share. Bats shares closed down 4.6 percent on Monday at $30.35 following a 19.9 percent rise on Friday on news of a potential deal. CBOE ended down … More »

  • Will boom in loans at retailers, manufacturers turn to bust?
    Will boom in loans at retailers, manufacturers turn to bust? Associated Press - 2 hours 22 minutes ago

    They sell diamond rings in malls and used cars at dealerships, make wrench sets for mechanics and giant combines for farmers. Not one has "bank" in its name, but they are all big lenders, and ... … More »

  • A step-by-step guide to fixing a scratch on your car
    A step-by-step guide to fixing a scratch on your car Business Insider - 2 hours 34 minutes ago

    Matthew DeBord/Business Insider When it was new — … Continued The post A step-by-step guide to fixing a scratch on your car appeared first on Business Insider. … More »

  • Oracle billionaire Larry Ellison is actually a much nicer guy than he gets credit for, people close to him say
    Oracle billionaire Larry Ellison is actually a much nicer guy than he gets credit for, people close to him say Business Insider - 2 hours 36 minutes ago

    Business Insider Oracle executive chairman and CTO Larry … Continued The post Oracle billionaire Larry Ellison is actually a much nicer guy than he gets credit for, people close to him say appeared first on Business Insider. … More »

  • Earth's climate past points to overheated future
    Earth's climate past points to overheated future AFP News - 2 hours 51 minutes ago

    Our planet may grow intolerably hot even if greenhouse gases in the atmosphere remain at current levels, according to the first two-million-year reconstruction of surface temperatures, published on Monday. "Stabilisation at today's greenhouse gas … More »

  • Grain lower, livestock lower Associated Press - 2 hours 51 minutes ago

    Grain futures were lower Monday on the Chicago Board of Trade. Wheat for Dec. fell 8.75 cents at $3.96 a bushel; Dec. corn lost 7.50 cents to 3.29 a bushel; Dec. oats was down 3.75 cents at $1.7325 a bushel; ... … More »

  • Youth has final word as Milan Fashion Week wraps up
    Youth has final word as Milan Fashion Week wraps up Associated Press - 3 hours ago

    Milan Fashion Week made way for young talent on the last day of preview shows for next spring and summer Monday. After Giorgio Armani ceded his usual spot anchoring the last day of fashion week this round, ... … More »

Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
to view quotes in your portfolios.


  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg

Market Data

  • Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change