Best Investment Strategy Interviews of 2012: Understanding Large-Cap Stocks Beyond GAAP Valuation with Portfolio Manager Rafael Resendes of Toreador Research and Trading



67 WALL STREET, New York - December 18, 2012 - The Wall Street Transcript has just published its Best Investment Strategy Interviews of 2012. The full issue is available by calling (212) 952-7433 or via The Wall Street Transcript Online.

Topics covered: Investment Strategies - Large Cap Investing - Investing in Emerging Markets - Investing in Energy - Value Investing - Downside Protection With Upside Participation - Macroeconomic Trends

Companies include: Apple Inc. (AAPL), Automatic Data Processing, Inc (ADP), Chevron Corp. (CVX), Ecolab Inc. (ECL), International Business Machine (IBM), McDonald's Corp. (MCD), Southern Company (SO), Exxon Mobil Corp. (XOM), Yum! Brands Inc. (YUM)

In the following excerpt from the Best Investment Strategy Interviews of 2012, an experienced portfolio manager discusses his investment methodology for large cap stocks:

We capture this through a proprietary concept we call Economic Margin Decay. If you study decay rates over time, and globally, it quickly becomes apparent that valuations based on multiples are just silly, and explains why so few firms and individuals consistently assign reasonable values to companies, and instead use coarse generalizations - such as growth firms or value firms - when in fact growth is required to understand value.

In the same way that Google has the best search algorithms, understanding intrinsic value is a unique advantage Toreador has over its competitors. This allows us to understand the future performance we are paying for a firm at any point in time.

For example in 2000, quality firms traded with very low future expectations embedded in their price relative to risky firms, and as the market became unstable and overvalued. We witnessed something similar in 2007, as Toreador moved to buy safety and held that position through much of 2011. In late 2011, our fund made a very explicit decision to trade out of safety. Going into 2011, we owned names like MCD (MCD), IBM (IBM), Clorox (CLX), Coca-Cola (KO), P&G (PG), and others that served us well through 2010. Essentially, you could go down the list, and we focused on firms that were considered to be safe - very stable cash flows, low leverage, big firms, multinational presences.

However, with the euro crises unfolding in 2011, these firms were consistently being overbought as everyone reached for safety, yields and low volatility. If you look at what happened last year, the top-performing firms versus the bottom-performing firms, the top-quartile firms returned about 26%, whereas the bottom-quartile performer returned a negative 30%. The top firms were roughly two to four times larger than the bottom-performing firms market-cap wise. Again, there was a clear reach for safety. The top firms were half as levered as the bottom-performing firms. Top firms' dividend yield was almost twice as much as the bottom-performing firms and the Economic Margin of the top firms exceeded the bottom ones by a factor of three, with a third of the volatility.

At the end of 2011, however, when we sat down and we spotted the value, we found that, on average, the typical firm in the safe group had to grow its sales for the next five years at about 14% a year to justify their valuation, and the question we asked is whether such performance is reasonable or not. If you look at these firms, on average, over the previous five years, they have only been able to grow at about 6.8% a year. In other words, right now, because of the reach for safety, these firms would have to grow at about more than double what they have been able to do historically, and to us, while these are great firms, they were just too expensive.

After the crash in August, we explicitly started investing in riskier cash flows as the market had unreasonably punished firms with these characteristics. For example, risky cash flow firms were priced to grow their top line at about 4% a year whereas, historically, they have been able to grow at about 10% a year. When stocks can beat their expectations built into their price, they tend to do very well, and when they can't, they tend to underperform. That's what we saw back in 2000 with the tech bubble, expectations exceeded reality and we witnessed the tech crash. We believe we were in a bubble for quality, and investors were significantly overreaching, and as a result, we restructured our portfolio to take advantage of this.

Some of the names that we own that I think are interesting are Bank of America (BAC). We made a big push into owning financials over Q4 of 2011. Bank of America is, I think, a really unique name in the sense of it probably has normalized earnings in the neighborhood of $2 a share. We expect that for 2012 it should earn maybe $1 a share. So in simple terms, has a p/e of 7.5 - after appreciating more than 30% this year - holding that constant with $2 of earnings, we believe investors will push its value to the low teens. Our estimate of its intrinsic value is approximately $15 a share, making it a wonderful buy-and-hold opportunity. We estimate the downside risk to Bank of America somewhere in the neighborhood of $6 if the market gets really jittery again. We see the upside at $15 plus. For us, 100% potential return with 20% downside even assuming 50/50 odds is a great investment vehicle. We actively search for those types of risk return opportunities, and as a consequence, we've made Bank of America the largest holding in our fund.

By the way, the financial sector is where we have the greatest percent of our funds allocated at the moment. We have about 28% of our fund allocated to financials, versus a market weight of 14%, primary focused on the global banks and life insurers such as MetLife (MET).

We believe the environment for financials is unique in the sense of offering what I call upside regulatory surprise. I think for the last three years, we've had a regulatory environment very hostile to financials from headlines to Washington's desire to capitalize on such sentiments. I think that environment will change. It is obvious an economic recovery will not reach its full potential with government at war with banks...

For more of this interview and many others visit the Wall Street Transcript - a unique service for investors and industry researchers - providing fresh commentary and insight through verbatim interviews with CEOs, portfolio managers and research analysts. This special issue is available by calling (212) 952-7433 or via The Wall Street Transcript Online.


Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
  • AP Top Extended Financial Headlines at 11:33 p.m. EDT Associated Press - 5 minutes ago

    Need a loan for a diamond ring or used car or wrench set … More »

  • Asian stocks mixed as traders follow US debate
    Asian stocks mixed as traders follow US debate Associated Press - 5 minutes ago

    Asian stock markets were mixed Tuesday as traders followed the U.S. presidential debate between candidates Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump. KEEPING SCORE: Hong Kong's Hang Seng index advanced 0.4 percent ... … More »

  • BRIEF-United Malacca reports monthly production data Reuters - 7 minutes ago

    Sept 27 (Reuters) - United Malacca Bhd : * Aug fresh fruit bunches 29,036 tonnes; Aug crude palm oil 5,989 tonnes; Aug palm kernel 1,392 tonnes Source text : ( ) Further company coverage:... … More »

  • China August industrial profits rise nearly 20 percent, fastest in three years
    China August industrial profits rise nearly 20 percent, fastest in three years Reuters - 16 minutes ago

    Profits earned by China's industrial firms in August grew at the fastest pace in three years helped by rising sales, higher prices and lower costs, pointing to strengthening economic activity. The world's second-largest economy has shown recent … More »

  • Asia stocks bounce, yen ebbs amid U.S. debate
    Asia stocks bounce, yen ebbs amid U.S. debate Reuters - 17 minutes ago

    Asian share markets recouped early losses on Tuesday and the dollar edged away from a one-month trough against the yen, suggesting investors judged Democrat Hillary Clinton was winning her debate against Republican Donald Trump. Markets have tended … More »

  • Gold slips as equities, dollar gain after US presidential debate
    Gold slips as equities, dollar gain after US presidential debate Reuters - 17 minutes ago

    Gold edged lower on Tuesday as equity markets bounced back and the U.S. dollar strengthened, hinting that investors viewed Democrat Hillary Clinton as the winner of her first U.S. presidential debate with Republican Donald Trump. Spot gold was … More »

  • China’s Shibor Climbs to Seven-Week High as PBOC Withdraws Funds Bloomberg - 29 minutes ago

    The one-month Shanghai Interbank Offered Rate climbed to 2.74 percent, the highest since Aug. 4, according to the National Interbank Funding Center. The People’s Bank of China has in the past month started to use 14- and 28-day reverse-repurchase … More »

  • Asia stocks bounce, yen ebbs amid U.S. presidential debate
    Asia stocks bounce, yen ebbs amid U.S. presidential debate Reuters - 35 minutes ago

    Asian shares recouped early losses on Tuesday and the dollar edged away from a one-month trough against the yen, suggesting investors judged Democrat Hillary Clinton was winning her debate against Republican Donald Trump. Markets have tended to see … More »

  • KWAP crosses out Airbnb potential Business Times - 37 minutes ago

    RETIREMENT Fund Inc (KWAP) has crossed off Airbnb, an online marketplace for property rental, as its second potential investment in a global digital company after pumping in US$30 million (RM123.8 million) in Uber Technologies Inc.  “We did look at … More »

  • UEM Edgenta to buy UEMS for RM563m Business Times - 37 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: UEM Edgenta Bhdis buying UEMS Pte Ltd for RM563 million to strengthen its healthcare services operations. UEMS is an established market leader, providing facilities management services to the healthcare sector. It serves more than 60 … More »

  • Good governance, leadership play key roles Business Times - 37 minutes ago

    MALAYSIA needs to keep its growth momentum going through good stewardship in terms of governance and leadership in order to further progress, said Khazanah Nasional Bhd managing director Tan Sri Azman Mokhtar. … More »

  • 'Khazanah firms to drive growth' Business Times - 38 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: Khazanah Nasional Bhd expects the continuation of a pro-growth and pro-society focus in the 2017 Budget, with its companies remaining the nation’s growth engines. Khazanah managing director Tan Sri Azman Mokhtar said at the same … More »

  • New concepts but Paris car show losing va-va-voom
    New concepts but Paris car show losing va-va-voom AFP News - 38 minutes ago

    The Paris Motor Show opens this week with promises of groundbreaking electric concept cars from Volkswagen and Opel, but the shine appears to be wearing off what was once a must event for the industry. Ford, Mazda, Volvo, Aston Martin, Bentley, … More »

  • China’s Long March to Rival Dollar Faces Obstacles After SDR (1) Bloomberg - 43 minutes ago

    The yuan will join the International Monetary Fund’s Special Drawing Rights this Saturday, marking a milestone in China’s efforts to build a currency that reflects the country’s economic and political sway. The SDR, created in 1969, gives IMF … More »

  • China Industrial Profits Jump Most in Three Years in August (1) Bloomberg - 49 minutes ago

    Industrial profits rose 19.5 percent in August from a year earlier to 534.8 billion yuan ($80.2 billion), the National Bureau of Statistics said Tuesday. "The pickup in industrial profit is driven by commodities prices and the property market boom, … More »

  • Tokyo stocks pare losses by break AFP - 53 minutes ago

    Tokyo shares pared their losses Tuesday morning as investors focus on the first US presidential candidates' debate. The benchmark Nikkei 225 index was down 0.33 percent, or 54.15 points, at 16,490.41 by ... … More »

  • Wall Street Shrinking in Asia Continues With Goldman, BofA Cuts Bloomberg - 56 minutes ago

    Bank of America plans to eliminate about a dozen senior positions at its corporate and investment-banking operations in Asia, the second time the U.S. firm is cutting jobs in the region this year, according to people with knowledge of the matter. … More »

  • China's Wanda in talks to buy Golden Globes producer
    China's Wanda in talks to buy Golden Globes producer AFP News - 1 hour 17 minutes ago

    Chinese conglomerate Wanda is considering ramping up its push into Hollywood with the acquisition of the production company behind the Golden Globes, the US firm said. Eldridge Industries, which controls Dick Clark Productions, said discussions to … More »

  • Asian Stocks Pare Losses as Clinton, Trump Spar in U.S. Debate Bloomberg - 1 hour 20 minutes ago

    The MSCI Asia Pacific Index fell 0.3 percent to 140.42 as of 10:51 a.m. in Tokyo after sliding as much as 0.9 percent earlier. While investors had became more risk-averse ahead of the U.S. debate, partly due to a rout in shares of Deutsche Bank AG, … More »

  • When deals go bad - China state firm managers spooked by new liability rules Reuters - 1 hour 33 minutes ago

    Business development managers at Chinese state-owned firms have been put on notice: mess up on M&A deals and you can be held personally liable - for life. Under new rules unveiled by China's State Council, or cabinet, last month, managers will be … More »

  • Asian Hunger for Yield Tested by Junk-Rated Casino Bond Plan (1) Bloomberg - 1 hour 35 minutes ago

    Imperial Pacific International Holdings Ltd. plans to sell dollar bonds for the first time to fund its casino resort in Saipan Island, a U.S. territory in the Pacific Ocean, according to a bond document. The bond is rated B1, four steps below … More »

  • U.S. Stock Futures Rise With Mexican Peso Amid Debate; Yen Falls Bloomberg - 1 hour 36 minutes ago

    With the first of three U.S. presidential debates taking place late Monday New York time, a Bloomberg poll showed Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton were tied in a head-to-head contest. “The peso started the debate near its weakest levels but at … More »

  • Clinton, Trump spar over plans for US economy AFP - 1 hour 36 minutes ago

    Hillary Clinton accused Donald Trump of peddling "trumped up trickle down" economics Monday on the presidential debate stage, as the candidates clashed in fiery exchanges over how to create American ... … More »

  • Nomura Sees More Europe Banks Boosting Defenses With Samurai (1) Bloomberg - 1 hour 41 minutes ago

    The London-based bank joined Standard Chartered Plc this month in selling yen bonds compliant with total loss-absorbing capacity, or TLAC rules, in a Samurai market where issuance is running at its lowest in four years. “Wherever you look, banks … More »

  • Ringgit opens lower against US Dollar Business Times - 1 hour 54 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: The ringgit closed lower against the US dollar today as investors remained cautious awaiting the outcome of the three-day Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) meeting in Algiers that began on Monday.At 9.02 am, the … More »

Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
to view quotes in your portfolios.


  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg

Market Data

  • Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change