Active Investment Management Misses The Mark

One of the most controversial subjects in the financial services industry is the issue surrounding the value of active investment management (AIM) in the secondary capital markets. The value of AIM has been debated by many investment professionals for more than a decade. While the results of the studies are mixed, a strong case has been made that investors should replace their actively managed investment products with products that rely on passive investment management (PIM) strategies. Let's take a look at the difference between AIM and PIM and see which type of investment strategy is most likely to offer you the opportunity to generate the highest risk-adjusted performance over time.

Active Vs. Passive Investment Management
AIM is an investment process that is used by investment professionals in order to assist them in making profitable investment decisions. AIM requires the use of time, resources, labor, knowledge and experience in order to assess the attractiveness of a company from an investment standpoint. Investors utilize AIM in order to select securities for addition to their portfolio, and to assist them in determining the appropriate weighting that each security should represent within their portfolio. In comparison, investors that utilize PIM strategies concentrate on the replication of the performance of a given benchmark proxy, such as the S&P 500 Index. The distinction between these two methodologies is significant, as PIM strategies ignore most of the traits that are typically believed to encompass high-quality investment analysis.

Given the differences between the two methodologies, a prudent investor may expect strategies based on AIM to outperform strategies based on PIM, especially over time. Ironically, most of the empirical evidence makes a strong case to the contrary. Given this conundrum, one must wonder how a passively managed investment product, such as an S&P 500 Index fund, is able to outperform a robust investment product that utilizes a prudent investment strategy such as AIM.

A partial answer to this question lies in the fact that PIM strategies require minimal resources to employ, and therefore have a significant structural advantage over higher cost investment options that utilize AIM. While this argument may be plausible, a significant case can also be made that the superiority of PIM strategies is attributed to the possibility that the secondary capital markets are informationally efficient, and therefore AIM strategies cannot add value when applied in this type of environment.

Capital Market Efficiency and the Secondary Capital Markets
When investors talk about efficient capital markets, they mean that the securities that trade in the markets have prices that accurately reflect all material information about their value in a real-time manner. Market efficiency does not mandate that stock prices will always reflect the correct per share value of a company. However, it does mean that security prices are accurately priced, and that any fluctuation in that price is unpredictable in terms of timing, frequency, magnitude and direction because the flow of information is unpredictable.

Factors That Mitigate the Value of Active Investment Management in the Secondary Capital Markets
There are four primary factors that promote market efficiency in the secondary capital markets.

  • The mission of the secondary capital markets
  • The prohibited use of material non-public information
  • The mandates set forth by Regulation Fair Disclosure (Reg FD)
  • The increase in passively managed assets under management
To begin, the goals of the secondary capital markets are to provide liquidity and transparency of trade completion. Given these goals, the mission of the secondary capital markets mandates that security prices are accurately priced. To explain, the secondary capital markets were created to allow companies to maintain long-term access to capital that they received through an initial public offering, while allowing investors that supplied the capital to have a market that will allow them to exit out of their investment in a timely manner with minimal price impact. Given this mission, it stands to reason that the secondary capital markets must maintain a level of efficiency in order to maintain investor confidence in the system. If this trust breaks down, the secondary capital markets will lose credibility and ultimately cease to function in a beneficial manner for both the management of the companies needing capital, and the investors that are willing to provide capital.

Second, for an AIM strategy to reliably add value in the secondary capital markets, the use of the strategy would have to uncover important information about a company that is currently not reflected in the price of the company's security. However, this type of information is typically known as material non-public information, and it is illegal for investors to buy or sell securities based on their access to this type of privileged information. A classic example of the prohibited use of material non-public information is the high profile insider trading violations that are routinely covered by the general media.

Third, in October 2000, the Securities and Exchange Commission implemented Reg FD. Reg FD mandates that material information about a company be disseminated in a timely manner to a wide audience of investors. It helps mandate transparency, and helps promote strong ethical standards in the secondary capital markets. However, it also hinders the ability of AIM to add value, because it minimizes the amount of time that investment professionals can capitalize on their knowledge of material public information. Moreover, Reg FD particularly hinders investors who want to make multiple purchases of a security over time, such as those that employ a dollar cost averaging strategy.

Finally, PIM strategies have gained significant popularity over the last decade, and many experts believe going forward there will be a greater shift to passively managed funds. Therefore, as a greater percentage of assets under management become passively managed, it will become more difficult for AIM strategies to add value, because more and more of the assets invested in the secondary capital markets will be invested according to PIM strategies, which largely ignore the factors that AIM strategies take into account when assessing the value of a security issued by a company.

The Bottom Line
In today's global economy, it is hard to fathom that a single investor, or even a large investment research team, will have enough time, knowledge, resources and skill to correctly foresee and assess all of the macro economic issues, micro economic issues, governmental issues, technological changes, legal issues and unique business risks in order to correctly determine the value of a company. Moreover, even if all of these issues can be accurately assessed, there is no way for an investor to gauge how other investors will assess all of this information, or how their assessment will affect their investment decision. Therefore, without this level of insight, it is impossible to know how the price of a security will change, the frequency with which its price will change, the magnitude of its price change, or the direction in which its price will change.

Given this level of unpredictability, one must consider the possibility that the secondary capital markets are indeed efficient, and that the employment of AIM in the secondary capital markets may very well be a noble, but futile endeavor.

More From Investopedia


Get stories like this on the Yahoo app and discover more every day.
Download it now.
  • Oil prices fall as Saudi Arabia dampens prospects of output freeze
    Oil prices fall as Saudi Arabia dampens prospects of output freeze Reuters - 8 minutes ago

    Oil fell on Friday and was set for its largest weekly decline in a month after the Saudi energy minister cooled expectations that top producers might agree next month to curb crude output levels. Brent crude oil futures were down 52 cents at $49.15 … More »

  • Kerry, Lavrov meet on Syria conflict
    Kerry, Lavrov meet on Syria conflict AFP News - 14 minutes ago

    US Secretary of State John Kerry and Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov met in Geneva on Friday for an expected push towards resuming peace talks for war-ravaged Syria. The pair sat down in a luxury hotel on the shores of Lake Geneva, launching … More »

  • Try chargeback request to get refunds, aviation commission tells Rayani Air's customers New Straits Times - 16 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: The Malaysian Aviation Commission (Mavcom) has advised Rayani Air’s customers who have purchased tickets using credit or debit card to initiate a chargeback request in order to recover their monies. The commission in a statement said … More »

  • European shares down as investors wait for US Fed cue
    European shares down as investors wait for US Fed cue Associated Press - 20 minutes ago

    European shares were mostly lower Friday following mixed trading in Asia, with investors preferring to sit on the sidelines ahead of U.S. Federal Reserve Chairwoman Janet Yellen's speech later in the day ... … More »

  • British economy escapes Brexit 'bomb', for now
    British economy escapes Brexit 'bomb', for now Reuters - 24 minutes ago

    Britain's high streets are heaving with shoppers despite June's shock vote to leave the European Union, big companies have reported few signs of distress and some tabloid newspapers are even talking about a post-Brexit economic boom. The … More »

  • AB InBev expects to cut 3 percent of jobs after SABMiller takeover Reuters - 27 minutes ago

    Anheuser-Busch InBev (ABI.BR) expects to cut some 3 percent of its combined workforce after it has acquired rival SABMiller (SAB.L), according to takeover documents published on Friday. AB InBev is aiming to achieve pre-tax savings of at least $1.4 … More »

  • Agricultural Bank Grinds Out 0.5% Profit Gain as Bad Loans Climb Bloomberg - 30 minutes ago

    While Xu Yiming, the chief financial officer of China Construction Bank Corp., told a briefing in Hong Kong on Friday that his bank was seeing less pressure from bad loans, Agricultural Bank Chairman Zhou Mubing told reporters in Beijing that the … More »

  • 11 Turkish police killed in bombing blamed on PKK
    11 Turkish police killed in bombing blamed on PKK AFP News - 44 minutes ago

    Eleven Turkish police officers were killed and 70 people injured Friday in a car bombing blamed on Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) rebels, as Turkey's army pressed an offensive against a Kurdish militia in neighbouring Syria. The early morning blast … More »

  • FTSE edges lower as pharmaceuticals weigh again
    FTSE edges lower as pharmaceuticals weigh again Reuters - 55 minutes ago

    By 0900 GMT, the FTSE 100 (.FTSE) was down 4.20 points, or 0.1 percent, at 6,812.70, down 0.7 percent for the week and set for a second straight weekly fall. Investors were awaiting a speech by Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen at a summit in … More »

  • Offshore Yuan Set for Second Weekly Drop as Fed Rate Odds Climb Bloomberg - 1 hour 5 minutes ago

    Wagers on higher Fed rates have been boosted this week as officials including Vice Chairman Stanley Fischer signaled that a 2016 rate increase is still under consideration, even as evidence of uneven global growth casts doubt over the U.S. central … More »

  • Dollar dips, shares touch two-week low before Yellen
    Dollar dips, shares touch two-week low before Yellen Reuters - 1 hour 6 minutes ago

    By Atul Prakash LONDON (Reuters) - The dollar edged down and global shares slipped to a two-week low on Friday as investors turned cautious before a keynote speech by Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen ... … More »

  • Hong Kong Tribunal Says Citron’s Left Culpable of Misconduct (1) Bloomberg - 1 hour 12 minutes ago

    The Market Misconduct Tribunal of Hong Kong said Friday that information in the Citron note was “false and/or misleading as to material facts or through omission of material facts,” and that as such Left was either “reckless” or “negligent” in … More »

  • Iran wants 'pre-sanctions oil market share'
    Iran wants 'pre-sanctions oil market share' AFP News - 1 hour 27 minutes ago

    Iran wants its pre-sanctions share of the crude market, Oil Minister Bijan Zanganeh said on Friday, dampening the prospects of agreement on an output freeze at an OPEC meeting next month. "Iran had no role in disrupting the stability of the oil … More »

  • Asia markets, dollar turn lower ahead of Yellen speech
    Asia markets, dollar turn lower ahead of Yellen speech AFP News - 1 hour 38 minutes ago

    Asian markets mostly drifted lower Friday while the dollar dipped, as investors waited on a speech later in the global day by Federal Reserve chief Janet Yellen. With few catalysts to drive business this week, Yellen's talk at the annual Jackson … More »

  • UBS trimming headcount in Paris by 15 jobs -source
    UBS trimming headcount in Paris by 15 jobs -source Reuters - 1 hour 40 minutes ago

    Swiss bank UBS (UBSG.S) is cutting about 15 investment banking jobs as it scales back its share trading business in Paris, a source familiar with the bank's plans said. The cuts, currently under negotiation, are on its share trading platform and at … More »

  • VTTI says suspends operations at Malaysia terminal after oil spill Reuters - 1 hour 58 minutes ago

    VTTI, the storage division of the world's largest oil trader Vitol, said on Friday it has suspended operations at its terminal in southern Malaysia after receiving a notice from the authorities following an oil spill. The spill occurred on … More »

  • Investor group rebukes Sports Direct, wants review of management Reuters - 2 hours 16 minutes ago

    An investor group whose members manage 850 billion pounds ($1.1 trillion) of UK equities has taken the unusual step of publicly rebuking the management of Sports Direct and calling for an independent review. The Investor Forum, which speaks for … More »

  • Tokyo stocks end lower, dealers await Yellen speech AFP - 2 hours 18 minutes ago

    Tokyo stocks ended the week in the red Friday as dealers awaited a speech by Federal Reserve chief Janet Yellen and after data showed Japan is still struggling in its battle to kickstart inflation. Many ... … More »

  • China Tightening Risk Seen Looming as Bonds, Property Surge (2) Bloomberg - 2 hours 21 minutes ago

    While economists aren’t predicting the central bank will raise benchmark lending rates anytime soon, there are signs that policy makers are looking to curb leverage in the debt and property markets. "The market’s liquidity right now is too big,” … More »

  • Bolivian deputy minister killed by miners
    Bolivian deputy minister killed by miners AFP News - 2 hours 34 minutes ago

    Bolivian miners kidnapped, tortured and beat to death a deputy minister who tried to negotiate with protesting workers on Thursday, in what the government condemned as a brutal murder. "All signs indicate that our deputy minister, Rodolfo Illanes, … More »

  • Singapore’s Air Quality Remains Unhealthy as Haze Worsens (1) Bloomberg - 2 hours 36 minutes ago

    Fire hotspots have appeared over Indonesia’s Sumatra island and West Kalimantan, where the Indonesian government said last week it deployed fire fighters. The number of hotspots is lower than 2015, when dry conditions from the El Nino weather … More »

  • World’s Biggest Pension Fund Loses $52 Billion in Stock Rout (1) Bloomberg - 2 hours 55 minutes ago

    (Bloomberg) -- The world’s biggest pension fund posted a $52 billion loss last quarter as stocks tumbled and the yen surged, wiping out all investment gains since it overhauled its strategy by boosting shares and cutting bonds. … More »

  • Restaurant Group to sell or shut 33 sites Reuters - 3 hours ago

    (Reuters) - Britain's Restaurant Group (RTN.L), the struggling owner of the Joe's Kitchen chain, said it identified 33 underperforming sites for sale or closure as a part of its ongoing strategy review ... … More »

  • Asia stocks wary, dollar slips before Fed Chair Yellen's speech
    Asia stocks wary, dollar slips before Fed Chair Yellen's speech Reuters - 3 hours ago

    SINGAPORE/TOKYO (Reuters) - Asian stocks were largely steady on Friday, with modest losses in some markets and gains in others reflecting nervousness before a keenly anticipated speech by U.S. Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen. European markets … More »

  • Oil prices dip, Saudis dampen hopes on output talks AFP - 3 hours ago

    Oil prices dipped in Asia on Friday after Saudi Arabia's oil minister cast doubt on the need to cut output, denting hopes for a deal at talks next month aimed at addressing a global supply glut. The commodity ... … More »

Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
to view quotes in your portfolios.


  • Most Actives
    Most Actives
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Gainers
    % Gainers
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • % Losers
    % Losers
    NamePriceChange% Chg

Market Data

  • Currencies
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Commodities
    NamePriceChange% Chg
  • Bonds
    TreasuryYield (%)Yield Change