Daily Ticker

‘Too Big to Fail’: Breaking Up Big Banks Is NOT the Answer, Former Regulator Says

Follow The Daily Ticker on Facebook here!

The 2008 financial crisis pushed the global economy to the brink of collapse and exposed major flaws in the financial system. Four years later, most observers agree policymakers whiffed on addressing one of the major causes of the crisis: The difficulty of dealing with financial institutions so large they are considered -- by regulators, the Street and the firms themselves -- as 'too big to fail' (TBTF).

"The TBTF institutions that amplified and prolonged the recent financial crisis remain a hindrance to full economic recovery and to the very ideal of American capitalism," Dallas Fed President Richard Fisher wrote last week. "It is imperative that we end TBTF. In my view, downsizing the behemoths over time into institutions that can be prudently managed and regulated across borders is the only appropriate policy response."

Fisher's comments prefaced the Dallas Fed's annual report entitled Choosing the Road to Prosperity: Why We Must End Too Big to Fail — Now, which notes (among other things) that the five largest institutions control more than half of the U.S. banking industry assets and the top 10 account for 61% of commercial banking assets vs. 26% 20 years ago.

In addition, the report argues that the Dodd-Frank financial reform legislation "may actually perpetuate an already dangerous trend of increasing banking industry concentration."

In the accompanying video, I discuss the 'too big to fail' issue with James R. Barth a senior fellow at the Milken Institute who has co-authored his own report on the big banks.

Big Banks? No Problem

While Barth agrees with the Dallas Fed about Dodd-Frank being a flawed response to the 2008 crisis, he comes to a very different conclusion when it comes to the issue of 'too big to fail.'

"The problem is not size per se. Big banks are not really the problem," according to Barth who is also the co-author of a new book Guardians of Finance: Making Regulators Work for Us. "The problem is excessively risky activities in which banks engage and banks that operate with too little capital."

Indeed, there is a strong case to be made that the 2004 "Bear Stearns Rule" -- which exempted firms with a market cap above $5 billion from rules capping leverage at 12-to-1 -- was a bigger cause of the financial crisis than the repeal of Glass-Steagall in 1999, which triggered a huge wave of industry consolidation and the rise of mega-firms.

Barth, a former chief economist of the Office of Thrift Supervision, further argues the true cause of the 2008 crisis was a failure of the regulators, not the size of the banks.

"If regulator authorities would do their jobs and make sure banks don't engage in excessively risky activities and operate with sufficient capital then we wouldn't have had as serious a problem as we did just a few years ago," he says.

Barth certainly has a point but there is a fundamental flaw in this logic: allowing banks to grow so large in the first place enabled them to amass the resources and power necessary to "capture" regulators and win passage of industry-friendly reforms, like the repeal of Glass-Steagall, as well as lobbying to prevent Dodd-Frank from being more restrictive on the banking industry.

Aaron Task is the host of The Daily Ticker. You can follow him on Twitter at @aarontask or email him at altask@yahoo.com

  • Canada approves $36 bn LNG project, eyes Asia
    Canada approves $36 bn LNG project, eyes Asia AFP News - 6 minutes ago

    Canada approved a massive Can$36 billion ($27 billion USD) project by Malaysia's Petronas to build a liquefied natural gas pipeline along its Pacific Northwest coast, targeting Asian markets. The project is the first deal by Canada's year-old … More »

  • Oil climbs after industry data shows U.S. inventory draw
    Oil climbs after industry data shows U.S. inventory draw Reuters - 7 minutes ago

    Oil prices rose in mixed trading on Wednesday, after sharp losses in the previous session, as industry data showed a surprise draw in U.S. crude stocks, although worries over a lack of agreement among producers to curb output kept a lid on gains. … More »

  • Engineer Smiths Group posts fall in underlying FY revenue Reuters - 11 minutes ago

    (Reuters) - British engineering conglomerate Smiths Group Plc said underlying full-year revenue fell nearly 2 percent on a decline in sales at one of its biggest units. Revenue for the year ended July ... … More »

  • Canada approves $8 bln LNG plant, but Petronas to review project Business Times - 21 minutes ago

    RICHMOND/ KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia’s Petronas said on Wednesday that it would review a proposed C$11 billion ($8.3 billion) liquefied natural gas plant in western Canada that was approved by Ottawa following a three-year wait. Many analysts are … More »

  • Dollar holds up as traders await Fed rate hike clues AFP - 23 minutes ago

    The dollar held up Wednesday as investors awaited fresh clues about the Federal Reserve's plans for interest rates, after the first US presidential debate lifted the greenback. A report on demand for durable ... … More »

  • Travel firm TUI Group nudges up full-year profit outlook Reuters - 25 minutes ago

    LONDON (Reuters) - TUI Group, Europe's largest tour operator, said it expected 2015/16 core profit to rise by between 12 and 13 percent, upgrading an earlier forecast for growth of at least 10 percent, ... … More »

  • Bursa Msia signs licensing agreement with KL Tin Market Business Times - 34 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: Bursa Malaysia Derivatives (BMD) today signed a licensing agreement with Kuala Lumpur Tin Market (KLTM) to develop and manage an alternative futures tin trading, the Futures Tin Market (FTIN) contract.At the signing ceremony here … More »

  • After promising start, Rolls-Royce boss East must deliver Reuters - 41 minutes ago

    Rolls-Royce boss Warren East has rebuilt confidence in the British engine-maker, but there are doubts among investors and industry experts about whether his slimmed-down group has the muscle to meet ambitious production and development goals. It … More »

  • Price comparison platform Priceza gets Series B from Germany’s Hubert Burda Media
    Price comparison platform Priceza gets Series B from Germany’s Hubert Burda Media e27 - 42 minutes ago

    Priceza operates in six countries, including Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore and Vietnam, with over 13 million monthly visitors Priceza, a shopping search engine and price comparison platform in Southeast Asia, has secured … More »

  • Trikomsel Says Indonesian Court to Review Debt Workout Plan Bloomberg - 1 hour 3 minutes ago

    A Jakarta commercial court had decided on Sept. 26 to postpone a deliberation meeting, the firm said in a filing to the Singapore stock exchange. Applications by trustees for note holders to vote in the meeting were rejected because there was no … More »

  • China's PSBC makes tepid debut on Hong Kong bourse
    China's PSBC makes tepid debut on Hong Kong bourse AFP News - 1 hour 5 minutes ago

    Postal Savings Bank of China (PSBC) made a low-key debut on the Hong Kong bourse Wednesday, despite notching up the world's biggest IPO in two years aimed at expanding the business. China's fifth-biggest lender raked in a colossal $7.4 billion in … More »

  • How a Part-Time Actor Got the Lead Role at $2.7 Billion Fund (2) Bloomberg - 1 hour 6 minutes ago

    Sawakami saw a spark and later offered him a job. “He’s a rascal,” Sawakami said in an interview, using an affectionate Japanese term that parents reserve for headstrong children. Kusakari is a rare example of a person in Japan who diverged from a … More »

  • BCM Alliance aims to raise RM16.01m from IPO Business Times - 1 hour 16 minutes ago

    KUALA LUMPUR: Commercial laundry equipment and medical devices equipment distributor BCM Alliance Bhd, which is en route to list on the ACE Market of Bursa Malaysia Securities Bhd, expects to raise RM16.01 million from its initial public offering … More »

  • Japan steel industry sees China merger promoting structural reform Reuters - 1 hour 19 minutes ago

    China's Baosteel Group's acquisition of Wuhan Steel will create stronger leadership in the country's steel industry and promote structural reform, the chairman of the Japan Iron and Steel Federation said on Wednesday. "We welcome the move as the … More »

  • Asia stocks edge down on Europe bank woes, lower oil
    Asia stocks edge down on Europe bank woes, lower oil Reuters - 1 hour 26 minutes ago

    Asian stocks were lower on Wednesday, with European banking sector concerns and lower crude oil prices dulling investors' appetite for riskier assets. Equities in Asia had gained on Tuesday from a perceived win by Democrat Hillary Clinton at the … More »

  • Malaysia's ranking drops to 25: WEF Business Times - 1 hour 33 minutes ago

    BERLIN: Malaysia was ranked 25th among the 138 economies in the latest annual World Economic Forum's Global Competitiveness Report. The drop by seven places from 18th in 2015 was due to a decline in scores in eight of the indicators in the 12 … More »

  • Asian Stocks Fall as Tokyo Shares Decline, Oil Drops Below $45 Bloomberg - 1 hour 45 minutes ago

    The Topix index dropped 1.7 percent, the most in two-and-a-half weeks, as more than half the companies on the benchmark traded without the right to the next dividend, a biannual event in Japan that typically sends the market lower to reflect the … More »

  • Toshiba More Than Doubles Profit Outlook as Yen Drives Sales (2) Bloomberg - 1 hour 46 minutes ago

    Toshiba, which makes everything from computers to nuclear power equipment, in August reported its first operating profit in six quarters. “Apple’s recent upgrades to its smartphone embedded memory have also helped Toshiba’s cause,” Amir Anvarzadeh, … More »

  • Gold hits one-week low as dollar firms
    Gold hits one-week low as dollar firms Reuters - 1 hour 49 minutes ago

    Gold inched lower on Wednesday to touch a one-week low, after suffering its biggest single-day loss in nearly a month in the previous session, on a firmer dollar. The safe haven asset slid nearly 1 percent on Tuesday, its biggest single session … More »

  • SE Asia Stocks-Vietnam hits 8-1/2-year high; Philippines up Reuters - 1 hour 52 minutes ago

    By Suhail Hassan Bhat Sept 28 (Reuters) - Vietnam shares hit an eight-and-a-half-year high on Wednesday, led by commercial banks, while Philippine stocks rose after three sessions of falls with financials ... … More »

  • Two Goldman Sachs Asia Partners Said in Discussions to Leave (1) Bloomberg - 2 hours 1 minute ago

    Asia Pacific Investment Banking Solutions head Anthony Miller is planning to depart the bank after 15 years with the firm, and Michael Smith, head of Southeast Asia and another Goldman partner, is also in talks about leaving, the people said, asking … More »

  • Toshiba revises up first half forecast on solid memory chip sales
    Toshiba revises up first half forecast on solid memory chip sales Reuters - 2 hours 16 minutes ago

    Japan's Toshiba Corp said on Wednesday it expects to post a bigger first-half profit than previously forecast as memory chip prices have climbed on rising demand for smartphones. A Toshiba spokesman said that the upward revision mainly reflects … More »

  • Oil stages weak rebound as hopes ease for output deal AFP - 2 hours 29 minutes ago

    Oil prices posted marginal gains in Asia Wednesday as an industry report showing a decline in US stockpiles was offset by worries about the chances of this week's key producers meeting ending with a deal ... … More »

  • Abe Clashes With New Opposition Leader Over BOJ Inflation Policy Bloomberg - 2 hours 31 minutes ago

    Renho, the leader of the main opposition Democratic Party, described the new framework from the central bank on Sept. 21 as an admission that the limits of monetary policy were being reached. Abe said he would continue to work closely with the … More »

  • The World's Most Innovative Universities - 2016
    The World's Most Innovative Universities - 2016 Reuters - 2 hours 37 minutes ago

    No university does that better than Stanford University, which once again tops the Reuters 100. Decade after decade, Stanford’s students and faculty consistently innovate. Companies founded by Stanford alumni – including Hewlett Packard and Google … More »

Editors' Picks

Subscribe and RSS

[X]

How to subscribe

Roll over each section to subscribe using Add to My Yahoo or RSS Feed feeds.

Yahoo News offers dozens of RSS feeds you can read on My Yahoo or using a third-party RSS news reader software. Click here to find out more about RSS and how you can use it with Yahoo News.
 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.